4 ms·
There are currently a lot of ways for multinational companies to reduce their tax burden to near zero by for example Microsoft allocating most of their European
by tim333 7y ago
There are currently a lot of ways for multinational companies to reduce their tax burden to near zero by for example Microsoft allocating most of their European profits to a DVD stamping plant in Ireland which had a near zero rate at the time. Also they are kind of expected to maximise shareholder value by taking advantage of such legal avoidance schemes.
The proper way to stop this is for counties to make anti avoidance laws.
I recall a fuss in the press over Google along the lines of
"Using dubious tactics dubbed the 'Double Irish' and the 'Dutch Sandwich', Google apparently was able to pay only 3.2 per cent in tax on its overseas profits in 2011 even though most of its sales were in countries with tax rates from 26 to 34 per cent,"
and Google's CEO said
"We pay lots of taxes; we pay them in the legally prescribed ways,” he told Bloomberg. “I am very proud of the structure that we set up. We did it based on the incentives that the governments offered us to operate."
And basically if the governments want more tax they have to pass appropriate tax laws:
"If the British system changes the tax laws, then we will comply. If the taxes go up, we will pay more, if they go down, we will pay less. That is a political decision for the democracy that is the United Kingdom."
Which is kind of what Spain is trying to do.
- sbacic 7y ago> The proper way to stop this is for counties to make anti avoidance laws. You mean tax evasion, not tax avoidance, right? Last time I checked, avoidance was legal, evasion was not. If you actually did mean tax avoidance, then I must point out how dangerous the idea of somebody arbitrarily deciding what _legal_ option is okay or isn't okay on a case by case basis. I'd much rather have some things reclassified as tax evasion rather than having a "just trust us" system in place that decides when something is legal or not.
- pjc50 7y agoNo, we really do mean a "general anti-avoidance rule" (GAAR e.g. https://www.gov.uk/government/collections/tax-avoidance-general-anti-abuse-rule-gaar https://www.gov.uk/government/collections/tax-avoidance-gene...), because otherwise you end up in an endless loop of adjusting the rules against moving targets. GAARs ultimately boil down to the question of "did you do this rather than a more obvious transaction structure simply to pay less tax", a sort of Occam's razor. > dangerous the idea of somebody arbitrarily deciding what _legal_ option is okay or isn't okay on a case by case basis. This happens all the time in precedent-based systems whenever something unclear is litigated. In some sense it's what the legal system is for, and it's the very opposite of arbitrary.
- sbacic 7y ago> GAARs ultimately boil down to the question of "did you do this rather than a more obvious transaction structure simply to pay less tax", a sort of Occam's razor. Okay, so it is a "just trust us" system of deciding who is breaking the law and who isn't. In that case, I'll gladly take multinationals not paying taxes over some government official arbitrarily deciding that I am avoiding taxes and should be punished. Even more so because I live in a country where that same official might be untrained, apathetic or downright corrupt. > This happens all the time in precedent-based systems whenever something unclear is litigated. Which, AFAIK, the European system is not.
- pjc50 7y agoIt is not arbitrary. If you're in a corrupt system, you're vulnerable even if you have followed the rules. GAAR systems generally have a set of best practices, and if you disagree with the result you have access to the court system (not "a government official") to work it out.
- sbacic 7y ago> ...if you disagree with the result you have access to the court system (not "a government official") to work it out. You also have access to the court in case of actual tax evasion, though I assume the odds would not exactly be in your favor. My whole point is that you're better off avoiding the whole ordeal in the first place and that having large multinationals and governments playing whack-a-mole over the tax system is an acceptable price to pay.
- tim333 7y agoBy anti avoidance laws I mean laws to prevent the legal avoidance by some means. For example to prevent Microsoft allocating its profits to a DVD stamping plant in a tax haven you could make a law requiring the taxes to be paid where most value was created or some such.