4 ms·
Zero corporate tax would lead to a lot of avoidance and drops in government revenue. Say you are a consultant earning 100k a year who owns a house. You could ju
by tim333 7y ago
Zero corporate tax would lead to a lot of avoidance and drops in government revenue. Say you are a consultant earning 100k a year who owns a house. You could just pay the 100k to your company and borrow against the house for living costs and pay zero tax for the time being.
- rb808 7y agoRight but eventually they money has to get from the company to the consultant - either dividends or wages. Either way it'll be taxed.
- beefield 7y agoYep. Eventually. Meanwhile Buffett's tax rate on his (and his companies) income is within the distance of epsilon from zero. Can you estimate when Buffett is going to need the bulk of the money from his compankes to buy a new house? How long heis going to have approximately zero tax rate, that is? My personal estimate is with a very good approximation 'never'.
- s1artibartfast 7y agoAs long as berkshire hathaway is paying capital gains on every investment, why would you care if the money stays invested in the company?
- mrep 7y agoBuffet pays capital gains taxes and most economists who argue for dropping the corporate income tax only recommend so with an increase in income/cap gains taxes or even merging them.
- tim333 7y agoYeah maybe eventually. Though people try to find loopholes eg. move abroad, transfer the money offshore, lend the money to the consultant from the company rather than paying him or her, send the money to a company owned by an opaque offshore trust and so on. Big industries spring up to facilitate the avoidance that lobby politicians to allow the loopholes and so on. It can get kind of messy.
- jhall1468 7y agoLiterally everything you mentioned isn't a loophole, it's tax fraud. Tax loopholes are what they do within a single jurisdiction to avoid taxes. What you're suggesting is transferring money from one jurisdiction to another, which can't be done tax-free.
- tim333 7y agoOn example under UK law is if you work abroad for a year and deemed non UK tax resident then you could receive income tax free during that period. The K2 scheme that Jimmy Carr took part in got a lot of coverage https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/K2_(tax_scheme) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/K2_(tax_scheme)
- leakybit 7y agoOnly if they needed the cash, or else the corporation would be a vehicle to store wealth.
- tonyedgecombe 7y agoYou could do this now, leave your profits in the corporation and borrow against the balance. I don't think it would work though, compound interest accumulating on the loan would soon eat the gains.
- nybble41 7y agoSo don't let the interest accumulate. Taxes on the income needed to cover the interest wouldn't be all that high compared to taxes on the full amount of the loan. Or the loan can just be interest-free, but then you pay tax on the foregone interest as if it were income.
- AnthonyMouse 7y ago> Zero corporate tax would lead to a lot of avoidance and drops in government revenue. Say you are a consultant earning 100k a year who owns a house. You could just pay the 100k to your company and borrow against the house for living costs and pay zero tax for the time being. The issue is that you can already do this by using a corporation incorporated in a jurisdiction with no (or lower) corporate income tax -- which is what international companies and billionaires do and it gives them an unfair advantage, so we should level the playing field. Meanwhile notice what you're really doing -- you pay no income tax only because you have no income. But that only works as long as you never want to spend the money. Which works great for Apple, because they don't have anything to spend the money on anyway, but they're already doing that. The consultant making $100K is going to have to choose between spending the money (and so paying the tax on it) or taking a vow of poverty, because you have no equity to borrow against if it wasn't already at some point taxable income, and once you've spent that you still want to eat.
- spacehome 7y ago> Which works great for Apple, because they don't have anything to spend the money on anyway Not true. Apple spends boatloads of money on dividends and share repurchases. Apple doesn't pay taxes on that, but shareholders do.
- prepend 7y agoAs an employee, you would pay taxes on the benefit of getting a free house from your company. How will you pay back the loan without income? Company you will pay you income that is taxed. Eventually the company sells the house and pays taxes. It might defer taxes, but won’t avoid them.