4 ms·
This is just a personal opinion, but I don't think that anyone should be sentenced to a term in prison longer than 20 years. I should also say that I was/am th
by youdontknowtho 7y ago
This is just a personal opinion, but I don't think that anyone should be sentenced to a term in prison longer than 20 years.
I should also say that I was/am the victim of a crime that, while I wouldn't feel comfortable talking about it here, would normally get someone the death penalty.
The primary reason that I don't support the death penalty is that I don't think that the state can be trusted to kill people humanely. It took me years to come around to this, but I also believe that it isn't punishment. It's revenge.
The reason that I don't support terms longer than 20 years is that, no matter how uncomfortable it is to think about it, its abuse is more horrifying than the crime. Our prison system is barbaric.
Google "California prison gladiator" and tell me that Abu Ghraib was a bunch of bad apples. Prisons produce that kind of abuse systematically.
No matter how bad a crime committed by a single individual is, an institution that that produces the outcomes like those that out prison system creates is worse.
Where I'm from, the prison system has a legacy that is intrinsically tied up to the slavery of the pre-civil war era. Some southern states even have prisons on the grounds of former slave plantations.
In fact one of the things that most american's don't know is that slavery is not prohibited by the constitution. The amendment that banned slavery left a clause in place for prison inmates. This is particularly grotesque because they are still counted for the purposes of determining representation in congress based on population.
Also, prison guard unions aren't prohibited from lobbying state or federal government to pass longer sentences. Never mind for-profit prisons, even prisons run by government aren't free from commercial pressures to keep prisons full.
I'm intimately aware of how horrible crime can be, but prisons do not stop crime.
- SolaceQuantum 7y ago"Some southern states even have prisons on the grounds of former slave plantations." To increase the horror of this- some southern states have prisons on the grounds of former slave planations, whose majority black prison population works the field of said plantations for less than a dollar an hour.
- dragonwriter 7y agoThat's not exactly just a horrific coincidence; the prison labor system was adopted as a direct continuation of slavery in the immediate aftermath of the Civil War, exploiting the explicit exception for penal slavery in the 13th Amendment.
- rland 7y agoAre you in the US? Not to discount your situation, but you'd need to be murdered for it to be a capital offense here.
- youdontknowtho 7y agoYes, I'm in the US, and yes, it was a murder. It was someone very close to me and the situation is one that I would rather not go into. I get it. I didn't get murdered. That's not the only way that someone is victimized by the violent death of someone they love. Again, there's more to it than I'm going to go into here, so if you could just cut me some linguistic slack I would appreciate it. EDIT: I hope this doesn't sound overly aggressive. It wasn't intended to be.
- rland 7y agoAh, that makes sense. I probably shouldnt've even raised that point.
- youdontknowtho 7y agoNah, you're good. Cheers.