4 ms·
The theory is two sides produce the absolute most convincing argument they can, and an independent arbiter - the jury - decides between the two arguments. As bo
by michaelt 7y ago
The theory is two sides produce the absolute most convincing argument they can, and an independent arbiter - the jury - decides between the two arguments. As both sides can freely choose their representatives, they can change if their guy isn't doing a good job. And as the jury has heard the strongest possible arguments, they've heard all the information the two sides believe they need.
If you're accused of being gay in 1880, a randomly selected truth-seeking arbiter might be very anti-gay as that was the median opinion in society at the time - or even subject to political pressure. Only by having free choice of who represents you can you get someone who isn't biased against you.
Of course, that's only the theory. How well it works in practice, particularly with under-funded public defenders, is a different matter!
- WilliamEdward 7y agoThere are so many holes in this theory it is no wonder it doesn't work at all in practise
- tenpies 7y agoGood news then, we use competing systems to determine a solution in several facets of society (e.g. politics at every level, almost everything related to countries, governance in the public and private sectors). The minute someone comes up with a better system with less "holes" it will be quite the human revolution.
- jellicle 7y agoThere are different systems in use today. In many other countries, judges/prosecutors are charged with much more of a "figure out the true facts of what happened; do justice" role than they are in the US system. https://definitions.uslegal.com/i/inquisitorial-system/ https://definitions.uslegal.com/i/inquisitorial-system/
- rootusrootus 7y agoIs there evidence to suggest that those systems are more effective at finding the truth, or delivering justice?
- WilliamEdward 7y agoThat is a subjective question. I would argue things like paying for lawyers, paying your court fees even if you win (US system), and bail, cannot be an effective way to achieve true justice because they are all biased towards the rich.
- WilliamEdward 7y agoSurely you don't think there is no better or even alternative system to the trainwreck that is the US justice system? I'm not arguing to get rid of courts i'm arguing to change the way they are run. I don't see how this needs to be a revolutionary idea.
- viklove 7y agoWhat makes you characterize the US justice system as a "trainwreck?" Also, which existing justice system would you point to as a better example?
- nemetroid 7y ago> The theory is two sides produce the absolute most convincing argument they can It's clearly not the absolute most convincing argument, seeing as the US legal system has rules regarding the admissibility of evidence, which may disqualify certain arguments.
- Sean1708 7y agoIt's like free market capitalism applied to the legal system.
- NohatCoder 7y agoThe police is supposed to be a neutral party in this system, I believe a lot of these failures stem from the police failing this role.