5 ms·
"There is always an infinite range of possible states of nature" Well, I think that is definitely and unambiguously false. The universe is not infinite, nor in
by perl4ever 7y ago
"There is always an infinite range of possible states of nature"
Well, I think that is definitely and unambiguously false. The universe is not infinite, nor infinitely divisible, as far as we know, and the number of future states of any particular person (or humanity) are even smaller than those of the universe. Limits in time mean limits in space, and limits in space mean limits in particles and possibilities.
I'm not sure I can make a case that it matters, but if it doesn't matter, why say infinite?
- jbay808 7y agoI guess this is a tangent. First of all my point really doesn't hinge on the infinity; it can be finite (but really big) but regardless, whenever you apply minmax you must first crop your decision space to a probability threshold, or else you'll make nonsensical decisions based on what gives the best outcome if the sun should happen to explode. But secondly, I think (although I'd happily concede if convinced otherwise) that the space of possible scenarios really is infinite, even if the observable universe is not. The space I'm talking about is not the actual state space of the universe, which in some interpretations of physics might be finite or even unitary. It spans the space of hypothetical universes that are all consistent with your information with nonzero probability, which I think is probably infinite, but again, if it's not infinite that's a technicality. If you include the states that have with zero probability (because why not? GGP was advocating that the probability is irrelevant to minmax decisions) then the space is definitely infinite, because even physically impossible states of nature will impact our decision making.
- brownbat 7y agoAnother way to conceptualize the "cropping" is to get rid of all future states where planning would have been meaningless anyway. We are momentary Boltzmann brains? We'll assume not, because if so, nothing really matters. Trivial difference, but that avoids potentially difficult threshold problems and cousins of the St. Petersburg paradox or even Pascal's mugger, at the risk of being slightly more hand wavy. Arguably an aesthetic distinction at this point, I generally think your description and approach are right.
- 6gvONxR4sf7o 7y ago>Well, I think that is definitely and unambiguously false. The universe is not infinite, nor infinitely divisible, as far as we know... This seems wrong. We don't know whether the universe is infinitely divisible. See this for a nice discussion: https://physics.stackexchange.com/questions/33273/is-spacetime-discrete-or-continuous https://physics.stackexchange.com/questions/33273/is-spaceti...
- perl4ever 7y agoI think it's sophistry to pretend we haven't any more idea of that since pre-Democritus. Thousands of years of science has shown that infinities are always a problem in our heads, with our theories. Does that prove they don't exist? No more than it's proven that the sun will come up tomorrow, I guess.
- krastanov 7y agoThere are plenty of examples of inifinities that are not problematic. Infinitely small wavelengths make our current understanding of physics break down, indeed. Or maybe infinitely divisible solids that lead to paradoxes like Banach-Tarski's. On the other hand, infinitely dimensional configuration spaces or continuous parameterization (e.g. coordinates, field strengths, phases) are trivial unoffensive parts of classical and quantum mechanics.
- jbay808 7y agoJust to be clear why this whole conversation thread is a TypeError, let's say I assign a probability of 99.9% to the hypothesis that the state space of the universe is finite, and 0.1% to the state space of the universe being infinite... ... In that case, how big is my hypothesis space about possible states of the universe?
- sooheon 7y agoIf you had a blog of thoughts along these lines I’d subscribe.