7 ms·
Through the snow as if on rails
- bradknowles 7y agoCongratulations! Porsche has discovered the concept of putting an electronic motor into each wheel, and what that can do for them with regards to stability control.
- bognition 7y agoIt’s more than that. They’ve implemented a system that’s is capable of responding in real time.
- CarVac 7y agoAnd without any additional sensors. This is a control theory problem: creating an observer, a model of the state of an unmeasurable quantity that you want to control, from limited data indirectly related to what you want, and using that to make control outputs, in a stable manner.
- cialowicz 7y agoI'm not sure that not adding additional sensors counts as impressive. Cars are already laden with all sorts of telemetry gathering sensors: ABS/speed at each individual wheel, steering angle sensor, accelerometers, temp and moisture sensors, etc.
- blunte 7y agoOnce you reach the limits of friction, and then some external factor surprises you (such as a little bump in the pavement which briefly lightens your car, resulting in newly greatly reduced friction), what will the great technology do to compensate? I can tell you - for a brief period, its compensation will have minimal benefit. But meanwhile, your momentum will happily carry you on in the direction you were traveling when you hit that bump.
- saagarjha 7y agoLike ABS?
- jbott 7y ago"Real time" in a mechanical system is pretty generous compared to electrical systems. Changes are in the timescale of 1 to 100 hz compared to the kHz (or even MHz) switching speeds of many electrical systems. Once you switch away from the large rotating mass of an engine (+ drivetrain), you get pretty much instantaneous torque response on an electric motor for free. I'd say it's more interesting that they were able to figure out the delta between driver intent and physical response without adding any sensors. Having that much flexibility in the firmware of multiple control units (probably collaborating between several vendors) was likely a more complex challenge.
- vvanders 7y agoThis is a basic property of any 3-phase AC VFD motor, it's hard to see what's special here compared to a traditional electric drivetrain.
- secabeen 7y agoHub or in-wheel motors have significant engineering challenges from the increase unsprung weight inside the wheels.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- byron_fast 7y agoThat is one expensive Subaru.
- ur-whale 7y agoPics or it didn't happen.
- jonplackett 7y agoC’mon! Video please, Porsche.
- trhway 7y ago>There was also an additional challenge: The driving characteristics had to be optimized exclusively through software. The Porsche engineers could not install any additional sensors and had to use the existing control devices. The task, in short, was essentially driving stability by app. sounds almost like 737 MAX. Though of course it is just a common chewing sound of "software eating the world".
- blunte 7y agoNot at all. The 737 Max added new, larger engines which had to be located more forward of the wing, leading to very different thrust balance characteristics compared to the previous models. The new software was made to try to prevent a pitch up change caused by too much thrust forward of the center of gravity.
- alamortsubite 7y agoIn the '70's, Porsche unabashedly made cars that earned the nickname "widowmaker." Now it's bragging that in the near future a driver (user?) will be able to mash their car's throttle mid-corner with total impunity. Off the top of my head I can't think of another car company that's had such a weird trajectory. It's disappointing the new technology is unlikely to help Porsche users stop any faster, because the need for them to do so could be a side affect of their finally feeling secure when turning.
- detaro 7y agoPartially it's different markets: In SUVs these things are seen differently. Partially I think it's a general change in attitude, and one I think is mirrored in other sports car makers too: They all have various kinds of stability features, and options to control how it balances between strict control and "fun" behavior (you can't necessarily turn it of entirely anymore, and for a vehicle with individually driven wheels the concept of "non-assisted" doesn't even make sense)
- blunte 7y agoWhen the Porsche 959 came out, it was likely the most technologically advanced performance road car available (well, not likely... certainly). The performance numbers and vehicle stats were fantastic, and the look was arguably good for that time. But there was one common complaint: it was boring. The car was so well engineered that it could be a very manageable daily driver, or it could go set lap records with an average driver. In other words, there was little risk, and equally little reward. Now you have Teslas with straight line performance that even stupid Dodge "muscle" cars can't match, at least for speeds even remotely within some legal limit. Since most drivers are ill equipped to drive a slow car well, it's quite scary to imagine them driving cars with the current performance characteristics. So yeah, give them more go fast tech and watch what happens! Unless we develop some new stop-faster tech that greatly improves on the current situation, there will just be more accidents.
- darksaints 7y ago> Now it's bragging that in the near future a driver (user?) will be able to mash their car's throttle mid-corner with total impunity. Funnily enough, that's exactly what you're supposed to do in a Porsche (assuming it is a rear engine 911). Unlike most cars, 911s will understeer (or correct an oversteer) when you mash the throttle, and oversteer when you lift off the throttle. The reason they're called widowmakers is that the oversteer/understeer dynamics are the exact opposite from what you would expect. Think you're going too fast into that turn? If you slow down, you're dead, but if you speed up, you'll survive. It's also why crazy adrenaline junkies love them so much...in some senses, they're actually safer when you push them hard than they are when you try to be careful.
- blunte 7y agoHah. I don't care how good your software and individual wheel control is - if even in the perfectly optimized situation you exceed the friction limits of all four wheels, you will slide. And if your software will not allow wheels to slide, then you will have reduced braking. Either way, you won't stop nearly as quickly as you want. What people fail to realize, particularly in slippery conditions, is that it's often much easier to gain speed than to shed it. Modern traction control systems make it more (too) easy to gain speed without equally making it easy to shed speed.
- kerpele 7y agoExactly. I remember a few years ago I came across an article on a major car website that ranked four wheel drive as more important in winter conditions than proper winter tires. I personally don’t care if accelerating takes a little longer as long as I’m able to steer and stop, but I guess everyone has their own preference.
- kenhwang 7y agoI think it's because you can add better tires to car with 4WD if you determine you need it. You can't add 4WD/AWD to a car with winter tires.
- deschutes 7y agoTires are the dominant factor in my experience. (In deep snow ground clearance is also a significant factor.) Many videos [1], [2] on youtube corrobrate this. For the non-professional drivers on public roads, AWD is not a safety feature. It's arguably dangerous as it gives false confidence as you exceed the limits of your equipment. It does provide a convenience at low speeds (e.g. parking lots and driveways) as it makes it more difficult to get stuck but even there tires and ground clearance are the dominant factors. [1]: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EC1E2eDt1JY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EC1E2eDt1JY [2]: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iXjzYbpt9Ow https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iXjzYbpt9Ow
- toomuchtodo 7y ago
- hcurtiss 7y agoPretty tough to overcome momentum absent friction.
- blunte 7y agoI suspect some readers didn't get your accurate but brief comment. I'll expand it :). Regardless of technology, once the limits of friction are surpassed, there's no current technology to save you from your momentum. And furthermore, moving the max capable speed upward with technology just means that when something unforeseen or accidental occurs, it now has a multiplied effect.
- blattimwind 7y agoTaking a corner at 80 km/h on a snowy road seems like an interesting proposition overall.
- kempbellt 7y agoEasy. Just generate a small, but dense planet-sized mass opposite the direction of momentum, then terminate its existence once momentum has ceased. Don't break earth or the space-time continuum in the process though - you might agitate stockholders. Seriously though, physics is physics. Software can do a lot, but it can't do magic.
- Animats 7y agoIt's basically ABS, but with more "vroom".
- vvanders 7y agoCongrats, Porsche has discovered the 3-phase AC VFD. The same technology that has been used for decades in diesel electric locomotives. It's well known that it has fantastic anti-slip properties. I'll have to dig up the source but in the transition from DC->AC in rail engines there was a massive increase in traction. The inherent principal of a 3-phase motor means that it will naturally resist overspeed(in the same way EV regen works) unless the VFD drives it faster. [edit] I remembered right, the improvement is on the order of 100% over DC[1] [1] https://www.republiclocomotive.com/ac-traction-vs-dc-traction.html https://www.republiclocomotive.com/ac-traction-vs-dc-tractio...
- kenhwang 7y agoI'm curious which company hired Porsche Engineering for this. Porsche wouldn't hesitate adding more sensors for their own vehicles.