3 ms·
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Internment https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Internment points out that internment "is the imprisonment of people, commonly in large g
by eesmith 7y ago
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Internment https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Internment points out that internment "is the imprisonment of people, commonly in large groups, without charges or intent to file charges, and thus no trial. ... Interned persons may be held in prisons or in facilities known as internment camps, also known as concentration camps."
It then quotes The American Heritage Dictionary's definition of concentration camp as: "A camp where persons are confined, usually without hearings and typically under harsh conditions, often as a result of their membership in a group which the government has identified as dangerous or undesirable."
Ergo, prisons which only contain people who have been convicted in a trial or agreed to a plea bargain cannot be regarded as concentration camps.
By comparison, the US held Japanese Americans in concentration camps during WWII, and held Filipino civilians in concentration camps ("reconcentrados") during the Philippine–American War. These can be distinguished from prisons as there was no trial for those held.
As I understand it, if the people being held at ICE are asylum seekers, then entry into the US is not illegal (even if they are not granted asylum). The US instead argues that they can be detained until that process is finished, even if that is indefinite.
This certainly sounds a lot closer to the definition of a concentration camp than US prisons containing prisoners who have be convicted in a court process.
In any case, we're talking about people in an organization which argued that the requirement for "safe and sanitary" conditions was so vague that it was okay to refuse toothbrushes, soap or adequate bedding to children.
Are all US juvenile prisons the same way? No. The 'typically under harsh conditions' is yet another distinction between "concentration camp" and "prison".
That said, many US jails and prisons are horrid, inhumane places.
"No one truly knows a nation until one has been inside its jails. A nation should not be judged by how it treats its highest citizens but its lowest ones." - Nelson Mandela in Long Walk to Freedom.
- LiNeXT 7y ago> As I understand it, if the people being held at ICE are asylum seekers, then entry into the US is not illegal (even if they are not granted asylum). This is not true.
- eesmith 7y agoCould you clarify what is not true?
- LiNeXT 7y agoIllegal entry doesn't suddenly become legal just because you file an asylum claim.
- eesmith 7y agoThanks. I looked into it. It seems that crossing the border not at a port of entry is a misdemeanor offense and typically results in "only" a few days in jail. I was confusing that with the US law which says that the asylum process does not require entry at a designated port of arrival. > Any alien who is physically present in the United States or who arrives in the United States (whether or not at a designated port of arrival and including an alien who is brought to the United States after having been interdicted in international or United States waters), irrespective of such alien's status, may apply for asylum in accordance with this section or, where applicable, section 1225(b) of this title. - https://uscode.house.gov/view.xhtml?req=granuleid%3AUSC-prelim-title8-section1158&num=0&edition=prelim https://uscode.house.gov/view.xhtml?req=granuleid%3AUSC-prel... Since the people are being held for more than a few days, and not as a result of a judgement or plea bargain done over a misdemeanor offense, then "illegal" in the context seems more like a red herring. It's like saying that most people are illegal drivers, because few have never exceeded the speed limit.
- leereeves 7y agoBy those definitions, detention facilities where people await their asylum hearings are also not concentration camps. And the people in detention are free to leave if they wish, they're just not free to remain in the US without a hearing. As for the harsh conditions, I completely agree they should be improved. But that would require funding that the Democrats refuse to provide, and services from other companies that Democrats like these activists are trying to block.
- eesmith 7y agoYou earlier wrote "If ICE facilities qualify as concentration camps, then so does every prison." How many prisons are there where the people in detention are free to leave? That is, isn't your current statement at odds with your previous statement? Were the Japanese-Americans in the American West during WWII free to leave, and if so, what would happen if they were found in the exclusion zone? That is, do you think those were internment camps?
- leereeves 7y ago> isn't your current statement at odds with your previous statement? Not at all. As you've correctly shown, prisons are closer to being concentration camps than ICE detention facilities are. Therefore, if you move the definition far enough to include ICE facilities, you also include prisons.
- eesmith 7y agoAt most you can infer that I said that some prisons are closer to being concentration camps. However, you wrote "every prison", which is a much stronger statement and one that has no basis in fact. Again I ask, were Japanese-Americans in the American West held in concentration camps during WWII, or not? Many of the Japanese-Americans who were there have long fought to have those facilities (correctly, IMO) recognized as concentration camps, and high-level officials at the time, including Roosevelt, referred to them as concentration camps. Do you disagree with them? Were the Japanese-Americans in the American West during WWII free to leave those facilities, and if so, what would happen if they were found in the exclusion zone?