3 ms·
There is a certain intellectual laziness in this perspective as might be expected from a short blog post - obviously Bayes' formula is theoretically sound becau
by roenxi 7y ago
There is a certain intellectual laziness in this perspective as might be expected from a short blog post - obviously Bayes' formula is theoretically sound because it is trivial to deduce and prove.
So we know that if the conclusion is not acceptable then either the method, the prior or the evidence is not acceptable. Evidence and method can be ruled out; so the prior was not reasonable.
Basically, he's saying that he doesn't believe the prior is flat. A reasonable thing to say too - as he says practically speaking if we suspect the distribution is probably random noise then the prior is we are probably looking at noise. So in practice the prior is heavily weighted towards 0. It isn't intellectually honest to use an uniformed prior unless you think the probability of a process being statistical noise is almost 0.
- 6gvONxR4sf7o 7y ago>obviously Bayes' formula is theoretically sound because it is trivial to deduce and prove. Quantum mechanics doesn't follow the usual probability rules, so you can't really say "obviously Bayes' formula is theoretically sound." It certainly seems like Bayes theorem should apply universally but apparently it doesn't. Or at least, the jury's still out. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quantum_probability https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quantum_probability