5 ms·
No, I think that this makes sense. Failing open would make the DRM useless if you could trick the client into thinking the contract was expired. OTOH, SecuROM
by jchw 7y ago
No, I think that this makes sense. Failing open would make the DRM useless if you could trick the client into thinking the contract was expired.
OTOH, SecuROM is also “securing” their software from modifications, so if it were to fail open, it would still at least be working to keep binary integrity and obfuscation working; obviously SecuROM does not want to offer this for free.
In my mind the correct action would be for the developers to release a patch that removes SecuROM. Similar was often done for other games that had CD based authentication; it was often removed years after original release, which makes sense to do after the pirates have long compromised the security. I think it makes just as much sense for online authentication for a game this old.
Aside: I am trying to avoid injecting my personal opinions about DRM here since they aren’t relevant, but just to be clear I am not trying to express sympathy or support for either party. This is amazingly dumb in my opinion.
- munk-a 7y agoI think personal opinions are quite relevant here, legally speaking the law is clear and we've all got a problem with that - concurrently, legally speaking any game you've got through steam is a leased copy so if steam revoked your ability to play it tonight you wouldn't have a clear legal way to challenge them (unless the game is a subscription and they continue to collect that fee)
- jchw 7y agoWell, from SecuROM’s perspective I think everything makes sense. Personally I think the responsibility should fall on the developers to ensure that people who paid for something can access it. Consumer protection really hasn’t caught up here. Desperately need it to, imo.
- andrecarini 7y agoRegardless of the EULA, there are legal arguments [1] to be made that Steam's games are goods, not services, and buyers whose games are remotely disabled due to auth servers being shut off should be entitled to either a refund, a reasonable patch to keep the game working locally or have a clear expiration date stamped on the storefront since day one. This recent French court's ruling [2] indirectly supports this interpretation. [1]: https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=tUAX0gnZ3Nw https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=tUAX0gnZ3Nw [2]: https://www.rockpapershotgun.com/2019/09/19/steam-should-let-users-resell-games-french-court-rules/ https://www.rockpapershotgun.com/2019/09/19/steam-should-let...
- BlueTemplar 7y agoOk, so it seems to be that : 2012 EU ruling : "software is a good that can be resold" 2014 German ruling : "games are not just software, but also "art"(?), they can NOT be resold" https://www.rockpapershotgun.com/2014/02/10/german-court-rules-against-rights-to-resell-steam-games/ https://www.rockpapershotgun.com/2014/02/10/german-court-rul... 2019 French court ruling : "Steam accounts are just software(?), they can be resold" https://www.nextinpact.com/news/108209-ufc-que-choisir-vs-valve-justice-consacre-vente-doccasion-jeux-dematerialises.htm https://www.nextinpact.com/news/108209-ufc-que-choisir-vs-va...
- paulie_a 7y agoMeanwhile you can just torrent the cracked version without inSecureROM with much less effort and no time limit. Piracy: it's cheaper and easier. If a company puts up too many roadblocks. Fuck them. There are zero legal consequences for doing so
- sukilot 7y ago> Failing open would make the DRM useless if you could trick the client into thinking the contract was expired. That's the DRM's problem to solve. Paying customers shouldn't have their stuff stolen because someone else might be a non-paying customer.
- jchw 7y agoReally, I think it falls on the company that chose to license DRM in the first place. Unfortunately, there’s nothing compelling vendors legally speaking that I’m aware of, but there damn well should be. I also think unavailability due to DRM downtime or issues should have ramifications, as well.
- BlueTemplar 7y ago... and then these games were put on Steam, and Steam's (optional!) DRMs were added to them...
- mlyle 7y ago> Failing open would make the DRM useless if you could trick the client into thinking the contract was expired. Depends on the kind of failure. You could have failure-to-reach-SecuROM fail closed, but you could have publisher-no-longer-has-a-license-with-SecuROM fail open (serverside at SecuROM). The latter is probably better from SecuROM's standpoint: it makes end-users less likely to avoid SecuROM protected content. On the other hand, it doesn't make end-users scream at their customers that have failed to renew.