3 ms·
What about if you also can't be prosecuted or convicted for it?
by openasocket 7y ago
What about if you also can't be prosecuted or convicted for it?
- throwaway894345 7y agoIllegal immigration is a prosecutable offense replete with fines and prison sentences. As I understand it, a judge hears the cases and can sentence an individual to deportation, fines, or prison time depending on the defendant's circumstances. IANAL. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Immigration_and_Nationality_Act_of_1965 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Immigration_and_Nationality_Ac...
- openasocket 7y agoI recommend reading up on Turcios v. INS and Akinmade v. INS. Both cases of refugees who lied to Customs and used false documents, and the court determined that is valid if fleeing persecution to seek asylum.
- throwaway894345 7y agoIt would indeed be really interesting to understand how the court was able to rationalize that; INA is pretty explicit. In any case, I doubt typical "illegal immigration" can be meaningfully described as "fleeing persecution", and I say that with an abundance of sympathy for those garden variety illegal immigrants.
- LiNeXT 7y agoThey didn't rationalize that because that's not what those cases were about. See my other reply to OP.
- LiNeXT 7y agoThis is completely wrong. The court determined no such thing in either one of those cases. Both of these are cases in which the Ninth Circuit disagreed with findings made by the Board of Immigration Appeals in denying asylum relief and reversed said decisions. Insofar as passports/documents are referenced, it is in relation to testimonial credibility. Those decisions do not endorse or in any way legalize the use of false documents or the commission of illegal entry. (Also, ninth circuit court holdings are only applicable in the ninth circuit.)