3 ms·
> Microsoft has started adding short life VMs. No idea if that's good. The lightweight sandbox VMs seem to be pretty useful so far. It's still so new that I've
by WorldMaker 7y ago
> Microsoft has started adding short life VMs. No idea if that's good.
The lightweight sandbox VMs seem to be pretty useful so far. It's still so new that I've not seen it used outside of blog posts yet, but that's the nature of cutting edge features only "just" released. (It was released with 1903 in May, which was delayed several months and a lot of businesses still are hesitant to install it.)
Windows 10 has had Controlled Folder Access (aka Ransomware Protection) available as an option for a while as well, which acts like Apple's system of forcing apps to need additional permissions to user directories. It's not quite as fine-grained as Apple's yet, and it is certainly not on by default.
(I turned it on for interesting paranoia reasons on my gaming desktop, and it's been fascinating to watch what gets blocked. Though my paranoia led me to adding Steam folders to the Controlled Folders list, which has especially made it a permissions whack-a-mole because Game Developers are children and games access random folders all the time, use five EXEs where one probably should have been enough, use random EXEs in TEMP folders to call EXEs in Steam folders, games not installed by Steam sometimes try to access Steam folders, NVidia wants to touch everything, etc.)
> Both MS and Apple offer their App stores with more locked down experiences though I'm sad they conflate app security and app markets.
Windows 10 has had sideloading on by default for years now, and supports Win32 apps inside APPX/MSIX. Win32 apps by default aren't nearly as sandboxed sadly (because it is hard to guarantee Win32 apps work as expected when sandboxed), but some sandboxing is better than none. The biggest issue seems a lot less to do with "app market" (you don't have to publish to the Microsoft Store, and MSIX even supports auto-updating for sideloaded apps vaguely "ClickOnce-style") and a lot more to do with "please rebuild your installer to something more modern", which is a hurdle a lot of developers don't want to overcome. (Because installers are terrible and once one is built who wants to rebuild it. Because MSIX support for Windows 7 is still "Beta" with the April end-of-support for Windows 7 looming over everything, and some Enterprises clutching their Windows 7 purses as the new XP...) Who wants extra app security when it means a lot of development effort to repackage your app? (Even if it can be semi-automated from your existing installer.)