4 ms·
UAC interrupts you, which is bad. UAC thinks that a thing happening is so important you need to acknowledge it. Everybody's going to learn to click past. I'm t
by tialaramex 7y ago
UAC interrupts you, which is bad. UAC thinks that a thing happening is so important you need to acknowledge it. Everybody's going to learn to click past.
I'm talking about notifications not interruptions. At most a toast message, much more likely just a small indicator lights up. Not a big deal - when you'd expect it.
Think about the turn indicator on the dashboard of your car. When you indicate one way or the other a lamp illuminates, on and off, sympathetic to (and in older models directly run by the same relays as) the external turn lamps. But it doesn't ask you to confirm. "Are you really turning Left? Yes/ No" and since you're expecting it you hardly notice. But, imagine you're on the highway and suddenly that lamp illuminates for no apparent reason. That's weird right? You might be too busy to do anything about it immediately, but you'd now be concerned that perhaps there's a problem. Good!
That's what I'm talking about. Yes, out of a million users whose key got abused, maybe 90% of them weren't looking at the screen when it happened and 90% of those left were too busy or didn't understand why it was strange, and 90% of those who noticed never actually investigated and 90% those who investigated give up without notifying anyone about this weird phenomenon... you've still got a hundred users complaining about the problem.
It's not a solution, but it's a warning system.
- rtpg 7y agoPeople act like UAC leads to banner blindness but I don't think that really holds up. In the mobile space you get prompts for soooo many things, and loads of people see "ask for location data" and say no when they think it shouldn't be used! The system works!
- MadWombat 7y ago> and loads of people see "ask for location data" and say no Do you have any non-anecdotal evidence for this?
- rtpg 7y agoplural of anecdote is data :) I see loads of articles about people talking around permissions. Much much more than for tools on desktop computers. I believe that the higher visibility makes people noticing much more likely. Of course the hypothetical "don't care" person won't notice.... but definitionally they won't ever notice! I think it's fairly undisputed that the little lights on webcams that are on when the camera is enabled has totally worked, and the location service blue bar on iOS has worked well too IMO.