7 ms·
> I strongly agree. Web developers and app designers should work to build fast, performant web sites that use bandwidth carefully because that's good for end us
by izacus 7y ago
> I strongly agree. Web developers and app designers should work to build fast, performant web sites that use bandwidth carefully because that's good for end users.
They should, but they didn't. Before AMP most of the web was unusable on slower Android phones and frontenders just laughed at you and told you to drop 800$ on an iPhone if you want to see their pages. Is it a surprise that Google shoved a technology to fix web on their platform down developers throats?
Nothing else before AMP helped. Why do you think those developers will suddenly wake up and start building lightweight web pages now? Instead of ad bloated, video playing monstrosities?
Web developers were slothful. This is how purgatory looks like. ;)
- corodra 7y agoTo be fair most web dev practices are all based on silly notions of tracking and crappy UI ideas made by idiots. Animating in blocks of text is what I'm mostly referring to, but theres plenty more. Take twitter for example. A tweet takes about 10mb to load. Based on something I did about a year ago. To put that in perspective, information transfer wise, war and peace is like 800kb. The whole book. 280 char or whatever, of a single page tweet being 10mb is moronic. Reddit bit the same stupid bug with their redesign. The biggest problem, everyone is complacent and thinks "this is what progress looks like and you're a curmudgeon boomer if you think otherwise." Forethought in real sustainability, both environmentally and sociologically is looked on as impeding progress. Just like when small amounts of devs a decade ago said we need to be careful of big tech companies with our data. They were shot down and that push for "break things fast" became the name of the game. Now everyone says tax dollars must be spent for 5g because "we need the bandwidth". No, more people need to be less stupid. Mostly consumers. But devs need to start taking a stronger stance in outing bullshit tactics these businesses are implementing and quit going on their knees to pray to the silicon valley giants as some great saviors of society and their wealth is an indication of their genius. Ugh... got into a rant...
- BlueTemplar 7y agoAs a "millennial" (urgh), that has already been using the Web in the previous millennium, I agree.
- JohnFen 7y ago> Web developers were slothful. This is how purgatory looks like. But as a web user, I resent Google's efforts to put me in purgatory as well.
- kgwxd 7y agoTracking blockers via extensions, and autoplay off by default would have fixed most of the problems while also encouraging site builders to stop doing those things. Firefox makes that possible on Android. Google seems determined to never support those things in mobile Chrome and are slowly removing or crippling the ability to do it on desktop.
- jan6 7y agoiirc they're also pushing for a new extention standard, for firefox and stuff too, which is very adblock-crippling...wouldn't be so bad if it was ONLY chrome... also, loopback proxy to localhost with a standalone blocker is the next step they'll force us to take ;p
- kevin_thibedeau 7y agoFighting web bloat is a noble cause. It doesn't require a self-designated centralized gatekeeper. All Google needs to do is reward lightweight sites with better search placement.
- tomcooks 7y ago> Nothing else before AMP helped. Why do you think those developers will suddenly wake up and start building lightweight web pages now? Instead of ad bloated, video playing monstrosities? This has been an ongoing trend since ever, Viz. YSlow and Firebug Speed Tab. Fuck Google, fuck amp
- littlestymaar 7y agoBut AMP didn't help either! The new reddit was rewritten using AMP and it's really slow (ironically old.reddit.com load faster on my phone right now).
- liquidise 7y agoWeb standards and traffic being monopolized by a company with... dubious opinions about the role of privacy online is your idea of purgatory? I'd like to think similar ends could have been achieved by setting and rewarding standards around #'s of included scripts, size of the page load, etc. But that wouldn't have achieved the goal of keeping people on google.com even when clicking search results.
- izacus 7y agoI would think so too and that would be the perfect solution. But it didn't happen unfortunately. I'm using the word "purgatory" because it's not too late to get rid of it. But it does demand the web devs to get their act together. Will they?
- Angostura 7y agoSo the answer was for Google to reward fast sites by giving them a SERPS boost.
- Kalium 7y agoI believe the optimistic read is that in a world where Google manages to measure strictly performance-based metrics and then rewards pages based around that, of course developers will do things right this time. After all, we all want to write good code and produce quality work! That speed matters to user behavior has been known for a long, long time. This knowledge existed long before AMP did. It had surprisingly little effect on how pages were implemented. So perhaps our princess is in another castle. To my thinking, ahat AMP does is create a political context that enables developers to push back. By setting an unambiguous standard and clear advantages to complying with it, developers have a weapon to push back next time Marketing wants to ad fifteen trackers or whatever. This is leverage that just was not present previously, and it can change decisions.
- lwansbrough 7y agoAll Google has to do is reward site improvements in critical metrics. That's it. If my page is going to rank higher because it's faster, I will optimize the hell out of my site. But Google has been really unclear about the amount of impact those improvements have, especially as they compare to building an AMP site that will without question be featured in their carousel.
- izacus 7y agoThey did exactly that and you can find several talks about how they prioritize performance. Didn't work.
- hombre_fatal 7y agoIt could only be used as a tie-breaker for search results with the same level of confidence, anyway. It would be ridiculous to down-rank the exact thing the user is searching for just because the user would have to wait 800ms longer for that information. Or up-rank something the user isn't looking for just because it loads faster. The best Google can do is bluff about how much perf matters.
- 7y ago
- FussyZeus 7y ago> They should, but they didn't. Before AMP most of the web was unusable on slower Android phones and frontenders just laughed at you and told you to drop 800$ on an iPhone if you want to see their pages. Is it a surprise that Google shoved a technology to fix web on their platform down developers throats? So let me understand this: Google allows OEM's to ship Android on shit hardware with terrible performance, is rightfully complained at for rubber-stamping hardware with no oversight, no standards of quality, and no requirements of suitably good UX, and then Google passes the burden of supporting the shit hardware they by-virtue-of-silence gave permission to onto a ton of unsuspecting content publishers, who now either face delisting from the dominant search engine not because their content is bad, but because their website requires resources not met by Google's, proxy, shit hardware? And you're okay with that?
- izacus 7y agoYes, I'm OK with world having the ability to buy a smartphone for 50$ outside US. Mobile devices shouldn't be reserved just for rich westerners. Same for the whole web - I don't see the reason why it shouldn't be usable on a dual core laptop with 2GB of RAM. I'm fine if supporting people with older and slower devices costs more development time for developers in Silicon Valley.
- FussyZeus 7y ago> Yes, I'm OK with world having the ability to buy a smartphone for 50$ But you apparently aren't okay with getting $50 worth of smartphone, since you're demanding a ton of companies you erroneously claim to be in California expend thousands of dollars in labor to support a framework they never agreed to support, have little to no say in how it's developed, in the name of a supposedly "open" web, so that you can have a good experience consuming content more than likely for free. That, to me at least, reeks of the worst kind of entitlement. This is, in my mind, like buying a Tata Nano, which is a perfectly acceptable if limited car, and subsequently demanding all the road ways be limited to 65 mph, so that you don't feel slow. If you want to drive with the pace of traffic, the absolute cheapest car you can possibly buy brand new [1] is probably not what you want. [1] That I'm aware of.
- dessant 7y agoAMP is not the savior you describe it to be, and web developers are not against lean websites. The real bloat comes from ads and excessive tracking, and you can test that by installing uBlock Origin in Firefox for Android and see for yourself how the web suddenly becomes fast and lean. I've downvoted this post because it lacks substance, and the resulting arguments will derail the thread and bury actionable information that was shared below. It's depressing how most of these threads could initiate action but seem to be derailed.
- izacus 7y agoI didn't describe AMP as any kind of saviour and my choice of word "purgatory" was very deliberate. I'm also sorry if you feel debating the reasons why AMP was created and popularised are derailing a slew unconstructive complaining.
- dessant 7y agoAgain, install Firefox for Android with uBlock Origin, and see your opinion change about the main reason mobile sites are slow. Pages load fast and are responsive even on older phones if you use an ad blocker. https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=org.mozilla.firefox&hl=en_US https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=org.mozilla.fi... https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/android/addon/ublock-origin/ https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/android/addon/ublock-origin...
- iteratorloopmap 7y agoI use ubo and have used AMP in past. UBO is an excellent ad blocker, but as far as bandwidth savings are concerned, it doesn't come close to AMP. Of course I use UBO with JS off by default which is better and arguably more secure. But I still occasionally have to unbreak sites.
- sandy123 7y agoShould installing an adblocker be a common knowledge. The world is not made up of techies
- airnomad 7y agoHonestly, a lot of bloat is coming from WordPress, which is a platform that encourages bad development practices. I had this client with content WordPress website, 50-so plugins and regular blog post would have 1 MB JavaScript. It's crazy. WordPress is epic mess and at the same time one of the most fascinating software platforms. I don't even know what to compare it with.
- saagarjha 7y agoSome of the slowest sites I go to are news websites, and that's not because they're on WordPress.
- Drew_ 7y agoThey're probably on their own proprietary CMS that's probably just as bad or worse than WordPress.
- chickenfries 7y agoThere’s a good chance some of them are. Or Drupal, which is very similar.
- slouch 7y agoWordPress is also a platform that encourages bad takes like this. If I have 50-so plugins that provide me only with tools in the dashboard, logged-out users won't be impacted by any of the fifty. Compare it to any consumer operating system. It puts a lot of power into the user's hands.
- bad_user 7y agoI've been using the web on mobile connections ever since I got my first iPhone in 2008. When you say that it was unusable, surely it's hyperbole. I might be in a minority maybe, but I never had a problem with it and I've been a heavy user. And especially now that 4G connections are everywhere and smartphones are overpowered. I mean I watch HD videos on the web while riding the city bus with no interruptions. Are you telling me that a phone with better performance than the desktop I had 10 years ago, with a 4G connection able to stream hundreds of MB of data on a moving bus isn't capable of loading freaking text content without AMP? Surely something is missing from this picture. I'm replying to you on Hacker News by loading the website in my browser, no AMP in sight. And I read HN, including all websites listed on HN, from my phone with no AMP. And sure some websites can take a second or two to load due to crappy ads mostly. I remember a time when I waited for 5 minutes to load a website, when all we had was dial-up. And even that was awesome ;-) N.b. I avoid AMP on purpose. I started using DuckDuckGo on my mobile to avoid AMP, as I had no other way to turn that shit it off.
- colonwqbang 7y agoIphone was one of the more expensive phones you could get in 2008, just like it is now. You were not browsing the Web on the "slow android phones" parent was taking about. HN is an exceptionally fast website and not representative of the Web at large. Compare HN to something like reddit, a website which provides very similar functionality but is an order of magnitude slower. Then ask yourself why reddit has to be so slow.
- bad_user 7y agoThe Reddit website is working perfectly fine for my purposes. The only thing I'm bothered with are the annoying popups suggesting to try their app. Also if Reddit is slower than HN, that's probably because they don't care (law of diminishing returns ftw) and I'm sure they'd rather drive people to their mobile app instead. All of this isn't the fault of the web technologies used and neglect can't be solved by AMP. AMP puts websites under Google's control and nobody asked for it, being shoved down on people's throats due to an imaginary problem. --- > You were not browsing the Web on "slow android phones" Note that even the shitty, stock Android phones today are better than the iPhone that I had back then. Such is the progress of technology. I know because we have a ton of low cost Android phones to test with. The only performance problems we encounter are in the third world countries of Africa and possibly in other emerging markets, but that's only a temporary issue and I predict that in another 3-4 years from now it will be a non-issue even in those countries, hardly a reason to give up on our web standards. And it's not like you can't design super lean websites anyway.
- matheusmoreira 7y agoI agree. Another example of this: Google will force ChromeBook hardware manufacturers to use fwupd instead of proprietary solutions: https://blogs.gnome.org/hughsie/2019/11/18/google-and-fwupd/ https://blogs.gnome.org/hughsie/2019/11/18/google-and-fwupd/ It would be great if these companies had enough good taste and pride in their work to at least try to build something great by default. What we get instead are minimum viable products built in the cheapest way possible and it takes a Google to force them out of their complacency by imposing policies. On the other hand, Google is at least partially responsible for the current web situation: they normalized advertising and tracking malware on the web. Because of them, publishers think it's totally acceptable to make people download 10 megabytes of ads and javascript to read 10 kilobytes of text. The correct solution is to block all that stuff by default by shipping uBlock Origin pre-installed with browsers.
- tamrix 7y agoYou realise you have to develop a static page for amp to cache it correctly. It doesn't any page. It's more to avoid bad networks not so your phone can load a page any better.
- maremp 7y ago> Before AMP most of the web was unusable on slower Android phones and frontenders just laughed at you and told you to drop 800$ on an iPhone if you want to see their pages. > Why do you think those developers will suddenly wake up and start building lightweight web pages now? Instead of ad bloated, video playing monstrosities? To be fair, I would say a lot of this is a result of marketing/sales trying to push a lot of BS on the page, and managers or devs failing to push back. Is the developer guily of creating a "ad bloated, video playing" webpage? Yes, a lot of them don't care and make it bloated, but even if you tried, you can't do much to improve the perfomance of a bad idea.