4 ms·
So, having looked into this a few times, my personal opinion is that a quickie instafigleaf will wilt like the fig leaf it is under legal scrutiny. Regardless
by patio11 16y ago
So, having looked into this a few times, my personal opinion is that a quickie instafigleaf will wilt like the fig leaf it is under legal scrutiny. Regardless of whether it is a LC or not, my software business has substantially less in assets than a taco truck, and any tortious behavior it carries out is definitionally certain to have been carried out by me personally. My expectation is that a lawsuit means I get held personally liable and that means bankruptcy. I could drop five hundred bucks tomorrow and be BCC LLC, but that does not change my estimate of risk of bankruptcy.
I would certainly get something formal if I had partners, like you did. I sincerely hope it works out for you.
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- bradleyland 16y agoThat's a valid point regarding partners and mitigating risk. If you're a one-man company, it's a lot easier to manage the risks, so forming a corporation may be superfluous. I think it depends on your product as well. The chances of being sued while providing a simple product like bingo cards is minimal. If you're providing a service to businesses, you stand a much greater risk of being sued. It's all a balance. BTW, I'm not suggesting that you should form a corp. Just to be clear on that. I do think this conversation is beneficial for the topic starter though. I hear the "weak corporations are worthless" argument a lot. I will say that our simple little corporation is holding up really well, and we didn't spend a bunch of money forming it. We did not use one of those insta-corporation sites though. We paid a local attorney, with whom we sat down and met with, to establish our corporation and provide guidelines for maintaining it. It cost us less than $1000. IMO, the bottom line with litigation is that it comes down to who has a bigger war chest. A weak corporate structure doesn't appear to be the shot that will sink our ship. Being unable to sustain the fight is the top threat. When the personal lawsuit hit the door, the first thing I did was investigate bankruptcy. It is possible to discharge debt resulting from a judgement, but it depends on your circumstances. I definitely lack the depth of understanding required to explain it fully, but the gist of it is that receiving a discharge for a judgement isn't always as straight forward as something like credit card debt. Anyone engaged in a business with non-trivial risk of legal exposure should understand the implications before dismissing the benefits of having a corporation.
- larrik 16y agoI'm not a lawyer, but I've been lead to believe that in the US at least, if you are the only member of your company (which I believe Patrick is), then no corporate structure is going to to protect you from liability. I think even with only 2 people it's a bit iffy (especially if the other person is your spouse). If you are by yourself, Sole Proprietor is easier and simpler for taxes and the like. LLC is more complex and may offer NO extra liability protection.
- damoncali 16y agoThat's not quite true - I'd research that a little more. As far as taxes, a single member LLC can be classified as a "disregarded entity". In that case, the taxes are treated exactly as they would be for a sole proprietorship. The additional complexity of an LLC is just the state franchise taxes (which are usually quite low or zero at first) and a couple of documents - it's not a big deal.
- bradleyland 16y agoWell, as I have learned, anyone can sue you at any time. I could file a lawsuit against you right now, and you'd have to answer it in court. I've also learned that there are no absolutes. An LLC/S-Corp/C-Corp does not offer absolute protection, but it's not worthless either. There are "tests" that pass or fail, and that determines your individual liability. In our case, the impression I have developed is that if you're acting in the course of business, and you're acting in good faith, your corporation stands a good chance of protecting you. If you set up a corporation for the purposes of protecting yourself while screwing people over, your corporation probably will not protect you. The possible number of scenarios is far to broad to express as a "protection/no protection" dichotomy.
- bradleyland 16y agoAs far as simplicity goes, consider this. As a sole proprietor, you must file a Schedule C with the IRS if you intend to take any deductions. Filing a Schedule C also dramatically increases your chances of an audit. Also, when you are audited, the audit covers all of your personal finances. If my corporation is audited, the audit does not automatically extend to my personal finances. Having a corporation actually simplified my situation, even when I was a one-man consultant shop. I've always maintained separate bank accounts for my businesses, which gives me a clearer picture of my business performance by isolating my personal finances from the picture. I find the required filing to be minimal in contrast to the added clarity. I can't make the argument that it requires less paperwork, but IMO, it does make the paperwork simpler.
- pfedor 16y agoI have a stupid question: for a one-person business, how does purchasing an umbrella insurance compare with setting up an LLC? Say an LLC in California costs $800 a year. I think you can buy umbrella insurance covering you up to a few million for less than that. And it seems that it doesn't have the problem you point out...?
- bradleyland 16y agoInsurance is protection from a defined set of liabilities. A lot of people conflate umbrella insurance with "everything" insurance. It's not. Wells Fargo has a good page [1] on the topic. Insurance isn't a bad idea if you're engaged in a business with specific liabilities. It gives you a chip to play if you are sued. You can say to the plaintiff, "I have insurance that may allow us to reach a settlement without going to trial." Then you and the plaintiff engage in a settlement negotiation that may or may not be successful. You can further strengthen your position by limiting your liability to your corporation. I can tell you from my experience that you feel much more exposed when it looks like the lawsuit is coming at your personally than you do when it is your business. [1] - https://www.wellsfargo.com/biz/insurance/property_liability/umbrella_liability/basics https://www.wellsfargo.com/biz/insurance/property_liability/...
- joeag 16y agoYou are correct. A legal entity of any type is not going to protect anyone given the typical underfunded HN startup profile. The great thing about technology/web based businesses is that they don't take much capital to start. Unfortunately probably the single most important factor in determining whether a legal entity will be respected when it comes to liability is whether the entity has sufficient assets given the character and nature of the business. So, for a business that is started with say $100K and maintains some assets thereafter, pretty straightforward that shareholders, limited partners, members, etc. will not be personally liable. However, if it starts with $1 and you keep a few hundred to a few thousand in cash or other assets in the business, it's not going to shield you personally. (Of course, you also need to respect all the other formalities, accounting, regular meetings, authorizations to act, etc.) Probably the best thing about using some type of legal entity is (as you mentioned) is that it makes it easier and provides more clarity to "who owns what" when there is more than one person involved in the company.