4 ms·
re: "Google is also the reason AMP sees any kind of adoption at all. Basically, Google has forced websites – specifically news publishers – to create AMP versio
by chiefalchemist 7y ago
re: "Google is also the reason AMP sees any kind of adoption at all. Basically, Google has forced websites – specifically news publishers – to create AMP versions of their articles."
Actually, that's not quite right. Publishers have forced Google to forced publishers to use AMP. That is, publishers can't control themselves and are adding more and more and more bloat to their pages.
I am by no means a Google and/or AMP fan, but the truth is most sites have no respect for the receiving device and/or connection speed.
- oarsinsync 7y agoNeither does Google. They prioritise AMP pages over regular pages, regardless of what the regular page looks like. EDIT: @afiori comments below that this may no longer be the case.
- shadowgovt 7y agoWhat does that have to do with respect for receiving device or connection speed?
- oarsinsync 7y agoIf the respect was for the receiving device or connection speed, the metric used to determine priority of results would be size of payload / speed of delivery, rather than if the technology / hosting was google-owned.
- afiori 7y agoAs far as I recall they fixed that, now the problem is that they the measure for speed they use does some weird tricks around partial loads; as long as you display _something_ soon they are happy and the fact that a page might be useless for many seconds is weighted less
- shadowgovt 7y agoThat matches with human psychology of perception, IIUC.
- afiori 7y agoYes, I understand why they would want to do it. But it also mean that I am staring at a unusable page...
- shadowgovt 7y agoBut the alternative is you'd be staring at a useragent-provided crawler for N seconds to get to a usable page, right?
- throwaway13337 7y agoThe correct response to bloat is to penalize it in search. If they can't get rid of bloat, better quality sites can rank. This would likely mean sites with less tracking and ads - two things Google has a vested interest in.
- ravenstine 7y agoHow many average people are walking around saying "I've quit the web! It's too slow!"? Nobody. It's a non-issue because, despite the faults of the web, the average person is still clicking on chum-boxes, sharing clickbait, and using Google services. Google isn't trying to save the web. They're trying to become the web. And they've already made their money, so what makes you think they care out of the goodness of their hearts?
- SlowRobotAhead 7y ago>Google isn't trying to save the web. They're trying to become the web. This is 100% the argument that I try and explain when people say "I don't support Google, I use Brave" (or some other Chrome/Chromium browser over Firefox). It typically falls on deaf ears. I wonder how many people supporting the imo absolutely deserved "FUCK GOOGLE" mentality use Chrome to voice their thoughts?
- afiori 7y agoI know it is a rhetoric "nobody", but I did. I almost never use a browser on my phone if possible because the experience is always terrible.
- droid404 7y agoI quit sites all the time. Take trip advisor, great website, completely unusable if you are not on a high end desktop. Its a website ffs! I refuse to open pages unless I really need them. I find them using the duck since google is: to slow.
- notatoad 7y agocompletely anecdotal, but my cousin did. she told me chrome (not the web, chrome, but she definitely meant the web in general) was "too confusing" and now only uses facebook and the mobile apps for a few other services.
- SmellyGeekBoy 7y agoHow many people use HN over other tech news aggregator sites specifically because it's so lightweight? I know I do.
- mqus 7y agoBut then Google shows up and demands that all that cruft has to be added back to make AMP and normal pages the same again. Doesn't this kinda defeat the purpose? I thought I can maybe understand AMP pages as some reader mode, fast and no-bullshit content, but now they look like they just want to push their kind-of proprietary tech.
- tyingq 7y agoIt's frustrating to me that anyone buys that the driver behind AMP was performance. A Trojan horse has to have some plausible reason to let it in the gates. That plausible reason isn't the actual reason it exists. If performance really mattered to Google, it would influence SERP and Carousel position in a meaningful way.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]