> The second graph shows that the warming/cooling is seasonal The second graph shows no temperatures at all, it's CO2 ppm / year. > the overall trend has been

> The second graph shows that the warming/cooling is seasonal The second graph shows no temperatures at all, it's CO2 ppm / year. > the overall trend has been up, in-line with CO2 levels. That's simply not true. If you have more than a decade of cooling with steady increase of CO2 and recently more than a decade of steady temperatures with sharp increase of CO2, it's obvious that there are other factors involved. > I don't understand what you don't understand about the second graph You should take a closer look at it.