5 ms·
You don't need a legal structure to charge people money. Sole proprietorship is the most common form of business in the United States -- by quite a large margi
by patio11 16y ago
You don't need a legal structure to charge people money. Sole proprietorship is the most common form of business in the United States -- by quite a large margin. For example, BCC is structured as a sole proprietorship: when someone pays me for bingo cards, they're really paying me for bingo cards.
You will probably find that no B2C customer actually cares about the structure of your business, legally. Your website design matters 10,000 times more in terms of trust gained. Your mileage may vary if you sell B2B, particular B2BigFreakingEnterprise.
With regards to liability: your main defense against liability is not your corporate structure or your terms of service. It is not pissing anyone off so bad that they decide to sue you.
You can, if you choose, get an LLC and create a Terms of Service. These are more to allow you to sleep better at night than insurance against catastrophe: no matter what you do right now, if you get sued, life is going to suck.
You want to sell subscriptions? Paypal Website Payments Pro + Spreedly. You can do it in two hours of coding and about two days or so in time it takes Paypal to review your business. I do not recommend doing yearly subscriptions until you have history: doing so increases your risk profile.
Your main regulatory issue for the typical SaaS app is simple: you owe income taxes on it, both to the US and to North Carolina. Luckily, you will have very good records of sales (because you'll be able to grab them from Paypal). If you want to deduct expenses, make sure to record them and keep proof of them (generally, receipts work fine -- for e-receipts, print to PDF and put it in your Dropbox so that you don't lose it).
- tsycho 16y agoFor a "sole proprietorship", is it necessary to register a company at all for doing what the OP asked (starting a website as a side project), or can he just do it as an individual and just pay taxes on the profits as regular income? PS> I am thinking of doing something similar to the OP, and not sure if this complicates things, I am on a H1 visa.
- patio11 16y agoThere may be local rules which require some form of business registration, but in the US the typical case is that the first -- and only -- time the government hears of the existence of a sole proprietorship is on Schedule C attached to the individual's tax return, which documents its income and expenses, calculates the profits, and tells you what other pieces of paper to copy the profit number onto to figure out how much tax you owe. Sole propretorship == doing it as an individual. This is not legal advice: if you're physically in America when doing the work, the IRS probably doesn't care about your citizenship, you owe it money on your sideline income. It may not be, strictly speaking, legal to work for someone other than your employer (yes, including yourself) while you are on a H1. In practice I'd bet you that this is commonly overlooked.
- Mikushi 16y agoAbout the H1, you are right, friend of mine lived in San Fransisco on for a couple of year, on an H1 visa, he had a full-time job, and had a small revenue from his website, paid his taxes accordingly, never had a problem. (It's actually the same in Canada, i'm in locked visa, and i do contracting from time to time, never had a problem)
- nitrogen 16y agoIf you operate under a name other than your personal given name, you may need to file for a d/b/a with your state.
- kbutler 16y ago* Your city-of-residence probably requires you to file (and pay annually) for a business license, even if you are doing a purely online business. * If you accept payments in any name besides your own (e.g., a website name), and you don't have an LLC/corporation/partnership, you probably need to apply (and pay) for a DBA (no, not that kind of DBA - a "Doing Business As"). Accepting payments in a name other than your own without this could result in prosecution for fraud. In my personal IANAL opinion, the LLC (Limited Liability Company) is the best "side projects for profit" option. Relatively simple and inexpensive formation (order of $100 w/o lawyer), limited liability (how limited? courts will tell), no "double taxation" from a corporate structure. But do your own research beyond asking on forums. kb
- IgorPartola 16y agoThank you for a detailed reply. What do you recommend as a source for the Terms of Service. Is it worthwhile to get it from a lawyer or is there a sort of "industry standard"?
- patio11 16y agoYou have permission to rewrite (any of) mine, if you want them. Wordpress also has theirs available under a very permissive license. NOLO presumably has one available in their books. If you pay a lawyer $1,000 to draft terms of service, your lawyer will have $1,000 more in his pocket than he otherwise would.
- sunchild 16y agoIAAL. If you do the self-service route for terms of service, make sure you do your homework. If you do a search/replace on someone else's terms (even those offered under CC or other permissive licenses), make sure you at least run some Google searches on the rationale behind each clause of the terms. There is a HUGE amount of common ground from one site's terms to another's, but you can still get badly burned if you miss something on liability, IP rights, user generated content, etc. The one area that I recommend you learn about is enforceability of online terms. Make sure you understand concepts like unconscionable terms, conspicuous notice, valid assent, and so on. These are big, ugly words, but the concepts behind them are not difficult to grasp. Every online transaction is a balance between disclosing important terms to users on the one hand, and not being obnoxious about it on the other hand. Same advise applies to privacy policies, although it's worth noting that those are typically just plain language disclosures of your practices (at least in the U.S.) Anyway, I'm curious because I'm considering offering review/preparation of website terms and privacy policies as a fixed fee service: what would you say is a fair price for that? (Obligatory: My comments above aren't intended as legal advice and I don't represent anyone on HN.)
- IgorPartola 16y agoI for one would pay a reasonable fee for such a service. So far, I have found http://www.bennadel.com/coldfusion/privacy-policy-generator.htm http://www.bennadel.com/coldfusion/privacy-policy-generator.... which does exactly what you said: a search/replace of some generic ToS, but reading it I see that almost none of it applies (e.g.: I would have no users interacting with each other and trading goods/services).
- messel 16y agoI'd just like to add that there are costs to doing business that you can claim that are well within your right. I'm not a tax or legal specialist but things like servers, shipping costs, and your unpaid time may all be deductible to balance against your revenue. It's worth it to hire an accountant to make sure your business is crystal clean, and that you're not penalizing yourself unnecessarily.
- patio11 16y agoyour unpaid time Not deductible in the US. It isn't a close question, either.
- euroclydon 16y agoWhen talking about time and pay, it's important to remember that if the business has revenue, there better be someone getting paid, for corporations that is.
- bradleyland 16y agoYou're 100% right from a technical standpoint, but I disagree with your opinion on the liability issues. I know it seems inconceivable when you start your business, but being sued is a possibility for just about anyone. It's entirely possible for your business to be sued because of the actions of an employee, for example. If that happens, and you're a sole proprietor, you are the one being sued. This might sound like paranoia, but I'm living it, and you're right about another thing. It sucks. We have a corporation, one person in the organization did something none of the other members were aware of, and now we're being sued. The plaintiff even went so far as to try and sue all of the partners personally. Fortunately, the courts set the bar really high for breaching the corporate firewall. Being sued personally is no joke. If someone gets a judgement against you for some exorbitant sum of money, it's hard to resolve. It can follow you around for a long time. Setting up a corporation is so simple, and so inexpensive that I don't understand why anyone wouldn't do it. I respect the fact that you've built a very successful business entirely on your own, and entirely organically, but operating without a corporation seems like flying trapeze without a net.
- arethuza 16y agoHaving been a co-founder of a company that was on the receiving end of IP litigation I can say that I found the whole experience incredibly stressful - I hate to think what it would have been like if it was me personally, rather than the company, being sued. Fortunately the case was completely groundless - but it still took months of time and quite a bit of money paid to lawyers to make it go away. That's the thing that really sucks about being sued - the chances are that even if you are completely in the right you may well still end up having to spend a chunk of money on lawyers.
- rexreed 16y agoDoes anyone advise getting insurance to cover these sorts of liability? Would General or Professional Liability or even IP liability insurance cover all the legal costs? I'm thinking that in addition to corporate structure as a way of handling this unknown (but significant) risk.
- patio11 16y ago
- edw519 16y agoWith regards to liability: your main defense against liability is not your corporate structure or your terms of service. It is not pissing anyone off so bad that they decide to sue you. I agree that "doing good" is necessary but unfortunately, not sufficient legal protection. You're overlooking those whose business model is "revenue by lawyer". There are scumbags out there who haven't figured out how to make money legitimately, so they just sue the most likely target. Paying them off is often more cost effective than prevailing in court, regardless of the merits of their case. I know one who kept his small business alive for 3 years with a settlement from a large corporation who just wanted him to go away. If may not matter now, but once you're big enough, they will find you. Make sure your legal moat is in place ahead of time.