3 ms·
It very much depends on what exactly we mean by 'self driving car'. The Wikipedia description of the Levels of autonomy doesn't help much. Level 5, steering whe
by simonh 7y ago
It very much depends on what exactly we mean by 'self driving car'. The Wikipedia description of the Levels of autonomy doesn't help much. Level 5, steering wheel optional, gives the example of a self-driving taxi but we pretty much already have those in highly controlled environments. Assumptions about the situations such a car would be expected to be autonomous are critical to clear communication and analysis of this issue.
An autonomous car expert saying we are 30 to 50 years from fully autonomous vehicles by itself doesn't mean much when we actually have fully autonomous vehicles on some roads, for some tasks already[0]. Equally Musk wasn't saying we would have level 5 driving capability in all situations by 2020, he was just taking about highway cruising. The exact parameters of the driving situations we are talking about make all the difference. Both Musk can be right and the autonomous vehicles expert can be right depending on the context.
[0] https://www.reuters.com/article/us-einride-autonomous-sweden/driverless-electric-truck-starts-deliveries-on-swedish-public-road-idUSKCN1SL0NC https://www.reuters.com/article/us-einride-autonomous-sweden...
- computerex 7y agoHere's what Wikipedia actually says about Level 5: > under all roadway and environmental conditions that can be managed by a human driver There is no autonomous vehicle deployed today that is true to that statement. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Self-driving_car#Classification https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Self-driving_car#Classificatio... > Equally Musk wasn't saying we would have level 5 driving capability in all situations by 2020, he was just taking about highway cruising. Actually he specifically said that by this time the car would be able to do a cross U.S trip autonomously, which I hope you understand consists of more than just highway driving. As far as the T-Pod driverless truck thing you linked: > An operator, sitting miles away, can supervise and control up to 10 vehicles at once. The T-Pod has permission to make short trips - between a warehouse and a terminal - on a public road in an industrial area in Jonkoping, central Sweden, at up to 5 km/hr, documents from the transport authority show. A remotely supervised truck permitted to travel at 3 mph in a highly controlled and scripted path - warehouse to terminal - is hardly what anyone thinks of or means when we talk about autonomous vehicles.
- AstralStorm 7y agoThe interesting thing about level 5 is that by the definition it is impossible, as "all situations" is undefined. You cannot certify the universe. If it said "no worse than human controls in a test defined in (standard number)" then it would be workable. Unless it is an assumption of level 5 which makes it a totally different thing: marketing.
- computerex 7y agoI think largely it is defined as "all situations that can be dealt with by humans". I don't think this needs to be said, because obviously no one expects an autonomous vehicle to be able to do anything about being hit with say, a thermonuclear warhead.
- AstralStorm 7y agoThe thing is, no human is level 5 certified.
- computerex 7y agoThis statement doesn't make sense. SAE level 5 is defined in terms of humans and their capabilities, so by definition humans are SAE level 5.