3 ms·
The test wasn't natural. A number of Google people did click on the links artificially associated with the nonsense phrases, while they had Bing's toolbar activ
by dspillett 16y ago
The test wasn't natural. A number of Google people did click on the links artificially associated with the nonsense phrases, while they had Bing's toolbar active.
If the Bing toolbar is picking up on this sort of thing generically (i.e. picking keywords out of the query-string on any page and associating them with clicked links, though I'm not sure how it could with a useful degree of accuracy in a way that couldn't be "maliciously" gamed buy underhand SEO activities) then I see nothing wrong in it as long as the users have knowingly opted in to their activity being analysed in this way. It would just be indexing keywords and content just as a web spider would.
If it is specifically detecting that it is on a Google page, and/or other search competitors, than the issue is much more cloudy.
- spydum 16y agoAs it's been pointed out, Bing compares more than just the clickstream datapoints. You have to imagine they provide some PageRank/domain weighting to the relevance. So if you setup a dummy site with no existing pagerank/weight, and performed the same experiement, you likely would not see the same results. However, since you can imagine Google is heavily weighted, those data point score high and can rapidly reflect in Bing search results.
- brudgers 16y agoBut it only worked 7% of the time despite 20 Google engineers' best efforts, the honeypots being ranked number 1, and the data repeatedly sent to Bing.