4 ms·
Most of why WiFi on aircraft sucks is because airlines went too early. To be fair, they had to guess. The better Ka band satellite experience wasn't ready when
by tyingq 7y ago
Most of why WiFi on aircraft sucks is because airlines went too early. To be fair, they had to guess. The better Ka band satellite experience wasn't ready when most airlines made their initial choice, so most of them went with either Ku band satellite or air to ground cellular. Both have either technical or cost barriers to deliver enough bandwidth.
And, the cost for the hardware, FAA certification, and long aircraft downtimes to get it all installed and working was really high. So they have to recoup all that before upgrading.
JetBlue guessed better with the timing, waiting until it was ready, so their experience is better, and pricing isn't terrible as compared to others.
I feel like Southwest made a decent compromise. They went Ku, but use a separate transponder to give away TV and movies at no charge, and a small slice of bandwidth to give iMessage and whatsApp for free. The paid wifi is slow, but comparitively cheap.
The airlines that went with AirCell/GoGo are the worst of the lot. Nothing for free, and the pricing is outrageous given the experience.
Most airlines should be about ready to upgrade all the old stuff soon, so the experience should improve. Low orbit tech would help even more.
- rootusrootus 7y agoAlaska uses GoGo and they also give away iMessage for free. A weird side effect is that sometimes you get more than just free messaging. Every time I've used it, I get full Internet access (though it sure is slow). My wife's phone only ever gets iMessage. No idea why I get the accidental free upgrade.
- o-__-o 7y agodo you have tmobile? I think the service provider is related. on a side note, I've always gotten iMessage to work on southwest flights without paying. and on united you can get to certain google hosts without a paywall. I think that's all I'll share on here for now
- bronco21016 7y agoAs someone who practically lives on airliners equipped with GoGo I’m curious what else you have... What Google hosts work? Would creating a tunnel to something on GCE work?
- tekknolagi 7y agoYes. Or at least, it did for awhile. I set up a small server as a SOCKS proxy and it worked great.
- o-__-o 7y agoI used to do OpenVPN on port 53 (DNS) when all the various airplane wifi first launched. suuuuper limiting (that 230 MTU tho) and eventually blockaded. then there was the google XSS-proxy-redirect that I abused for awhile until google removed it (also hella limiting). then i decided all future jobs must pay for my airplane wifi habit, and my experience has gotten so much better (though there are some other tricks I find when i've got nothing to do.. like the redboot bug that gave me free IFE on a long haul flight :)
- bronco21016 7y agoI used both of those as well. They were good while they lasted. Nowadays I find its best to board a GoGo equipped aircraft with a list of T-Mobile numbers. When you find one with a T-Mobile One plan you’ve hit gold.
- o-__-o 7y agoLOL well first of all, I don't think a TMO plan is required just an unlimited plan (I have a grandfathered unlimited plan without the throttling that lets me GoGo) but second, and most importantly, I'm going to tell EVERYONE about this because you sir are a genius.
- rootusrootus 7y agoNah, Verizon customer (well, T-Mobile now, but that changed a couple weeks ago, my last flight was over a month ago). One trick that you can do if you want a free hour of GoGo WiFi is try numbers until you land on a T-Mobile subscriber number. Not exactly ethical, but neither is the price they charge for a cross-country flight of WiFi ;-)
- maxerickson 7y agoSo they have to recoup all that before upgrading. They aren't making the decision in that manner. They are comparing the economics of keeping the current systems with the economics of new systems, factoring in other information, and choosing the one that is better for them. (consider the cartoon scenario where the old system cost $10,000, earns $1 of revenue per flight and can be replaced by a system that costs $1000 and earns $10 per flight...)
- tyingq 7y agoI should have said "Depreciate" or "Amortize". Meaning they aren't going to replace a system until it's been there it's entire lifetime. The overall cost per airplane is huge for a new system. Most airlines make zero or a very tiny profit on the system. It started as a perk to gain share, then ended up as table stakes. Aside from the initial costs, all that Ku transponder time is crazy expensive. As is the maintenance for the onboard equipment.
- cm2187 7y agoPlus I guess one kid streaming videos on his instagram app is crippling the connection for all passengers.
- tyingq 7y agoIt's whack a mole, but most of them either block or throttle video and other bandwidth heavy traffic.