4 ms·
the problem of fake news is fundamental to the way Facebook operates. It's a noise-generating machine by design. Instead of trying to play whack-a-mole with fak
by Barrin92 7y ago
the problem of fake news is fundamental to the way Facebook operates. It's a noise-generating machine by design. Instead of trying to play whack-a-mole with fake news the saner alternative would be to architect communication systems in ways that don't allow this bottom-up virality. Associate some cost with the proliferation of posts, say limit the number of contacts users can have and how many people see their posts, bring it down to communal or human scale. Everything else is just trying to fight a hurricane with a hairdryer.
Should be obvious that it directly interferes with the business model of the company so it's probably never going to happen.
- OedipusRex 7y ago>Should be obvious that it directly interferes with the business model of the company so it's probably never going to happen. Bingo. Facebook started out as social media platform for humans, now every local news station, your favorite burger joint, and any "news" website on the web can have a Facebook profile convincing enough to look legit. Instead of fixing the news on Facebook lets take the news out of Facebook. Which is almost as impossible as "directly interferes with the business model of the company so it's probably never going to happen."
- organsnyder 7y agoI don't think that corporate presence on Facebook is really the problem. Facebook is designed to maximize user engagement. That doesn't conflate with truthfulness of content (user- or corporate-posted)—in fact, often times it's the opposite. Of course, this isn't new—yellow journalism was a big problem in the early 20th century. But Facebook's algorithm—and the ease of starting new media outlets—makes it orders of magnitude worse.
- the_snooze 7y agoExactly. All these problems are caused by Facebook's competitive advantage: network scale and reach. Any solution they propose is almost certainly doomed to failure until they acknowledge "hey, you know what, maybe this 'making the world more open and connected' thing is actually really dangerous."
- bananabreakfast 7y ago>limit the number of contacts users can have Just look at Path. It was a social network that was arguably much better than facebook and it did exactly this by limiting the number of friends you had to 150. Wasn't able to grow fast enough to dominate and collapsed.
- newnewpdro 7y ago> Should be obvious that it directly interferes with the business model of the company so it's probably never going to happen. That same bottom-up virality is being used with great effect to increase consumerism across the board. Tamping down this fire would hurt not just facebook but every business selling more products and services in sustaining this raging dumpster fire of peer-to-peer propaganda/advertising. It's not limited to the business model of facebook, it interferes with business in general.
- Uehreka 7y agoSomething that I imagine could even be good for Facebook's bottom line, would help mitigate this issue and would improve the user experience immensely: Rebalance how often friends/groups/pages show up in the feed. Right now, I have some friends who never post, some who post "regularly" (I'll leave that intentionally vague) and others who post 5-10x as much. As a result, my feed is dominated by about half a dozen people and groups. The "mega-posters" are often people who: - I know only tangentially (they aren't my best friends) - post generally good/thought-provoking/funny stuff (otherwise I'd just unfollow) - some (but not all) of them post political stuff Again, I don't want to unfollow these people, but Facebook gives me no options besides "see it all" or "see none of it" (they took out the "See less of this" button at some point). If Facebook were to rebalance my feed so that I saw at most 1 post per person per day (or some similar metric), that would have a couple effects: - I'd scroll through Facebook for longer at a time before getting the "I'm done with this" feeling. - I'd probably be more likely to see stuff from friends who don't post often - The political content of my feed would no longer be dominated by news junkies or other outliers (like the person who posts every article from every publication about the impeachment proceedings) If I didn't have many friends, I could see how this model would cause me to "run out" of content in my feed, and maybe then Facebook could revert to showing everything. But I've accumulated hundreds of friends over more than 10 years on Facebook, so I don't think that would be an issue.