9 ms·
As someone who worked at Google I'd like to clarify this corporate speak & I'm really disappointed as I thought Google had higher standards. Google has traditi
by vlovich123 7y ago
As someone who worked at Google I'd like to clarify this corporate speak & I'm really disappointed as I thought Google had higher standards.
Google has traditionally embraced an open culture so accessing documents outside the scope of your job has traditionally been totally fine & is the stated reason why every full time employee is considered an insider for trading purposes, with legal restrictions imposed on when you can trade.
'm guessing from memory (& this would be from before my time so ex-Googlers with a better memory please remind me), but the data policy was introduced to deal with SREs looking at customer data they weren't supposed to, not about the work product of coworkers.
In terms of people's calendars I'm totally confused - it's super-easy to change sharing permissions even on a per event level. Sounds like it's a pretext - the reasonable approach would be A) Improve training about the available privacy settings B) Improve Google Calendar to make it easier to manage those privacy settings since I'm sure other workplaces have a similar problem.
So the calendar stalking is the bigger problem I think on the part of the fired employees but the "accessing documents outside the scope of their jobs" is total BS. The leaking "sensitive business or customer information" seems like pure FUD - seems like a lawyer-approved way to slander about what happened.
I'm really curious whose calendars were accessed "inappropriately" and who reported feeling threatened. Moreover just accessing a calendar is not something you're notified about so that would indicate this is either BS on Google's part or these people were doing a bit of active stalking on the side. Could come out that everyone is the asshole in this story but given how bad management/labor relations have gone under Sundar, I'd wager that Google is definitely engaging in really shady shit on their own here.
- jariel 7y agoI don't think this is corporate speak really. If what Google is contending here is true, they have every justification for dismissal. Maybe 'corporate posturing' because it avoids having to deal with the ugly issues, but it seems like they have a pretty valid 'gotcha' going for them.
- Lammy 7y agoThe way it reads to me is that Google wanted to find a reason to fire these people and found the data thing to be a convenient and plausible excuse.
- NovemberWhiskey 7y agoTo me it reads like: "Hey, I guess we didn't think we needed to make it explicit that you shouldn't stalk, leak about, or facilitate harassment of your colleagues because they're working on projects with which you have personal objections. Let's now be clear that's not OK; these people just got fired for it and now we're going to make bright lines around that type of conduct to be clearer about the company we are."
- Lammy 7y ago"Stalking", "leaking", and "harassing" are all very loaded and subjective terms, and I don't trust any party who wants to lean on them as a substitute for facts.
- malvosenior 7y agoSetting up alerts around a co-worker's calendar that you're not actually meeting with is definitely stalking. Would you want someone doing that to you?
- Lammy 7y agoI wouldn't put anything in my organization's calendar that I wasn't okay being broadcast to the entire organization. Certainly not my medical appointments or other sensitive personal things. Otherwise, who cares if somebody wants an alert that I have a meeting? That's why the feature exists.
- malvosenior 7y ago> Otherwise, who cares if somebody wants an alert that I have a meeting? I would care if the person doing this then leaked my meeting information and tried to use my meetings for political gain.
- Lammy 7y ago
- shadowgovt 7y agoThe restriction on viewing and disseminating internal corporate information (not user PII, but design documents and plans) outside of one's field of responsibility is new, and there was wide concern internally that it looked like setup for this type of "you don't agree with another team and are throwing same in the wheels by adding inconvenient questions; get fired" arrangement.
- jartelt 7y agoEarlier this year Google e-mailed all employees and noted that accessing docs outside the scope of your job responsibility is forbidden and a fire-able offense. I think this policy change marked the end of the open culture you speak of. Whether this was a legitimate policy change or a change simply made to find reasons to fire activists, I don't know. But, it was made clear many months ago that digging around to access docs outside your spec could result in a firing.
- malvosenior 7y ago> Whether this was a legitimate policy change or a change simply made to find reasons to fire activists, I don't know. From the outside it seems like a very legitimate policy change. If my co-workers are stalking my calendar to find meetings they politically disagree with so they can pressure me and/or leak it to the press, well that's super creepy. I think this is a perfect example of why "full transparency" can actually be conducive to a toxic working environment. Even if it wasn't formally against the rules the intent behind that type of stalking should get anyone who engages in it fired. It's literally harassment. I think Google's change in policy is for the best here as it codifies common sense.
- joshuamorton 7y agoAs an aside, can you explain what a meeting someone might "politically disagree with" is, and how you could have such a meeting without bringing politics into the workplaces? More on topic, I'll note that nowhere did anyone use the word "politics" except you.
- malvosenior 7y agoFrom the article: > Rivers had said she was being targeted for protesting against U.S. Customs and Border Protection, which is testing a Google cloud product. Berland was active in protests against YouTube for its handling of hate speech policies. As others have stated in this thread, they were apparently policing people's meetings around these topics. If you don't like your company's legal clients, quit. Do not stalk your co-workers, harass them and leak info about them to the press.
- dickeytk 7y agoHaving blackout dates for employees buying and selling stock is something every company I’ve worked for has enforced. It doesn’t have anything to do with the open documents policy