2 ms·
If everyone is being completely honest then using debt to return money to the shareholders is fine. It is equivalent to using profits to buy back shares and bor
by roenxi 7y ago
If everyone is being completely honest then using debt to return money to the shareholders is fine. It is equivalent to using profits to buy back shares and borrowing to finance new investment.
The issue is more likely to be that if the company is misjudging how much debt is wise or what the return is likely to be, the people who are responsible for picking up on that (shareholders, senior management) are probably selling their stake in the company.
Eg, if I owned a company like WeWork I have incentive to make the company borrow large amounts of money, use that money to create artificial demand for shares, then sell my shares. Effectively a wealth transfer from lender -> me and an obligation transfer for the remaining shareholders to pay back the initial lender. That way I benefit even if the company makes no actual money and has massive debts. That sort of bad faith can't be proven until there are major scandals though; if people are operating in good faith and the lender is canny it is fine.
- ptah 7y agothere is a vast difference between using profits to buy back shares and using debt to buy back shares
- frockington1 7y agoWith interest rates so low you might as well use debt. With high corporate tax rates, repatriating cash is expensive. Might as well use cheap debt while you can
- aguyfromnb 7y ago>there is a vast difference between using profits to buy back shares and using debt to buy back shares There is zero difference. It's all money in a pool of corporate capital that is either growing (or shrinking some if you're paying interest). If you can do borrow money at negative rates and buy back shares, why wouldn't you?