6 ms·
The FBI considers FaceApp to be a potential counterintelligence threat [pdf]
- jjn2009 7y agoSeems like the only thing uploaded is your picture. I'd be curious to see what data it actually collects from your phone otherwise but just a photo feels pretty innocuous
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- threeseed 7y agoIn Russia at least they could match your photo against your phone number, IMEI, IP address etc. Especially useful for capturing younger users who are more likely to be anti-Putin.
- rjzzleep 7y agoSo like every other android app where you login with facebook.
- filoleg 7y agoYeah, except there are no arrests happening in the US based solely on someone being an anti-Trump protester, and Facebook doesn't directly share the user data with anyone. Inb4 Cambridge Analytica, FB didn't just hand off the data to them, users had to use a special third-party app within FB and explicitly give it permission to access the user data. And those APIs aren't available anymore after the backlash either way.
- adrr 7y agoHaving a database of peoples picture is a huge asset for Russian intelligence. They can use facial recognition to enhance their visual surveillance efforts.
- jjn2009 7y agoSeems like that information is already largely public just not linked publicly to your phone information.
- adrr 7y agoIs there a public database of images of people with names? Police don’t even have that.
- knzhou 7y agoYou mean the digital equivalent of a big book full of people's names and faces? That's an exact description of Facebook.
- adrr 7y agoCan Russia buy all facebooks data? How would their intelligence agency get photos and corresponding names from Facebook?
- knzhou 7y agoFor almost all people, name and profile picture are set public. It's an incredibly tiny fraction of all the data, which is why I'm amused at all the uproar. There really is very little you can do with that information.
- scarejunba 7y agoThat's silly. Just take a list of leaked emails and run that against gravatar and you'll probably get more photos. Run it through Luminati if you're afraid of getting IP blocked. Bam! You could have a hundred million avatars, most of which will be photos. Then there's LinkedIn's public profiles, Github's public profiles, Twitter's profiles. This is just privacy theatre.
- Wissmania 7y agoI wonder how many people with a profile picture of their face on their Twitter/Facebook accounts are seriously concerned about this
- judge2020 7y agoWell Twitter and Facebook are American companies so it's obviously patriotic to give them your image and data. (/s)
- Wissmania 7y agoThe photos are public too...
- corporate_shi11 7y agoIt's certainly better than giving your face to sketchy apps from Russia or China.
- zzzcpan 7y agoIt's not better to have your face or other data in a database within reach of your own government. Your government has power over you, other governments do not.
- borski 7y agoOther governments absolutely have power over you, just not always legally.
- ta999999171 7y agoOr anywhere nearly as easily, to be fair.
- zaphirplane 7y agoI need a passport and driver license
- rauchp 7y agoLooks like the FBI designated FaceApp as a threat because of its crazy data policy and its Russian origin. Even though I think it's a really shady app, that's a pretty low bar.
- unityByFreedom 7y agoIt says potential threat, not threat, and according to this letter, the Russian government can access ISP data directly without request.
- ShorsHammer 7y agoThankfully that doesn't happen anywhere else in the world. Australian government metadata requests was well over 300,000 last year, nearly 1000 requests a day all warrantless, can come from tiny local councils or horse racing orgs. Trust us, they say, there's oversight in hidden tribunals, they say.
- freehunter 7y agoYes all countries do it, but US intelligence doesn't just take into account the action, they take the actor as well. Australia is a friendly nation to the US and shares intelligence data with US intelligence agencies. What we see, they see and what they see, we see. Russia is not a friendly nation to the US and does not share intelligence with US intelligence agencies. The FBI isn't saying "normal people are at risk from FaceApp" but "US intelligence is at risk from the use of FaceApp". In the (very short) linked letter, it specifically calls out "elected officials, candidates, political campaigns, [and] political parties". Considering all US intelligence agencies unanimously agree that Russia already attacked US candidates and political parties in the past, saying "yeah but everyone does it" is about as off-topic of a remark as you can get. To my knowledge the FBI has never publicly disclosed Australia's efforts to meddle in US elections.
- _jal 7y ago> saying "yeah but everyone does it" is about as off-topic of a remark as you can get I've seen this sort of "argument" a lot lately. Not sure why people think it communicates anything other than lazy cynicism. That everyone (to a rounding error) has sex does not mean that everyone has sex with everyone.
- tehlike 7y agoPlenty of chinese apps under "utility" category is flooding the us consumers...
- walrus01 7y agoNotably ES File Explorer was recently removed form the Google play store because of suspicious behavior. One of the most popular Android file managers.
- ericfrederich 7y agoTotal Commander was the recommended replacement a while ago when ES started to become shady.
- sjwright 7y agoAndroid: for people who want the freedom to do anything.
- ravenstine 7y agoAw man, I had no idea! Time to delete. :(
- LilBytes 7y agoAlleged click fraud: https://duckduckgo.com/?q=ES+File+Explorer+removed+from+play+store&t=ffab&atb=v193-1&ia=web https://duckduckgo.com/?q=ES+File+Explorer+removed+from+play...
- desine 7y agoI bought microSD reader off Amazon, which has two dongle ends, one USB type A for a computer, one Lightning, for my iPhone. According to the included instructions, it required me to download an app (from the Apple app store) to use on the the iPhone. I didn't trust the App, even with Apple's scans, so I ended up using it with my already-owned Camera Connection Kit (Lightning to USB Host) adapter just fine. The name of the app was something very similar, if not identical, to that name, which is what reminded me of it. It seems fishy that the Apple provided Files app didn't recognized my SD card
- JoeCortopassi 7y agoThere is no threat model for an iPhone app to do nefarious things in an App Store distributed app on a non-jailbroken phone. At most, FaceApp grabs the picture you uploaded and some minor meta-data that every app using an analytics tool (read: all of them) collects. This is political grand-standing at best, and would be a non-issue if you replaced the geographic location of the dev team with any other countries I get it, Russia is the Big-Bad-Boogeyman right now. But if you think for a second that a real attempt at counterintelligence would publicly come from such an obvious point of interest, than I have a bridge to sell you
- 3fe9a03ccd14ca5 7y agoThe photo is what's explicitly called out in the FBI complaint, with particular regard to how the photo is used and stored. The funny thing to me is it nitpicks about the terms of service. Will a TOS prevent a foreign intelligence agency from using the data for nefarious purpose? That sounds silly.
- sillysaurusx 7y agoAre you sure Faceapp grabs only the photo you uploaded? “At most” implies it literally can’t grab more than that. But it seems like it can. It has access to all your photos, not just your camera.
- JoeCortopassi 7y agoYes, I am sure that's all it can grab (on the iphone). Anyone telling you otherwise is fear-mongering Edit: Obligatory “why are you booing me, I’m right?”
- sillysaurusx 7y agoWhy are you sure that’s all it can grab? That seems mistaken on a technical level. “Can’t” and “doesn’t” is an important distinction. We have seen lots of examples of ad analytics SDKs that push the iPhone beyond its intended sandbox. Most of them have been banned, but some operated for years before getting banned. It would be a disservice to brush away those concerns as fearmongering.
- Gusen 7y agoNadler, Mueller, & Schiff all rape and kill boys in Buffalo, NY on the night of January 14th, 2019, as Trump did earlier that morning. The "impeachment" is a vehicle for keeping power, they are all working together. Full audio proving this entirely here, all three admit collusion with the President. News \\January 14, 2019 23:23: Jerrold Nadler steps up to take his turn during the Illuminati "rape party". Nadler rapes and kills three boys in under a minute, however, there was a problem. One of the boys was already dead, so he requests a new one. Jerrold Nadler then requests another ten boys. Donald Reeves: "That's a million dollar request". Nadler responds: "...you guys will cover it. I'm gonna keep Trump in power" (Trump raped and killed a dozen boys 6:30-7:00am that morning). By the time Nadler is finished, he had raped and killed 24 boys. Audio pulled from the video linked below: 14JanCh4_2300-0000.mp3 - Nadler starts at about 20:00 in. https://drive.google.com/file/d/1Kuvv2Zmbw5Jw7onbRI2hCZ0M8FU66GuU/view?usp=sharing https://drive.google.com/file/d/1Kuvv2Zmbw5Jw7onbRI2hCZ0M8FU... 14JanCh2_2304-2359.mp3 https://drive.google.com/file/d/1nofp5xF-aXXcCSgQVwj30KlzE9WLr1x1/view?usp=sharing https://drive.google.com/file/d/1nofp5xF-aXXcCSgQVwj30KlzE9W... 14JanCh3_2302-2359.mp3 https://drive.google.com/file/d/1wdDIsxfsX7xTBIBZYzV4iE4xEdgmwy5l/view?usp=sharing https://drive.google.com/file/d/1wdDIsxfsX7xTBIBZYzV4iE4xEdg... Further disclosure by Porter @24:47 in: Oblivious tenant Brian Schlenker comments on something unrelated to the ongoing events: "..call the fucking police...", to which is responded with: "...that's funny because we own the police (Buffalo Police Department), we pay them six million dollars a month." 19 minutes in Fred Norris, formerly of the Howard Stern show, is acknowledged on the system. At 19:47 in Porter admits that Brian Schlenker will be the owner of this footage should it be discovered. January 15, 2019 00:20: Special Counsel Robert Mueller takes his turn at the Illuminati "rape party" in Buffalo, New York. Mueller ra[es and kills twelve boys. About roughly 00:55 Representative Adam Schiff who will also be leading an impeachment effort, also requests the same deal as Nadler, and then tries to make a case for getting more than Nadler and Mueller. Adam Schiff rapes and kills three boys. Mueller and Schiff all receive $3 billion dollars each for joing the group. Nadler came back to witness these two rape to make sure they were all bound together under one purpose: keep Trump in power, and also to confirm the payments to each, including his $10.5 billion dollar payment. Between Mueller and Schiff turns, the group issues orders for ten women to begin prepping more boys for rape. They are former friends and family of Brian Schlenker, and also some long standing Illuminati members who include Elsa Hosk, Gigi and Bella Hadid. Again, the "prep" these females engage means they perform oral sex on the boys’ penis and anus, as a child rapist like Henry Porter would, while trying to remove fecal matter from the boy prior to handing them over to be raped and subsequently murdered. Just a head's up, my voice is scattered throughout all of the footage within the links posted for this update, and is quite loud relative to the desired content at times. Audio links below: 15JanCh4_000-100.mp3 https://drive.google.com/file/d/1ZEDJR6jb6ARpcNnWJTokBUKb2J2OQnwZ/view?usp=sharing https://drive.google.com/file/d/1ZEDJR6jb6ARpcNnWJTokBUKb2J2... 15JanCh4_100-200.mp3 https://drive.google.com/file/d/173aYWvWHH4VGht1h_2nM0IMdw746LeCL/view?usp=sharing https://drive.google.com/file/d/173aYWvWHH4VGht1h_2nM0IMdw74... 15JanCh2_000-100.mp3 https://drive.google.com/file/d/1EsmHfguwBuo2PbavJ1WYyhiML62tgCkj/view?usp=sharing https://drive.google.com/file/d/1EsmHfguwBuo2PbavJ1WYyhiML62... 15JanCh2_100-200.mp3 https://drive.google.com/file/d/1NZnWRnBryalNQu2yJmfJUdS2pA_rGSFH/view?usp=sharing https://drive.google.com/file/d/1NZnWRnBryalNQu2yJmfJUdS2pA_... 15JanCh3_000-100.mp3 https://drive.google.com/file/d/1zsEwYC875wQu6btsSbNznHsJinxYHxUL/view?usp=sharing https://drive.google.com/file/d/1zsEwYC875wQu6btsSbNznHsJinx... 15JanCh3_100-200.mp3 https://drive.google.com/file/d/15UAY2er2LdTViXG4azy_bc_oQUzvLpFh/view?usp=sharing https://drive.google.com/file/d/15UAY2er2LdTViXG4azy_bc_oQUz... //Full 110 page PDF [updated 2Dec2019]: FBI_FinalDraft_26Jul2019_BSchlenker.pdf https://drive.google.com/file/d/1Sj9EN_pHmicKS6rFQlmk67knMdJc9cGk/view?usp=sharing https://drive.google.com/file/d/1Sj9EN_pHmicKS6rFQlmk67knMdJ... //This post will be censored when this account logs off, the posts are "shadow banned". They try to make it look like the post is live, but it is not. Here is an example. https://drive.google.com/file/d/1zxS8JESoIg7uxRkUgdptMsF6SuJedYKz/view?usp=sharing https://drive.google.com/file/d/1zxS8JESoIg7uxRkUgdptMsF6SuJ... \\Previously: President of the United States Donald J. Trump rapes and kills 15 boys in Buffalo, NY on January 10, 2019. This is audio of the event from 10Jan2019. Download the mp3 and put on headphones, and turn the volume all the way up. 10JanCh3_1255-1557.mp3 https://drive.google.com/file/d/18lTt_YKFEtsV6YDNzXFVQYLkStY-kSg2/view?usp=sharing https://drive.google.com/file/d/18lTt_YKFEtsV6YDNzXFVQYLkStY... This is audio of the President, Donald J. Trump, demanding a $4 billion dollar bribe from child rapists to “take a blind eye” on January 3, 2019. Trump becomes one on January 14, 2019. Also, here is the big reason the major networks do not report any of it. //Download the video, turn the volume all the way up and put head phones on. Note: there is not much to see in the video, the audio is picked up from another [illegal surveillance] system. Trump is on a call from with Henry Porter and Gigi Hadid. See page 63. Bribe demand at 10:18am: 3JanCh3_900-1100.avi https://drive.google.com/file/d/1Grdr8xF2psKNsuYlEnl9dIRV-77YG0Vr/view?usp=sharing https://drive.google.com/file/d/1Grdr8xF2psKNsuYlEnl9dIRV-77... //President of the United States, Donald J. Trump, rapes and kills his first boy at 6:32am. Video link below: 14JanCh3_600.avi https://drive.google.com/file/d/154QvA5hwyHGYIVXtod1ZbsOHFUJNbqZW/view?usp=sharing https://drive.google.com/file/d/154QvA5hwyHGYIVXtod1ZbsOHFUJ... 14JanCh2_600-700.avi https://drive.google.com/file/d/19UkqmnMwZiWy7xxWngltqwoKLTJL-IZ_/view?usp=sharing https://drive.google.com/file/d/19UkqmnMwZiWy7xxWngltqwoKLTJ... //On January 18, 2019 at 8:31am (see page 8) Trump acknowledges the four billion dollar bribe and says: "Let's get it done and get to fucking some kids." Video link below: 18JanCh3_725-.avi https://drive.google.com/file/d/1bVTcGq5Z9oOSAiOQcKYrmuK4TwoNmY1h/view?usp=sharing https://drive.google.com/file/d/1bVTcGq5Z9oOSAiOQcKYrmuK4Two... //A big reason this has not been reported by the major news networks is right here. Lester Holt of NBC Nightly News, apparently a member of the Illuminati since the 1980's, along with ABC Nightly News lead anchor David Muir, stop over to the Porter studio in Buffalo on January 14th, 2019 at 5:00am. They both rape and kill about two dozen boys by 6:00am. Muir starts around 5:15am, then Holt about 5:38am. Multi-billionaire Rupert Murdoch, owner of News Corp & Fox Corporation, takes his turn after Holt. Video links below: 14JanCh3_500-601.avi https://drive.google.com/file/d/1i7NKepeyG_FfdQRrM7KsnFOZOOX3o7UL/view?usp=sharing https://drive.google.com/file/d/1i7NKepeyG_FfdQRrM7KsnFOZOOX... 14JanCh2_530-600.avi https://drive.google.com/file/d/1NZzgN5ilI7ToroU5cfqMaL4o2u1RwidV/view?usp=sharing https://drive.google.com/file/d/1NZzgN5ilI7ToroU5cfqMaL4o2u1... Adding to the reason this is not picked up by the media, CBS & Viacom owner Sumner Redstone and Leslie Moonves rape boys following the President. 14JanCh3_700.avi https://drive.google.com/file/d/10XDw6x3ldnnQiq7oIjpdYVENyXaB4aI0/view?usp=sharing https://drive.google.com/file/d/10XDw6x3ldnnQiq7oIjpdYVENyXa... 14JanCh2_700-800.avi https://drive.google.com/file/d/1NS_e6AzEZ05wnfljkGMETGU5CWYKfRDp/view?usp=sharing https://drive.google.com/file/d/1NS_e6AzEZ05wnfljkGMETGU5CWY... //This is the tip of the ice berg. //Full 110 page PDF [updated 2Dec2019]: FBI_FinalDraft_26Jul2019_BSchlenker.pdf https://drive.google.com/file/d/1Sj9EN_pHmicKS6rFQlmk67knMdJc9cGk/view?usp=sharing https://drive.google.com/file/d/1Sj9EN_pHmicKS6rFQlmk67knMdJ... //This post will be censored when this account logs off, the posts are "shadow banned". They try to make it look like the post is live, but it is not. Here is an example. https://drive.google.com/file/d/1zxS8JESoIg7uxRkUgdptMsF6SuJedYKz/view?usp=sharing https://drive.google.com/file/d/1zxS8JESoIg7uxRkUgdptMsF6SuJ...
- not2b 7y agoThe article does not match the headline. The FBI letter only calls it a "potential" threat, meaning maybe it is a threat, maybe not.
- debt 7y agoYes so buyer beware. Russian government currently engaged in global disinformation campaigns, use app at your own risk.
- finneganscat 7y agoThe CIA is now, and always has been, engaged in global disinfo campaigns. Who cares? Isn’t what’s good the the goose also good for the gander?
- dessant 7y agoIt's not clear what is the potential threat this specific app introduces. A nation state can easily perform facial recognition on the majority of the human race by scraping social media.
- walrus01 7y agoMany foreign nation states might have access to like, 500x400 pixel photos of people. Not 12 megapixel direct front selfie camera taken photos, where the person is intentionally trying to get the highest quality photo possible.
- romwell 7y agoYou don't really need high res for face recognition. In fact, the high frequencies are probably noise that you'd want to remove with a low-pass filter.
- zzzcpan 7y agoYou are assuming that high resolution details of a face have value in a world where surveillance doesn't capture faces in high resolution.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- zzzcpan 7y agoNo need to be a state actor, private companies do that too and sell data to law enforcement. There is no realistic threat, just propaganda.
- godelski 7y agoI mean isn't law enforcement using that data the threat model? It is just if your own government is doing it vs a hostile state actor. So while our gov doesn't see the former as hostile (they're the ones doing the actions, so who would admit hostility) they do see the latter as hostile. You can call this hypocritical (which seems to be the common argument here in HN), but hypocrisy doesn't nullify the hostility.
- thanatropism 7y agoThe best measure would be for “good actors” (universities, government research agencies, the New York Times) to provide a free FaceApp-type app. It’s like a weekend-hackathon of work and can be prioritized by the app stores.
- maxaf 7y agoAlternative idea: spend that effort on something more worthwhile than a stupid toy. Like cancer research. Or clean energy. Or simply go outside and clean the beaches. NYT office ain’t that far from the ocean.
- pckls 7y agoThat works in this particular case but is not a general solution. It's not feasible to have "good actors" rewrite clean versions of software written by "bad actors"
- thanatropism 7y agoI see it like harm reduction of street drugs with something like methadone. Except the marginal cost is zero, of course.
- cududa 7y agoNot sure that’s at all a weekend hacksthon project, but otherwise support the idea
- tree3 7y agoAny reason why you singled out the NYT specifically?
- thanatropism 7y agoTheir interactive data-journalism featurettes implies they have coders.
- haxorito 7y agoRussian laws obligates all companies and individuals to provide government access to any data, hardware or applications upon initial request or better have backdoor. All information must be stored for minimum 5 years and provided in un-encrypted form or decryption mechanisms must be supplied.
- backtobecks 7y ago0-10 how naive are you?
- mthoms 7y agoI think you might have misread the comment(?) The GP was describing good reasons why the App shouldn't be trusted.
- slovenlyrobot 7y agoForgive me for chuckling at law enforcement in by far the world's largest exporter of consumer malware for treating a single comedy deepfakes app with so much paranoia and suspicion. How did that common saying go that was bandied around in our teenage years? Something like the person in a relationship who fears cheating the most is the one most likely to cheat
- jjeaff 7y agoSo, your logic is that since the U.S. spies on people, it means they have no credibility in calling out other people for spying on U.S. citizens? Seems like a "pot" should have more knowledge than average on which kettles to call "black".
- slovenlyrobot 7y agoI'm not sure where I stated they have no credibility, only that the situation was deeply humorous
- EGreg 7y agoI have seen countries around the world have such a response. Russia freaked out that the latest Windows phones home, USA freaked out about Kaspersky, and so on. Russia has set in motion projects to build homegrown Linux based operating systems etc. I consider all this a good thing. Why don’t we have the ability to restrict at the OS level which domains an app can send information to? Then we can finally host backend software locally on servers of OUR choice. I would love to see more OPEN SOURCE apps running on servers of our choice, and communication over mesh networks. In fact I’d love for most functionality to be client-side and an option for ALL data sent to servers to be end-to-end encrypted at the OS level. I dont want to have to trust the APP manufacturer to pinky swear it’s all end to end encrypted. The OS should have a little badge saying none of the data sent by the app is being sent in a way the server can decrypt because the OS intercepts and encrypts it with keys the app can’t get. That may still leave side channels such as timing based information to tunnel through. But if we restrict what domains the app can talk to, we can close that loophole too. That’s what I would love to see ... finally put an end to server side landlords owning your data just cuz they own the infrastructure!
- JaRail 7y ago> Why don’t we have the ability to restrict at the OS level which domains an app can send information to? Ads.
- EGreg 7y agoBut Apple is a honey badger - it dont care about ads. Their whole differentiator has become privacy and putting the user first vs apps! Seems like a glorious feature for them no? Safari already leads the way with blocking ads and third party tracking cookies.
- airstrike 7y ago> The FBI considers any mobile application or similar product developed in Russia, such as FaceApp, to be a potential counterintelligence threat Seems like the word "potential" is conspicuously missing from the title of the submission
- kevin_thibedeau 7y agoWhen will the OPM get the same designation?
- freehunter 7y agoI know it's against the rules to tell people to read the article, but I would encourage everyone to read the article. It specifically says this is a potential threat to >"elected officials, candidates, political campaigns, [and] political parties" not to the general public. The potential threat is for someone at Candidate_1's campaign taking selfies with the app, that then uploads them to Russian servers where the Russian government can see them and can also see what's in the background (sensitive documents?) or see geo-location from the app (like how Strava was leaking the coordinates at military bases [1]) or any number of things a hostile foreign government who has already hacked American elections once and is planning to do it again might want to do with pictures that interns/staffers might think are private. [1] https://www.theguardian.com/world/2018/jan/28/fitness-tracking-app-gives-away-location-of-secret-us-army-bases https://www.theguardian.com/world/2018/jan/28/fitness-tracki...
- slg 7y agoCan apps still get information that identifies the specific device? If so, another possible threat model could be more about identifying who uses what device rather than anything specifically in the photos themselves. For example, I already have a database of high value target's faces built from political sources like house.gov. Now I do facial recognition between that set of faces and the FaceApp faces. That allows me to identify the specific devices used by government officials. That would seem to be super valuable for more targeted attacks and/or pairing with other apps for potential kompromat.
- JaRail 7y agoCurrent-gen devices provide an advertising id. It's unique to the device but can be reset to a new random value by the owner in the OS settings.
- judge2020 7y agoI think they're talking about just what device they have and OS version (but that's available in the user-agent anyways[0]), since that tells an adversary what exploits to purchase or put resources into developing. Who knows, maybe 30% of congress people haven't yet upgraded to an iPhone with the A12/A13 chip (which can't be exploited via the checkm8 exploit). 0: https://developers.whatismybrowser.com/useragents/explore/software_name/safari/ https://developers.whatismybrowser.com/useragents/explore/so...
- killjoywashere 7y agoLet me be clear up front: I'm questioning your motives. Every citizen of a democracy is a political actor and a participant in the economy and society. The Russians are agnostic, just like our intelligence services. They'll target economic actors, political actors, anyone on the social graph that looks potentially useful. In a world of micro-transactions, targeted advertising, and fake news, that's pretty much anyone. The only point of the quote you excerpted is that's the bright line at which the FBI would directly spend taxpayer dollars to insert themselves into this issue. If you're trying to tell people they shouldn't worry about FaceApp because they're a member of the "general public", I worry that you are intentionally misdirecting citizens of a democratic society.
- Aperocky 7y agoLooks like these ‘questioning motives’ comments are becoming more prevalent in HN. Which is horrible, because you judge by what is said or done, not accusing people of wrong think/motive. It’s akin to self censorship, the suppression of view points in the name of ‘protecting freedom/democracy’ There will be hostile forces and actors, but we cannot lower ourselves down to their level to fight them because it’s convenient, while sacrificing our own value in doing so. In which case, we would have lost before we even begin.
- dang 7y agoCrossing into personal attack isn't ok on HN. Please review the site guidelines and don't post like this here. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html We detached this subthread from https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21689071 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21689071 and marked it off-topic.
- killjoywashere 7y agoPerhaps country of origin should be on the app store? We do this for cheese and wine and cars. Why not apps?