3 ms·
Pretty on the nose, IMO. I've lived in SF since 2010, and the Bay Area since 2004. I've seen the change even in that amount of time, not even the longer time
by kelnos 7y ago
Pretty on the nose, IMO. I've lived in SF since 2010, and the Bay Area since 2004. I've seen the change even in that amount of time, not even the longer time scale of the OP, who grew up here and later moved away.
In my mind, it all comes down to housing policy. Prop 13 needs to go. Restrictive zoning needs to go. The right of residents to complain and lawsuit development projects out of existence[0] needs to go.
In the shorter term, while all this plays out, we need to invest heavily in sheltering our homeless population, getting them off drugs, and getting them help with any mental health needs. Acceptance of this needs to be mandatory: once we have sufficient services in order to help the entire homeless population, I actually do want to "criminalize homelessness". It should not be an allowable choice, and those who are homeless and need help getting back on their feet can get that help, every last person.
Of course, I don't expect any of this to happen. I agree with the OP that the next 15 years aren't gonna look great for the city. I just wonder what it will take. Will people actually wise up, see the actual roots of the problem, and fix them; or will there be a backlash that results in a giant exodus that crashes home prices and leaves the city in shambles?
[0] This one is especially insidious. Often a housing developer will be delayed multiple years before they're able to break ground. The extra money that they have to spend on legal fees, as well as being paid to sit on land they own but can't make money on, drives up the cost of the finished product. I hear so many complaints that all the new development is "luxury housing" -- well, duh. Because of all the anti-housing activism, high-end housing is the only way developers can turn a profit.
- purple_ducks 7y ago> I actually do want to "criminalize homelessness". It should not be an allowable choice How about people who are an utter nuisance on their neighbours? Do we just say tough luck to the neighbours? Have you ever experienced that? People who have zero respect for their neighbours and just do whatever they want at whatever time they want? How many noise complaints will the neighbours be forced to tolerate because I have zero doubt given SF's governance that putting these people in jail will not happen. Should people just tolerate their lives being disrupted until all avenues of addiction/mental health/other treatment are exhausted?
- kelnos 7y agoPretty sure this is an edge case. Sure, one that needs to be handled, but I don't think it invalidates my thinking. Fines are obviously not a great option, since someone who has been recently homeless likely can't pay them. Maybe jail time is the right answer? I agree that SF wouldn't reach for that solution, but I wasn't talking about things that SF likely would do, just what I think it needs to do in order to get us out of this hole.
- xtiansimon 7y ago> “Prop 13 needs to go.“ Prop 13 permitted my grandmother to stay in her home on SS as a widow into her 90s. Four generations of my family have lived in the Bay Area. I’ve lived in the Greater NYC/Long Island Area for going on 13 years and it’s a much different story here. Property taxes essentially force retirees to move south. Away from their families, grandchildren and the homes they own, but can’t afford to keep because of high property (plus school taxes). People here never heard of Prop 13. And why should they? The East Coast is completely different—-older, tighter geographic communities, and years of aging adults moving away from the freezing north. Before people in CA decide to make Prop 13 the scapegoat, you should look at what property taxes do for all home owners here on the right coast. And BTW, luxury housing? You said it, ‘turn a profit’. Americans have too much ‘stuff’ to live in the smaller units that would also turn a profit. IMHO