6 ms·
It's not just medical residents. Doctors do refresh their knowledge from videos online. And they totally google for information. But I don't think it's what man
by viraptor 7y ago
It's not just medical residents. Doctors do refresh their knowledge from videos online. And they totally google for information. But I don't think it's what many people imagine when reading it.
> How can doctors tell which videos are valid and which contain bogus information?
They're doctors. They had years of training and know the basics of what they're booking up. It's closer to experienced developers looking up specific usage for some tool which they're familiar with otherwise, rather than learning from scratch.
Sure, there's going to be some extreme bad cases, but those are bad doctors in general, the source of info is not relevant.
- dang 7y agoOk, we've promoted residents to doctors in the title above.
- JshWright 7y agoThat's more of an "expansion" than a "promotion" (residents are a subset of doctors)
- ISL 7y agoI've not met a professional that doesn't make internet searches for information when necessary. I'm a professional physicist, and I search for specialty-specific information multiple times per day, every day.
- alexis_fr 7y agoAre there websites like StackOverflow where you find pharmaceutical receipes for acetylcysteine?
- arcticfox 7y agoI think the parent is a physicist, not a pharmacologist, but I'm curious about what exists in both physics and pharmacology so I hope people chime in on both.
- MereInterest 7y agoPhysicist here. ENSDF (Evaluated Nuclear Structure Data File) is a fantastic resource for anything related to nuclear physics.
- petschge 7y agoPerson doing simulations in plasma physics / astro physics here. I google tons of stuff every day. And I have a hard copy of https://www.nrl.navy.mil/ppd/content/nrl-plasma-formulary https://www.nrl.navy.mil/ppd/content/nrl-plasma-formulary on my desk. And the PDF on just about any of my devices. Once every few years I ask the Navy for 20 copies and hand them out to grad students and colleagues.
- ISL 7y agoThe Decay Chain article on Wikipedia is a go-to favorite of mine: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Decay_chain https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Decay_chain The graphics for the natural decay chains are eminently-usable and teachable.
- semi-extrinsic 7y agoNot a medicinal chemist, but I think the general procedure for that is to do a google (or better, Google Scholar) search for "$chemicalName synthesis". Here you go: One-step synthesis of N-acetylcysteine and glutathione derivatives using the Ugi reaction https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0040402009005778 https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S00404... I can't seem to find an openly available PDF, but you can search sci-hub to pirate that. From reading the abstract and the graphics, it doesn't exactly look like something you cook up in the kitchen. For instance they run the reaction in trifluoroethanol, which is flammable, toxic, irritant and possibly causes reduced fertility from exposure.
- lilott8 7y agoNot sure if you have access to it, but reaxsys[1] is an amazing database for stuff like this. I've used it many times for looking for (un)safe reaction paths for particular drugs. It looks like the ``free'' version might let you get a lot of information from it. Also, pubchem[2] might be of help as well. This is entirely free. [1]https://www.reaxys.com/ https://www.reaxys.com/ [2]https://pubchem.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/ https://pubchem.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/
- refurb 7y agoThat's usually done by literature search, which nowadays, can be done online. You draw a structure and it will look up literature that reported that as a product. I haven't seen a website like stack overflow in the sense of posting questions like "How do I purify after this Beckmann rearrangement?"
- msla 7y agoWhen reading articles like this, here's a quick check: Replace "YouTube" with "bookstores" and see if you're still outraged. Anyone can write a book, and the bar to getting a book published has absolutely nothing to do with the book's accuracy. If "Chariots Of The Gods?" can get published, you know publishers aren't doing sanity testing or any other kind of checks for the reliability of the content. And yet doctors buy books from bookstores, and use them to learn things. How do doctors know they're not getting nonsense? Because they know what real information looks like. This is the biggest reason for teaching the basics of a broad variety of subjects: If you know what real information looks like, and how the real field basically fits together, you're less likely to be taken in by absolute nonsense. OTOH, if you get bad information to start, you're going to evaluate all subsequent information on that standard, and reject good information because it doesn't jibe with the bad stuff you've already internalized.
- smileysteve 7y agoEven worse, imagine it was medical journals that are mostly pay to publish, have clickbait titles, and have never been replicated or have poor p values,
- colonelpopcorn 7y agoThere's also the compulsion that highly trained professionals have to correct false information out of a sense of pride or ego. It helps to combat misinformation when you have a fair number of "ummm, ACKSHULY"'s in your profession.
- petschge 7y agoAs always there is a relevant xkcd: https://xkcd.com/386/ https://xkcd.com/386/
- wlesieutre 7y agoAlternately: > Developers are turning to Stack Overflow to fill in gaps in their training There's a lot of garbage channels on YouTube, but there's no shortage of knowledgeable people too. Nobody knows everything, and it turns out there are people on the internet who know things we don't.
- toomanybeersies 7y agoI've seen some terrible code in codebases that I just know has come from Stack Overflow (often I can trace back and find it). Some of it's for security related code, so it's fairly critical to get it right. Doctors aren't magically smarter than developers.
- GauntletWizard 7y agoThere's no magic to it - There's a lot more gatekeeping, training, board certification, etc. It's not perfect, but it's a darn sight better than the complete lack of professional standards that we developers are held to (myself included - I'm shipping code today that I wish I weren't, that I believe is unsafe at any speed, but thankfully I don't believe it'll be getting above .1MPH) You can hire a developer off the street who just happened to be the CEO's nephew. You can't do that with doctors.
- g_langenderfer 7y agoWould you prefer we had to get a license like a barber? There's a growing shortage of developers. What would that look like with more barriers to entry?
- tonyedgecombe 7y agoIt would look pretty good for the developers.
- wolco 7y agoPutting gates around something as basic as medicine has only resulted in the price going up. You can hire the CEO's nephew for any role. Doesn't mean you are getting anything done. That nephew can buy a medical degree abroad or locally at Harvard.
- bbrodriguez 7y agoI recently had an elevated D-Dimer level in my blood lab which indicates a clot of some sort. I remember sitting in the doctor’s office while my primary care doctor was reading the lab results. He literally started Googling “primary causes of D-Dimer elevation” and clicked on the link to a WebMD documentation on D-Dimer levels. That’s when I realized that’s their StackOverflow. Combined with their existing training, I assume WebMD helps them make better judgement calls (definitely compared to a lay person self-diagnosing themselves). He then said, “well, none of the top causes really apply to your situation: you didn’t have a surgery recently and it’s impossible for you to get pregnant as a guy”. I was consequently referred to a hematologist.
- skwb 7y agoAlmost, but not quite right. Usually doctors and medical professionals use reference guides like Merk Drug Manual and Up To Date. They essentially fill in the gap somewhere between review articles (which can be a bit too specifically focused) and medical textbooks (which can be a bit overly broad in how they describe topics). These guides often provide the "typical" routine, but is then augmented by a physicians judgement.
- Medicalidiot 7y agoI hope that your physician didn't use WebMD. There are significantly better resources that are heavily vetted whereas WebMD is for the lay person.
- SkyPuncher 7y agoMy wife is a resident. She'll often does similar to verify she's not missing something obvious. In most cases, WebMD is simply agreeing with her pre-existing knowledge. Occasionally, it will present some other information - which she will research further to verify accuracy.
- vo2maxer 7y agoSome resources Doctors use: Medscape [1] which is owned by WebMD; Sources like MPR [2] for handy drug information and The Medical Letter [3] for in-depth medication reviews; UpToDate [4]; various journals depending on specialty, The New England Journal of Medicine being one of the most prestigious [5]; the Sanford Guide for infectious diseases [6]. [1] https://www.medscape.com/ https://www.medscape.com/ [2] https://www.empr.com/ https://www.empr.com/ [3] https://secure.medicalletter.org/ https://secure.medicalletter.org/ [4] https://www.uptodate.com/home https://www.uptodate.com/home [5] https://www.nejm.org/ https://www.nejm.org/ [6] https://www.sanfordguide.com/ https://www.sanfordguide.com/
- hinkley 7y agoI watch Youtubers build things, or just playing my favorite video game and while I learn a lot from them, sometimes I learn more from the times that I disagree with them. I was watching a video for a game I play, about a dogmatic approach to solving a particular problem and realized it had been min-maxed into the ground by bad math. By de-optimizing it a couple percent I could get 2 and a half beneficial outcomes instead of just the one. Given how time consuming the process is, it was madness to sink so much effort into solving only one problem. Of course having spotted something someone else missed, I've been staying up too late trying to validate my theory. Unfortunately my change barely made it any faster, and my first attempt to break it down into two phases didn't work out and ended up costing me more time than I had saved. Point is, I got all new nuances and areas to explore based on watching a video that I felt was provably wrong.
- Tyr42 7y agoNow I want to watch your video on this. What game?
- akira2501 7y ago> rather than learning from scratch. The idea of a medical equivalent to a "script kiddie" is a somewhat amusing mental image, though.
- russdill 7y agoMany medical schools now use Problem Based Learning (PBL) approach. Fewer textbooks are assigned and there are fewer lectures. Students are taught to track down the resources they need, books, journals, internet resources, etc. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Problem-based_learning#Medical_schools https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Problem-based_learning#Medical...