7 ms·
The title sounds intentionally provocative -- "face scanned" appears to be just "have their photo taken". I can't find a single source that suggests anything mo
by crazygringo 7y ago
The title sounds intentionally provocative -- "face scanned" appears to be just "have their photo taken". I can't find a single source that suggests anything more than that.
Which isn't much different from having your photo taken for your driver's license, passport, or at the border, all of which the US does.
Burner phones are mostly associated with criminal activity, so tying phones to identities feels like a legitimate function -- which many countries do. And if criminals are trying to register phones through identity theft, this seems like it would be an additional protection.
If you're concerned with privacy, that's what encrypted communications are for, and if you don't want to be tracked by radio, then don't take any phone with you.
- anigbrowl 7y agoIt would be valuable for technologists to be mindful of the difference between explanation and exhortation, lest they be seen as shifting the moral/legal burden for the operation of a social system entirely onto the shoulders of the individual users who have the least control over it.
- dang 7y agoOk, we've put "photo taken" in the title above. Thanks.
- kevcampb 7y agoIt's not "photo taken" https://www.hongkongfp.com/2019/12/02/china-tightens-cyberspace-controls-introducing-mandatory-face-scans-phone-users https://www.hongkongfp.com/2019/12/02/china-tightens-cybersp... A China Unicom customer service representative told AFP that the December 1 “portrait matching” requirement means customers registering for a new phone number may have to record themselves turning their head and blinking.
- dang 7y agoThanks—that's a better article. I've switched to the AFP version of it. (Submitted URL was https://www.technologyreview.com/f/614781/all-new-cellphone-users-in-china-must-now-have-their-face-scanned/. https://www.technologyreview.com/f/614781/all-new-cellphone-...) Reading it closely, though, the evidence on the face-scanning point seems weak. The source is a customer service representative who said may. That's two weak points: a customer service representative is not who you'd normally ask about policy, and "may" also means "may not". Also, that's the only thing that particular source is quoted about. I'm not sure what to do, because there doesn't seem to be anything unambiguous in the English-language press. All the articles I've looked are reporting on the same directive that was issued in Sept and took effect Dec 1. So I guess we'll quote the directive in the title above. If anyone can suggest a more accurate title we can change it again.
- CharlesColeman 7y ago> Burner phones are mostly associated with criminal activity, so tying phones to identities feels like a legitimate function -- which many countries do. And if criminals are trying to register phones through identity theft, this seems like it would be an additional protection. > If you're concerned with privacy, that's what encrypted communications are for... That's all true, but the real question is: what exactly is "criminal activity?" That's how a policy can be made to seem legitimate on the surface, but can actually be quite sinister when examined more closely. Policies like this one cannot be examined in isolation, and must be interpreted in context [1]. > If you're concerned with privacy, that's what encrypted communications are for... I'm pretty sure that E2E encrypted communication products are de-facto banned in China, at least for private citizens [2]. [1] https://www.nytimes.com/2017/07/25/magazine/the-lonely-crusade-of-chinas-human-rights-lawyers.html https://www.nytimes.com/2017/07/25/magazine/the-lonely-crusa... [2] https://www.scmp.com/news/china/policies-politics/article/2064587/chinas-move-clean-vpns-and-strengthen-great-firewall https://www.scmp.com/news/china/policies-politics/article/20...
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- threatofrain 7y ago> If you're concerned with privacy, that's what encrypted communications are for, and if you don't want to be tracked by radio, then don't take any phone with you. Then people like my mom get tracked and people like my nerdy friends don't. When one thinks of policy and consequence surely one doesn't simply say "well she exercised her agency, so that's that."
- Terr_ 7y ago> If you're concerned with privacy, that's what encrypted communications are for [...] Privacy includes who you communicate with, when, and how often... not just what you talk about. This is especially true when there might be an unscrupulous government willing to round up social circles for "re-education."
- salawat 7y ago>The title sounds intentionally provocative -- "face scanned" appears to be just "have their photo taken". I can't find a single source that suggests anything more than that. That's all you need for a face scan. You really don't understand how biometrics work do you? You just need a straight on mugshot. >Burner phones are mostly associated with criminal activity, so tying phones to identities feels like a legitimate function -- which many countries do. No, mobile prepaid phones are associated with activity where one does not wish to enter onto a full on Know-Your-Customer like relationship to their network. It is completely legitimate. China is just finding an excuse to try to collect biometrics associated with something basically every citizen is going to need to get by. >If you're concerned with privacy, that's what encrypted communications are for, and if you don't want to be tracked by radio, then don't take any phone with you. If you don't like the smog, you can just stop breathing. Just saying. If you don't like driver's licenses, you can just take a rickshaw across the country. Just saying. If you don't like the reeducation camps... When one flippantly dismisses the costs one's policy decisions will enact on one's countrymen, civilization is lost. Given government policy implemented so far, forgive me if I find the motives and applications of this information to be downright worrisome.