2 ms·
Ultimately you're just asking them for help in refining it into publishable form, so you should be first author, they should be second author. Only if you've f
by cperciva 18y ago
Ultimately you're just asking them for help in refining it into publishable form, so you should be first author, they should be second author.
Only if you've feeling very generous. I would acknowledge help received in a section at the end of the paper, but I would never list a co-author who didn't contribute any of the ideas.
- hugh 18y agoPerhaps we're estimating differently the amount of work which will be needed to turn this into an actual paper. But I've never published in a maths journal (only physics) so you probably know better than I do on this point.
- brent 18y agoIf I had to guess I would presume the OP has not done a formal analysis of the algorithm. This would undoubtedly be the contribution of the professor/researcher assuming the analysis proves it is an improvement over prior algorithms. This analysis/proof is certainly worth being a second author even if it is not a contribution to the algorithm itself.