6 ms·
I think this is silly. Unless Google can come up with a copyright claim on its search results, and I seriously doubt they can, they have nothing to complain abo
by cookiecaper 16y ago
I think this is silly. Unless Google can come up with a copyright claim on its search results, and I seriously doubt they can, they have nothing to complain about. I use Google's search results too -- information you pump out publicly can be used to the advantage of your customers as well as your competitors. If Google is scared that Bing is "stealing" their search results, they should quit making those results public in a way where people can "steal" them. Accept that freely available information is freely available or clamp down and stop publishing information that might help your competitors. In Google's case, unfortunately, the info that helps Bing is also the info that is essential to Google's customers.
I know of some other media companies that are hyper-paranoid about their mass produced, widely disseminated, public content being "stolen" by others, maybe Google should set up a lunch date with the RIAA.
- MichaelApproved 16y agoYour argument is seriously flawed. Just because something is made publicly available doesn't mean it's free and clear for anyone to reproduce. For example, if I don't chain my bike it doesn't mean anyone is allowed to steal it. Taking my bike is still a crime. How I protected it has nothing to do with the criminal act.
- cookiecaper 16y agoStealing a bike necessarily deprives a person of his property. Copying your competitors when they do something people like is a time-honored tradition and certainly not illegal as long as the copying occurs along certain guidelines. If Bing was scraping Google en masse and just putting a "Bing" interface on it, Google might have something here, but looking at Google's results and deciding they have some better results (and it's unclear if they even did that) and then making sure you have the same "better" results on your page too is not wrong, and deprives no man of his property. This is merely Google whining that Bing is delivering sort of good results because that threatens Google.
- MichaelApproved 16y agoThe stealing a bike example goes to counter the parent's argument that they can't complain if they don't protect their content. As to whether this is a crime or not would probably be a copyright issue. If Google had a valid legal claim I bet they'd make it in court.
- cookiecaper 16y agoYeah, as stated I really don't think they'll be able to claim a copyright infringement based on this, one link is not a copyrightable work. However, it's not that what Bing did is not criminal, it's that it's a non-issue; there is nothing wrong with keeping an eye on competitors directly or indirectly and implementing good ideas or products that you don't have. Everyone does this, it's just normal business. I don't know why Google cares or is making a big deal out of it, it just seems like whining to me, like they are mad that Bing can just manually compile a list of good results, even if those results come partially from Google. Sorry Google, that's just the nature of the format you're in and the game you're playing. A list of automatically-generated links with no custom or special content, much less a single link, would be a hard case to claim copyright protection, especially since for most actual queries it would be difficult to prove that Bing couldn't have come up with it independently. I see nothing wrong with it and nothing unfair about it. Do you think the Google guys developed and tweaked their algorithms in a vacuum when they were starting out? You don't think they ever brought up AltaVista or Yahoo! results for comparison and tweaked until they got the same (better) results? I've heard several times that Google constantly has people manually tweaking queries and results, totally extra-algorithmically, to make sure they provide good results for everything possible. So what if Bing does this too? Bing is even being accused of something much less direct. I just see no problem at all, it's just the way this is played.
- jedsmith 16y ago> If Google is scared that Bing is "stealing" their search results, they should quit making those results public in a way where people can "steal" them. I'm curious how you'd implement that idea.
- cookiecaper 16y agoIt's practically impossible for Google.
- billybob 16y agoSimple: you just have to put a EULA at the top of every search result page... ;)
- MikeCapone 16y agoIt's an appeal to the average person's "fair play" instinct. I'm not saying that they should or shouldn't do something like this, but it seems very effective. They have a perfect narrative for people to wrap their heads around, and even if nothing illegal was done, it still feels like Microsoft is doing something "wrong".
- neutronicus 16y agoEspecially since PageRank is "looking over the shoulder" of every content creator of the internet to do its thing.