5 ms·
Journalists are currently underpaid. Small newspapers are shutting down left and right. That's contributing to journalism going to hell.
by DoreenMichele 7y ago
Journalists are currently underpaid. Small newspapers are shutting down left and right.
That's contributing to journalism going to hell.
- chiefalchemist 7y agoTrue. But the biggest contribution is the big time mainstream media's race to the bottom. They're not focused on quality. They're focused on quantity (i.e., ad revenue).
- DoreenMichele 7y agoThat's another facet of the same issue. It's a little like arguing about whether the rampant dry tinder in the drought is the problem or the vast numbers of tourists flicking their still burning cigarette butts into it is the problem while we stare at the ongoing conflagration.
- chiefalchemist 7y agoI see it different. Given the importance of The Fourth Estate, the nature of TFE's business is, in and of itself, important. Yet, they bury that lead behind an endless stream of fluff.
- cmdshiftf4 7y ago>Journalists are currently underpaid Based on what? Their pay is surely a function of the revenue their content generates their publishers, no? >Small newspapers are shutting down left and right. Because the above journalists aren't sufficiently able to engage people to pay for their content. It amounts to people providing something that few are interested in, or especially sufficiently interested to actually pay for it. How would those providers be deemed underpaid? Sounds frivolous.
- DoreenMichele 7y agoI'm a writer (not a journalist) and I'm quite poor. So I pretty often read articles about what is going on with the industry generally. I'm not going to bother to dig up supporting links. These articles show up on HN quite regularly. I'm also increasingly seeing comments on HN about the poor quality of journalism today. I'm only pointing out what looks to me like a blindingly obvious connection. I spent two weeks writing a blog post that hit the front page of HN. It got more than 60k page views and 300 comments and was copied by other people. It made me not one red cent. I find it really hard to attract Patreon supporters. I'm routinely told "get a real job," never mind that with the rise of the Gig Economy there are damn few "real jobs" with good pay and excellent benefits out there. So I know firsthand that it takes substantial time and effort to write a good piece and it takes years of experience to get good at writing, but that writing is often de facto given away for free or sold for peanuts so some writer can eat occasionally. I"m tired of trying to prove this to people who don't want to listen. The TLDR: If you want actual good writing, you should be trying to figure out how to reward writers who write well. If you don't want to in any way, shape or form whatsoever (because most people on HN use ad blockers) let them get paid somehow, don't be all shocked when the writing goes to shit.
- cmdshiftf4 7y ago>The TLDR: If you want actual good writing, you should be trying to figure out how to reward writers who write well. If you don't want to in any way, shape or form whatsoever (because most people on HN use ad blockers) let them get paid somehow, don't be all shocked when the writing goes to shit. I don't think anyone disagrees with this overarching point whatsoever. My disagreement lies in the assertion that journalists are underpaid. Their pay is a reflection of the revenue they generate for their publishers, which itself is a reflection of the engagement their content provides for that publisher to monetize through ads, subscriptions or one-off purchases. The demand for quality journalism is now low, hence it generates little money and therefore those involved in it are rewarded little. I agree with you in that if people want quality journalism, they should pay for their content in some form. However, even if you got the entirety of the hackernews readership to pay for a subscription, you would not put a dent in the overall direction journalism is traveling in. Another option would be to have the government subsidize outlets, as is done in the UK with the BBC, Canada with CBC, Ireland with RTE, etc etc. This effort will be at the mercy of the taxpayer and can only provide so many jobs, and due to the nature of being state controlled will be subjected to, or dismissed entirely because of, claims of bias or propaganda. When the internet is pumping out limitless, "free" content, much of which uses manipulative behaviour to maximize engagement, mainstream outlets polarize politically and in doing so ostracize half their potential readership base, people's attention spans are continually shortening and intellectual curiosity shallowing, it's no surprise that quality will suffer hugely. It may be fair to say that it could well be beyond rescue at this point. But just an FYI: I maintain subscriptions to several newspapers and magazines. I'm personally more than happy to pay for the content I enjoy.