4 ms·
Thanks for your patience but this is still confusing. It's clear from your explanation that the moves and end-game states are given at the start of learning (no
by YeGoblynQueenne 7y ago
Thanks for your patience but this is still confusing. It's clear from your
explanation that the moves and end-game states are given at the start of
learning (now that you mention it, I remember the bit about illegal actions
leading to a game loss). So training does not start from scratch without
knowing anything about the game. The system knows what moves are _legal_ (not
just possible) and it knows when the game ends, and how to score it. I don't
see how this supports the claim of "no rules".
I appreciate that someone explaiend this to you at some point but I'm going
with what I've read in some of the published papers and the ones I've read
really leave a lot to the imagination. That is no way to present and support
such big claims as "no rules", "no hands", especially when this is the central
claim in a paper. Why fudge this so much when it's such an important aspect of
the whole contribution? [1] You (general you) make a claim? Support the claim.
I didn't get what you mean about logic programming? Where does that come in?
________________
[1] Oh, I know why. It's the whole silly game with machine learning publications
where they never tell you everything and you have to figure it out yourself.
Well I like to play the other game, where I call bullshit unless it's
explained clearly. In the paper. Not on Twitter and not by kind colleagues.
Silly games don't advance the science though.