4 ms·
> Ends the over-representation of small states and under-representation of large states in presidential voting and in the US Senate by eliminating small and lar
by ekianjo 7y ago
> Ends the over-representation of small states and under-representation of large states in presidential voting and in the US Senate by eliminating small and large states.
States are not regions of a larger nation. In Federalism they have a different history and different statuses, and the US has never been built as a direct democratic system. It's a Republic. Not sure what this list of bullet points is all about: changing everything about US politics?
- woah 7y ago> Keep in mind that this is an art project, not a serious proposal, so take it easy with the emails about the sacred soil of Texas.
- roenxi 7y agoThe whole point of the Electoral College is that it gives smaller states an advantage over larger ones. Imagining other scenarios is great fun, but the point needs to be stated - the Electoral College isn't failing when someone loses the popular vote and wins the election. That outcome is the sole purpose of having an electoral college. "Preserves the historic structure and function of the Electoral College." is almost precisely wrong. Equal-population states is a very fundamental change to the system. The advantages and disadvantages columns aren't engaging with the actual issues surrounding the electoral college.
- lotsofpulp 7y ago>The founding fathers established it in the Constitution as a compromise between election of the President by a vote in Congress and election of the President by a popular vote of qualified citizens. https://www.archives.gov/federal-register/electoral-college/about.html https://www.archives.gov/federal-register/electoral-college/... I don't think the statement above means the electoral college was about giving smaller states an advantage over larger ones. For one, the electoral college was developed during a time when communication was very difficult, and education and literacy was not as widespread. Conditions have changed, and it is possible the system is now too far skewed in one direction such that it no longer represents the people's wishes.
- roenxi 7y agoOk sure, but without having analysed electors vs. senator numbers that is probably tending towards a more extreme power differential than what I suggested. Instead of [other party voters] it would be [other party leadership figures]. And the outcome would be largely similar. The point is that it is a mechanism for overriding the popular vote. Ergo, whenever it swings into action it will be making a decision other than the popular one. They knew that when it was set up.
- masonic 7y agoa mechanism for overriding the popular vote So is CA's and NY's practice of awarding all electors to the plurality winner instead of proportionately.
- jrs235 7y agoThe President is supposed to faithfully execute the laws and abide by the Constitution. The States have a greater concern over who the arbiter and executor of their pact is than the general populace.
- netcan 7y agoI'm always confused by statements like "a republic, not a democracy." These words don't have clear, practical meanings. Words like republicanism, democracy, liberal democracy, democratic republic, etc are pretty abstract... and they were a lot more abstract 250 years ago. No nation state today is a "direct democracy," afaik. All of them are "representative democracies" with a congress/parliament. You can call that system a democracy, republic or whatever. Point taken about the historical (and current) reasons for federalism. That said, I don't see how/why redrawing states, electorates, changing how voting works, congress works or such has any bearing on a "democracy or republic" question. If you're into European history during the reformations/schisms, people of that period were obsessed with extremely abstract, theology/epistemology. Eucharistic metaphysics seemed important to them att, in retrospect it seems (literally) meaningless.
- jakeogh 7y agoRepublic, in the sense that we do not use majority rule; as it's inherently less stable and easier to break and cant protect inalienable rights and equal protection.
- netcan 7y agoOk... take non-republics with similar political cultures: Australia, UK Canada... You will find very similar "we do not use majority rule." they have states/state-like governments. Senates (for state reps), and lower houses (for district reps). There are some differences at the symbolic sovereignty level (queens, governor general's, etc.) Where does their lack of "unrepublic" differ to the US' republic, at the point where their voting, counting majorities, etc.
- jakeogh 7y agoAus has no free speech. UK is a class system where only one class gets to perserve life with effective tools. They dont due have process. Got stabbed? Here's a mandatory class: https://dailycaller.com/2019/07/01/london-bridge-hero-deradicalization/ https://dailycaller.com/2019/07/01/london-bridge-hero-deradi...
- xref 7y agoThis is a good writeup on why “it’s a republic not a democracy” is a meaningless argument: http://www.lawyersgunsmoneyblog.com/2016/11/durr-its-a-republic-not-a-democracy-durr-and-other-terrible-arguments http://www.lawyersgunsmoneyblog.com/2016/11/durr-its-a-repub... It also explains just how terrifying the Electoral College, where technically Electors and not voters have all the power, really is. > But a move by the electors to override the Electoral College and elect Clinton would be a disaster. Her presidency would be fatally hobbled from Day One. The potential for violence would be terrifying, and the presidential election system would be permanently broken—and the Republicans would declare any future Democratic winner an unqualified demagogue. The cure would be worse than the disease.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- Redoubts 7y agoThis is an incredibly dumb statement given how almost immediately, concerns about the balance of power between slave and free states were the main driver of how states were admitted and shaped. Not to mention the whole point of the EC was to give slave states more voice without enfranchising up to half their population living in bondage. What’s the point of alluding to history if you’re not going to even understand it?
- TMWNN 7y agoThe Electoral College's intention was to balance large states' power with small states' desire to not let large states run everything. The college had nothing to do with slavery or the Three Fifths Compromise. Slave states gained more power in the Electoral College from the extra 3/5 votes, but a) the compromise itself had nothing to do with the Electoral College's creation or design, and b) 3/5 of a vote gave less power to slave states than their preference, a full vote for each slave.
- Redoubts 7y ago> The Electoral College's intention was to balance large states' power with small states' desire to not let large states run everything. To pretend this is the only factor the designers had in mind it absurd. To ignore tensions between the north and south in the design of the system is equally so. > Slave states gained more power in the Electoral College from the extra 3/5 votes, You cannot look at something with massive implications and pretend they are accidental. Unless you want to admit it's poorly designed. > 3/5 of a vote gave less power to slave states than their preference, a full vote for each slave. Is there a point to this statement, other than to complain the North did not fully capitulate to slave power? -e- From Madison’s notes on the constitutional convention: > There was one difficulty however of a serious nature attending an immediate choice by the people. The right of suffrage was much more diffusive in the Northern than the Southern States; and the latter could have no influence in the election on the score of Negroes. The substitution of electors obviated this difficulty and seemed on the whole to be liable to the fewest objections. http://memory.loc.gov/cgi-bin/ampage?collId=llfr&fileName=002/llfr002.db&recNum=60&itemLink=r?ammem/hlaw:@field%28DOCID+@lit%28fr00218%29%29%230020061&linkText=1 http://memory.loc.gov/cgi-bin/ampage?collId=llfr&fileName=00...