2 ms·
The first sentence of the Wikipedia article is "Constructor theory is a proposal for a new mode of explanation in fundamental physics". Well, if it's a "new mo
by perl4ever 7y ago
The first sentence of the Wikipedia article is "Constructor theory is a proposal for a new mode of explanation in fundamental physics".
Well, if it's a "new mode of explanation", then the baseline expectation is that it doesn't add anything to all existing explanations of physics. The point of it would be to somehow allow explanations of things that were unexplainable before...
I mean, if you have a new way of explaining things, you have to derive all of the things we already know are true.
Edit:
The "Outline" at the bottom of the page doesn't sound like a profound new way of understanding the universe; it makes my bs meter twitch, but I don't see anything that provides a definitive reason to consider it all null.
- knzhou 7y agoYou’re completely correct: new modes of explanation can be extremely useful, and you can’t judge from the Wikipedia article alone because it can’t get to the meat! That’s why I had to read the papers. Turns out, the meat just isn’t there, it doesn’t exist. There aren’t any ideas beyond the vague popsci outline, which by itself does no good.