2 ms·
It seems to me that a basic requirement for not being an idiot is that you recognize hard problems as being hard, and I see a lot of supposedly smart people dec
by perl4ever 7y ago
It seems to me that a basic requirement for not being an idiot is that you recognize hard problems as being hard, and I see a lot of supposedly smart people declaring hard problems are easy because they're just ignoring tradeoffs or aspects of an approach that undermine it.
I'd think "everybody" knows, certainly I would expect Linus to know, about Postel's law and the subtle ways it ends up causing problems. Whenever you make things easy or difficult, you shape the evolution of how people do those things. There's no simple universal answer to "do we make things easy or difficult". Or "do we blame the user or the toolmaker?"
I don't really understand the psychology of going around arguing one side of an insoluble problem, observing that others are totally convinced of the other side, and occasionally flipping sides, but never acknowledging the meta-problem of integrating both or deciding when to apply each.
- dooglius 7y agoWhat do you think the "insoluble" problem is here?
- perl4ever 7y agoDeciding whether and how to influence the way people use a tool or product. Do you say "you're holding it wrong", or do you adjust to what people seem to be like? I mean, it's insoluble if treated as a single binary decision and not contextual.