3 ms·
I don't know how it is for turbines, but with pistons, an aviation engine is designed very differently from an automotive one, and one of the distinguishing fea
by userbinator 7y ago
I don't know how it is for turbines, but with pistons, an aviation engine is designed very differently from an automotive one, and one of the distinguishing features of the former is that it is designed to run at full load for much of its lifespan. In comparison, an automotive engine spends very little time at full load, even in a racing application. A plane needs a lot of continuous thrust just to keep it moving forward fast enough and generating lift, whereas a car moving at constant speed has to only counteract rolling friction and wind resistance.
- SteveNuts 7y agoDon't most airliners power way down at cruising altitude though?
- pdonis 7y agoThey power down some, but not much: the thrust of jet engines is significantly lower at typical cruising altitudes (because of reduced air density), so it takes almost as much power to cruise as to climb to altitude.
- selectodude 7y agoThat is not accurate. The efficiency of turbofans goes up as speed increases. A normal commercial high-bypass turbofan is at its most efficient around 1000 km/h, which is a speed it cannot sustain at lower altitudes due to air resistance over the blades. Just to add, at cruise, N1, the RPMs of the outermost fan on the jet, will peak over 100 percent, but that isn't a function of fuel consumption.
- pdonis 7y ago> The efficiency of turbofans goes up as speed increases. I didn't say efficiency, I said thrust. Nothing you said contradicts anything I said.
- selectodude 7y agoYou said that the engine has to burn as much fuel in cruise as it does during takeoff.
- pdonis 7y agoI said no such thing. I said the engine power had to be almost as high during cruise as during climb to altitude. Engine power setting is not the same as engine fuel consumption.
- colechristensen 7y agoWhen you say not much it's hard to agree or disagree, who knows what much is. Numbers can be added, about 80% is common for cruise altitude. The performance equations are not linear. One example another pointed out is that thrust goes up as you go faster, you point out that thrust goes down as density gets lower, it's both. There tend to be max/min points where the influence from one effect is overtaken by another.
- dsfyu404ed 7y agoIt's all in how you rate your engine. Comparing car engines to aircraft engines is apples to oranges since they are not rated the same way. An aviation engines leaves a decent amount of power on the table in order to be able to claim near continuous duty cycle . Look at their power outputs. They're abysmal compared to similar displacement automotive engines (for something using 100 octane) by the standards of the time they were designed because they are designed for continuous duty If car engines didn't care so much about max power they'd have a higher duty cycle at max power or conversely if aircraft engines cared more about max power it would be easy to make them output greater peak power at which they can't live almost indefinitely. The heavy equipment section of your local craigslist is littered with stuff powered by boring old automotive engines that are rated at a power output (slightly lower than what they would be rated at in cars/trucks) and given sufficient cooling to run indefinitely at that output.