6 ms·
The project founder’s wikipedia page: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Curtis_Yarvin https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Curtis_Yarvin It has leaked over to the projec
by sneak 7y ago
The project founder’s wikipedia page:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Curtis_Yarvin https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Curtis_Yarvin
It has leaked over to the project WP page:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Urbit https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Urbit
I personally choose not to run this software or support this project. YMMV.
- nothal 7y agoI agree that the founder has some pretty odious beliefs, chiefly racist, misogynistic, fascist, and the ilk. That said, Urbit is one of the most interesting projects I've seen.
- bronzejaguar 7y agoFounder isn’t associated with project anymore. Worth taking another look
- sneak 7y agoIt says he quit; it does not say he doesn’t still have equity.
- belisarius222 7y agofrom the FAQ: "In early 2019, Curtis left the Urbit project and gave all of his voting interest (both as address space and voting shares in the company) back to Tlon. He retains a non-voting, minority interest in both the address space and the company — but is not involved in the day-to-day development or operations."
- blotter_paper 7y agoWhy is the project still named after his Royalist blog? It's hard to take this distancing act seriously when the very title of your project is a fascist dog whistle.
- basilisks 7y agoCan you back up this claim?
- blotter_paper 7y agoHere is the ending of the second-to-last entry in Unqualified Reservations by Curtis Yarvin (AKA Mencius Moldbug)[0]: > Anyway. UR will reemerge, of course. But not here, and not soon—and probably not even in this form. I’ll also try to do something non-lame with the archives. Thanks for reading! If the name alone isn't enough, I feel like this context makes it pretty obvious that he named Urbit after his racist blog. [0]: https://www.unqualified-reservations.org/2014/08/hiatus/ https://www.unqualified-reservations.org/2014/08/hiatus/
- eoxenford 7y agoNo, Urbit is named after urbs, urbis, the Latin word for “city,” together with the computer term bit. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9677378 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9677378
- blotter_paper 7y agoHe claims to have been working on Urbit since 2002, and the first UR post was from 2007. It's entirely believable to me that the name Urbit came first (albeit not publicly), but the names are very obviously related and the quote I pulled above shows that he considers some post-2014 project a continuation of UR. I can believe the specific claims of the comment you linked, but I think it dances around the fact that these two projects are purposefully tied together by nomenclature. Whether UR or Urbit was named first in Yarvin's head isn't really the point.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- basilisks 7y agoIt’s an open-source project. Anyone can work on it or fork it. If you’ve got technical criticism, let’s hear it.
- maehwasu 7y agoThe reason I found Yarvin’s (awesome) writing in the first place was because of a post like this on Twitter. I figured that if vinegar-drinking scolds hated him, he might have something interesting to say. Your post will probably have a similar effect for a couple lucky people.
- pron 7y agoThe difference between Yarvin and vinegar-drinking scolds is that Yarvin merely repeats yesterday's vinegar-drinking scolds. If you like his writing, there's literally centuries' worth of it (in fact, it only stopped being the norm rather recently), and if you go study history at a university you'll read quite a lot of it. It does seem less fresh, though, once you read it in proper chronological order, and with appropriate context, rather than somebody posting a stuffy, safe, and dull 1897 text as a surprising, reactionary 2012 blog post. He served cold leftovers and seemed like a chef to people who'd never had a good meal.
- maehwasu 7y agoI actually agree strongly: one of the best things in his writing is his references to primary sources, many of which I found extremely enjoyable to read. The past is a foreign country more interesting than any tourist trip you can take. If the only thing the Moldbug posts did was link to that material, that would be a service in itself. To give Yarvin his due though, he does a good job synthesizing it all into a general theory of power being a necessary and sufficient explanation of motivations in most cases.
- pron 7y agoExcept for two problems: his understanding of the material is well below that of a first-year history student (he's a layman more than an amateur), and any decent college book or course contains far better references. Second, there is nothing new about his positions. They're a rehashing of the old mainstream, that was rejected over time because of societal and technological changes he doesn't know and certainly doesn't understand. As someone who studied both physics and history in grad school, his writing about history seems to make as much sense to someone who has actually learned that history as the multitude of texts about Reiki and channeling aliens that mention "quantum energy" make sense to someone who has actually studied physics. It only looks interesting (in a serious way) when you know virtually nothing. I read it in the same way I read about Reiki: a sort of curious anthropological entertainment from an epistemology that diverges sharply from science and scholarship. Sort of like a modern person would enjoy reading medieval texts about body humours or the four elements. So it's interesting to me to see the alternative constructions people who have no real scholarship make in order to understand the world around them.