8 ms·
The former soviet states are a great natural experiment in economics. Countries that liberalized their economies, like Estonia, Lithuania, Czech Republic, and L
by rayiner 7y ago
The former soviet states are a great natural experiment in economics. Countries that liberalized their economies, like Estonia, Lithuania, Czech Republic, and Latvia (the "mostly free" countries here: https://www.heritage.org/index/ranking https://www.heritage.org/index/ranking) have grown much faster than countries that retained socialism and central planning, like Ukraine, Belarus, and Moldova. See: https://www.theguardian.com/news/datablog/2011/aug/17/ussr-soviet-countries-data https://www.theguardian.com/news/datablog/2011/aug/17/ussr-s.... Remarkably, much of the economic growth came before Estonia, Lithuania, (Czechkia and Slovakia), and Latvia joined the EU. Indeed, their democratic and economic reforms, along with corresponding growth, paved the way for EU membership.
- sparkling 7y agoI would argue that in the case of Ukraine and Moldova, the main reason for their bad economy today is the large scale corruption that took place during post-soviet privatization in the 90s. This has lead to the extreme Oligarch power structure that we see today.
- literallycancer 7y agoCheck out Slovenia for a counterexample. You can do either approach badly or well.
- dsego 7y agoSince when is Slovenia a former soviet state?
- vkou 7y agoIt's not a former Soviet state, being a part of former Yugoslavia, which was a member of the non-aligned movement. It was, however, a stong-man communist dictatorship.
- atlasunshrugged 7y agoI'd also be curious the effect of EU funding - I know Estonia received hundreds of millions if not billions over the years on development and I'd guess it's much the same for Latvia/Lithuania as well
- lnsru 7y agoLook at Germany. It’s a better experiment. Former democratic part got billions from westerners and didn’t evolve far. They got basically new infrastructure build from western money, but people left former communistic paradise. Salary gap is still huge. That’s why Tesla picked location there and not in the western part of the country.
- TulliusCicero 7y agoThe US has similar variation in GDP per capita in its states, despite having had essentially the same economic system at least back to the civil war over 150 years ago.
- jogundas 7y agoA much more nuanced story can be told about Germany, see eg https://www.economist.com/europe/2019/10/31/germans-still-dont-agree-on-what-reunification-meant https://www.economist.com/europe/2019/10/31/germans-still-do... . When it comes to the Tesla factory, it will be right outside Berlin https://www.dw.com/en/tesla-factory-outside-berlin-to-cost-4-billion/a-51286353 https://www.dw.com/en/tesla-factory-outside-berlin-to-cost-4... .
- zzzcpan 7y agoOnly Belarus from your list didn't "liberalize" its economy and retained central planning.
- ernst_klim 7y agoAlso Belarus is benefiting mostly from 1) refining Russian oil, which they buy at lower prices, 2) gambling (which is illegal in Russia, so Russians go to Belarus) and 3) reselling European food to Russia to bypass Russian anti-sanctions. Their economy is quite shitty and simply parasitizing on Russia.
- Dolores12 7y agoGambling is legal in Russia in specific gaming zones.
- ernst_klim 7y ago>Gambling is legal in Russia in specific gaming zones. Which are virtually non-existent. https://www.vedomosti.ru/business/articles/2019/01/14/791383-igornie-zoni https://www.vedomosti.ru/business/articles/2019/01/14/791383...
- Dolores12 7y agoNon-existent gambling doesn't make it illegal.
- ernst_klim 7y ago> Non-existent gambling doesn't make it illegal. It's illegal outside special zones which are virtually non-existent. Yes, it's virtually illegal.
- Dolores12 7y agoSpecial zones are inside of Russia. So in fact gambling in Russia is not illegal, it is limited to special zones.
- guzey 7y agoYou cannot use this as an example of a natural experiment. Natural experiment features external variation. In contrast, the amount of liberalization of the economy likely had a lot to do with the country's history, e.g. Ukraine's markets had been less developed than Estonia's before Soviet Union and as a result they couldn't afford to liberalize as much.
- grussergraph 7y agoThis is like saying expressways are better than sidewalks because they support a higher speed limit. A fundamental argument for socialism was always to avoid being beholden to the infinite growth requirement of capitalism.
- petre 7y agoSadly the EU is not that eager on taking new memberships right now. Look at North Macedonia and Albania's potential membership negotiations getting initially opposed we are too busy right now and then conditioned by France ok, but one step at a time.
- dep_b 7y agoAfter the backlash they got after opening up the borders with Bulgaria and especially Romania it would be political suicide to open up for Albania.
- ChuckNorris89 7y agoWhy was the backlash for Romania greater than the one for Bulgaria?
- sam_lowry_ 7y agoRomania is bigger
- dep_b 7y agoLots of organized begging and pickpocketing in European cities by people from Romania, apart from the usual complaints that most European European countries got.
- petre 7y agoPickpoketing was already rampant in certain big European cities without the Eastern Europeans.
- arcturus17 7y agoNot GP but in Spain we have ton of Romanians, and it’s one of the most popular “blame the immigrant” targets. You can see how that becomes a political problem. (I don’t agree with those views, I’ve been to the country a couple times and I think the culture and the people are beautiful)
- jayalpha 7y ago"The former soviet states are a great natural experiment in economics." More about history. "Countries that liberalized their economies, like Estonia, Lithuania, Czech Republic, and Latvia (the "mostly free" countries here: https://www.heritage.org/index/ranking https://www.heritage.org/index/ranking) have grown much faster than countries that retained socialism and central planning, like Ukraine, Belarus, and Moldova" Estonia, Lithuania, Czech Republic and Latvia were tech hubs during soviet time. Ukraine, Belarus and Moldova much much less, relying on stuff like mining and heavy industries. Your comment makes as much sense as saying: Fertilizer is always good business. Look at Belarus, they have one of the biggest Potash producers in the world (Belaruskali). Why did the baltic states not just copy this? Or take Georgia, a country listed as having a lot of poor people in the Bloomberg article. Georgia's economic freedom score is 75.9, making its economy the 16th freest in the 2019 Index. Before you talk about "great natural experiment in economics" you may want to apply some reasoning.
- rayiner 7y agoGeorgia suffered a massive civil war from the time the Soviet Union fell until 1995, that caused its GDP per capita to fall by 2/3 to 1995. The economic reforms happened in the 21st century and growth since then has been very quick. From Wikipedia: > Since the early 21st century visible positive developments have been observed in the economy of Georgia. In 2007, Georgia's real GDP growth rate reached 12 percent, making Georgia one of the fastest-growing economies in Eastern Europe. The World Bank dubbed Georgia "the number one economic reformer in the world" because it has in one year improved from rank 112th to 18th in terms of ease of doing business. Georgia improved its position to 6th in World Bank's Doing Business report 2019.
- sam_lowry_ 7y agoWhat civil war?
- cbnotfromthere 7y agoWhat civil war? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Georgian_Civil_War https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Georgian_Civil_War
- kome 7y agoIf you comment about those issues, it would be nice you knew something about it. Ukraine is very liberalized economy, perhaps more than in the west - and yes, the results are less than stellar, for a complex number of reasons. About Estonia, Lithuania, Latvia the economic results seem OK, but the social one is close to tragedy: in 3 Baltic countries emigration has been terrible, and the lost a large part of their population, threatening the social fabric. https://www.oecd-ilibrary.org/social-issues-migration-health/coping-with-emigration-in-baltic-and-east-european-countries_9789264204928-en https://www.oecd-ilibrary.org/social-issues-migration-health... Your comment is pure ideology.
- tasubotadas 7y agoWhy is emigration bad? It is good. People who left started earning more, and people who stayed, started earning more. The only ones who see that in a bad light are pro-nationalist lackeys that put the state above an individual person. It's a win-win.
- sam_lowry_ 7y agoIndustry and even agriculture decline in Baltics are a major reason for emigration. The old EU countries got cheap labour and killed competition. Do you really think the Ignalina power plant was closed for environmental reasons? And the lack of funds for the trans-baltic railway, was it due to these countries lack of cooperation?
- AndriyKunitsyn 7y ago>people who stayed, started earning more Citation needed on this one.
- scottlocklin 7y agoUkraine liberalized its economy and it pretty much destroyed the place. The whole GDP growth fetish is a lot of horse shit; some measure needs to be taken that the increase in GDP doesn't destroy the lives of some large swathe of the population like it did in Russia. Belarus may be led by a repressive dictator, but the fact that it didn't experience the absurd declines in life expectancy and quality of life in the 90s that Russia did will keep him popular, even if they do have to pay more for oil.
- sodosopa 7y ago> Ukraine liberalized its economy and it pretty much destroyed the place. The Russian invasion destroyed the place.
- NaggingGranpa 7y agoDon't be thick. A handful of oligarchs seizing all the wealth created by Soviet "slave" labor and sharing very little did destroy Ukraine long before the loonies in Lviv decided to overthrow the shameless crook from the Donbas.
- sodosopa 7y ago> Overthrow Oh you mean the invading Russian forces. https://foreignpolicy.com/2019/08/02/russian-disinformation-distorted-reality-in-ukraine-americans-should-take-note-putin-mueller-elections-antisemitism/ https://foreignpolicy.com/2019/08/02/russian-disinformation-... > By the next morning, soldiers in unmarked uniforms had taken the Crimean parliament and raised the Russian flag. Throughout the day, the little green men—as the irregular Russian soldiers came to be known—fanned out across the city, capturing government buildings. Soon, behind closed doors and under Russian guns, the autonomous region’s parliament voted to request Russian security assistance.
- NaggingGranpa 7y agoUtterly irrelevant. Your point was that Ukraine's economic problems are due to the Russian invasion, which is false. Losing the Donbas may have made things a bit worse, but Ukraine was an economic basketcase since the collapse of the USSR and it remains one.
- xiler 7y agoNote though that when many of the former soviet economies liberalized some of their economic and social outcomes were initially not so great. They experienced high inflation and, in some cases, a sharp drop in life expectancy. [1,2] I understand that some economists explain the high inflation by saying that pent-up demand was "unleashed" after the Soviet Union collapsed. To me this seems kinda hand-wavy (is it possible to measure pent-up demand?). On a related note, something that comes close to a natural experiment is a comparison of the economic history of Finland and Russia. Finland was part of the Russian empire and, like the rest of Russia, was very poor at the time. It then broke away during the civil war, which is, of course, around the time that Soviet communism began to take root. Meanwhile, a little later, Finland took took a different economic path and instead implemented some social democratic policies and is now per capita richer than Russia and indeed many countries in Europe. [3] [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Transition_economy#Transition_in_practice https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Transition_economy#Transition_... [2] https://data.worldbank.org/indicator/SP.DYN.LE00.IN?locations=RU-LV-EE-LT https://data.worldbank.org/indicator/SP.DYN.LE00.IN?location... [3] I realize Finland is not a perfect social democratic economy, but it is a closer approximation than most European economies
- cosmodisk 7y agoEven during soviet occupation, all of the Baltic countries were already way ahead,compared to the likes of Azerbaijan or Kazachstan. There are many more reasons,such as mentality, culture, geographical location and education that influenced it. Economical model was only one piece of the whole picture.
- ghostwriter 7y ago> There are many more reasons,such as mentality, culture, geographical location and education that influenced it. These traits are the same in Korea, yet there's a drastic difference between South and North.
- discobot 7y agoEstonia and Lithuania despite democracy and economic reforms are well known money laundromats for Russian oligarchy (see for example https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Danske_Bank_money_laundering_scandal https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Danske_Bank_money_laundering_s...).
- stebann 7y agoAnd I think you're a liberal biased man...