3 ms·
This is mostly huffing and puffing by museums. In the US, this was settled in Bridgeman vs. Corel, in 1999, and reinforced by Meshwerks vs. Toyota, which extend
by Animats 7y ago
This is mostly huffing and puffing by museums. In the US, this was settled in Bridgeman vs. Corel, in 1999, and reinforced by Meshwerks vs. Toyota, which extended that to 3D scans.
This is effectively settled law. The best demonstration of this is that Wikipedia operates on the principle that scans of public domain art can be included in Wikipedia, and the Wikimedia Foundation is willing to go to court over that. The National Portrait Gallery in the UK did start a lawsuit once, but backed down. After 20 years, no claim of copyright on a copy of a public domain image seems to have gone anywhere in court.
- nkurz 7y agoThanks, unlike the linked article, this argument gets at the core of the matter: if the scan was not an artistic creation, it is not eligible for copyright protection. Here's a summary of Meshworks v Toyota: https://www.intellectualpropertylawblog.com/archives/meshworks-inc-v-toyota-motor-sales-u-s-a-good-news-and-bad-news-for-creators-of-new-media-works https://www.intellectualpropertylawblog.com/archives/meshwor... Interestingly, I wonder if you could make the argument that the "illicit trench coat scanning" would have been an artistic creation falling under copyright, but a higher grade commercial scan (as this now appears to be) does not. It thus makes me wonder if this might have been part of the reason for the cover story. Are there more exact cases where a court has ruled that a 3D scan is not artistic? I've been surprised how low the threshold seems to be for photographic works, with "cropping" sometimes seeming to qualify. I wouldn't find it impossible for a court to decide that human decisions on how the raw model was cleaned up might deserve similar consideration. But you seem confident that they will not?
- bjelkeman-again 7y agoIn Sweden the highest court ruled that the distribution of photographs of public art is a breach of copyright. Wikimedia got sued and lost. https://blog.wikimedia.org/2017/07/25/wikimedia-sweden-freedom-panorama/ https://blog.wikimedia.org/2017/07/25/wikimedia-sweden-freed...
- tastroder 7y agoIn Germany, the country in question here, the current stance of the federal supreme court (links to Wikipedia case below, ruling is dated 12/2018) seems to be that even photography of public domain works can retain copyright with the museum. To be clear, I find both that stance and the behaviour of the organisation behind the museum appaling but I'm really not sure how US copyright law or unrealized EU directives are all that relevant. Intellectual property rights in Germany are complicated and when in doubt usually err on the side of copyright holders. http://ipkitten.blogspot.com/2019/02/digitized-images-of-works-in-public_19.html?m=1 http://ipkitten.blogspot.com/2019/02/digitized-images-of-wor... https://dejure.org/dienste/vernetzung/rechtsprechung?Text=I%20ZR%20104/17 https://dejure.org/dienste/vernetzung/rechtsprechung?Text=I%...
- cxr 7y agoThis doesn't refute what Animats wrote. In copyright law, "public domain" has a very specific meaning (and it's not "art displayed in public").