4 ms·
Are there many places that have elected judges? Why not require law degrees? It’s not like “elected” must mean “can’t require qualifications”?
by alkonaut 7y ago
Are there many places that have elected judges?
Why not require law degrees? It’s not like “elected” must mean “can’t require qualifications”?
- erentz 7y agoIt’s one of the stranger things about the US. Electing not just judges but also coroners and sheriffs and prosecutors.
- Balgair 7y agoTo be fair, with coroners it's more out of necessity than anything. One of the counties next to mine has few coroners and it's something of a problem, as you can imagine. We recently had a friend die and the coroner's report is still not complete, three weeks later. We still don't know what the cause of death is, and as it's suspected to to be a suicide, it's not been a fun time waiting for the results to come out. An elected coroner could relieve the burden by preforming reports on 'mundane' deaths and leave the more complicated cases to more experienced people. Again, it's not a good solution by any means, but it's a better solution than the one they have currently.
- beagle3 7y agoBut why elected rather than hired? It’s supposed to be a mostly scientific job with no agenda.
- t-writescode 7y agoPrestige of being an elected office might draw more candidates to an otherwise undesirable job
- Teknoman117 7y agoI would argue that we'd be better off not electing the prestige seeking people. We want the best person for the job, not someone viewing high offices as a prize.
- beagle3 7y agoIt might also draw candidates who are better at running a campaign than at doing the work - in fact, it is most likely. For almost all jobs, the common way of doing that is improve compensation and/or working conditions, and I see no reason a coroner should be different.
- Balgair 7y agoBecause it is difficult to get people that are so well trained to work in that county, yet the work needs to be done. Many counties require that a coroner be a licensed MD with training/experience in the coroner's office. These costs necessitate a high salary to pay off such educational investments and also due to supply and demand. That particular county is very poor and there is little to attract such caliber of people outside of money. Money that largely does not exist. So, one solution is to take anyone that will volunteer for the job. One way to sugarcoat this is to elect the coroner and make it seem like 'the people' have taken this risk upon themselves. Sure, many elected coroners are well trained and very good at their jobs. But those people are not the issue. Having massively undertrained people do this job is glaringly stupid on just so many levels, but what other option exists? The job market has spoken.
- beagle3 7y agoSame things can be said about practically any professional job. If the job is required, it should pay market salary, as it does in essentially every other profession. Why not elect system administrators? Everything you mention is true of them in many places as well.
- Balgair 7y agoI mean, I'm not arguing for this method, it is obviously crazy and has contributed to a lot of issues in other parts of the country [0]. I'm just giving the rationale I have heard from others. [0] https://www.newsweek.com/2016/10/28/teen-suicide-contagious-colorado-springs-511365.html https://www.newsweek.com/2016/10/28/teen-suicide-contagious-...
- beagle3 7y agoThanks, appreciate your response, though I must say it sounds like a post-factum rationalization to an existing practice, and not the real reason it got this way.
- DanBC 7y agoIt's really weird to me to see US reporting on suicide. Journalists understand that suicide is contagious, but take no responsibility to decontaminate their own writing. The report you linked is written in a dangerous way. It will cause death.
- tssva 7y agoNeither judges or coroners are elected in all states. Prosecutors are almost everywhere. Sheriff's are elected but in many places are not the chief local law enforcement officer. In many places there is a police force which is led by an appointed police chief. In this situation the sheriff's office is usually limited to courthouse security and serving summons. The original thought behind electing judges was that they are an equal branch of government which provides a check on the executive and legislative branches so having them appointed by the branches they are suppose to provide a check against makes no sense. Also this article is about appointed and not elected judges.
- x86_64Ubuntu 7y agoMore often than not, the Sheriff is the highest lawman in the county. Police chiefs work for metros. Like we have the NYPD, but there are also the Kings County Sheriff
- sonthonax 7y agoBritain’s lower courts are presided by magistrates. There isn’t even an election. It’s a simple interview and a application form. https://www.gov.uk/become-magistrate/apply-to-be-a-magistrate https://www.gov.uk/become-magistrate/apply-to-be-a-magistrat... While there are supposedly checks on their powers, abuses though sheer incompetence happen.
- iam-TJ 7y agoHowever, all Magistrate Courts have a Clerk to the Justices who is qualified and advises the magistrates on the law at hearings and handles other court functions. "A person can only be designated if he/she has a five-year magistrates' court qualification, was a barrister or solicitor who had served for not less than five years as an assistant to a justices' clerk, or had previously been a justices' clerk" https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Justices%27_clerk https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Justices%27_clerk
- chrismeller 7y agoThis also applies to law enforcement. Many small towns have elected sheriff’s (or police captains or whatever they call them locally). How is that right? Sure, maybe they have to convince a county DA that there was a crime for actual prosecution, but the number of areas they could abuse their power before (or completely without) charges is insane. Look at it from the viewpoint of the Andy Griffith show... the circuit judge only shows up every few months. Do you really want to sit in jail until then, or do you want to take the deal/admit your fault/rat someone else out... whether he’s got enough evidence against you or not, you’re still in jail, losing your job, getting your kids taken from you...
- basementcat 7y agoI think the idea is that the electorate has the responsibility of making sure office holders are qualified. If a small town decides that someone with no law enforcement experience is the most qualified candidate to be sheriff, then that is their choice.
- BurningFrog 7y ago> How is that right? It's democracy. It has its pros and cons.
- analog31 7y agoThe Wisconsin Supreme Court is elected.
- basementcat 7y agoI actually think the most troubling aspect of elected judges is the amount of money they have to raise every few years just to keep their job. I suppose this isn't all that different from technical fields (PI's have to write grant proposals, entrepreneurs have to give pitches) so maybe its not that big of a deal.
- alkonaut 7y agoHow do they do that without accepting money from either local business or individuals (which would be problematic as soon as those individuals or businesses find themselves in court)?
- basementcat 7y agoMy understanding is they do accept money from local businesses and individuals. Perhaps it is no more or less problematic than a PI publishing something a sponsor doesn’t like or a startup disrupting another company in the same VC portfolio. EDIT: John Oliver did a bit on this a few years back. Access may be restricted outside USA. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=poL7l-Uk3I8 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=poL7l-Uk3I8
- roenxi 7y agoAt heart, if the law is so complicated that only a trained professional can interpret it then it is unreasonable to ask people to follow the law. The people vote for the law so it isn't actually that obvious why their voice should then be abstracted away and filtered out from enforcing and interpreting the law. I am certainly more comfortable formally restricting positions of power to the over-educated elite; although rather those with technical degrees over legal ones. But from that perspective it is clear to me why a polity might prefer not to have a legal degree as a requirement.
- TheOtherHobbes 7y agoThis is like expecting physics, engineering, or medicine to be simple. Law is inherently complex - partly by design, partly because of politics, but also because law is based on established concepts that are non-trivial. Even a supposedly simple concept like "guilty" includes shades of culpability that an untrained view won't appreciate. This has a direct and very obvious effect on the level of fairness and justice available in the legal system. So no - generally you do not want untrained people making important decisions about other people's lives. Ideally you want people with wisdom, maturity, and strong personal integrity making those decisions. If that's not available - it often isn't - then a professional knowledge of precedent and case law is the next best thing. Lawyers are only over-educated in the sense that law is also about manipulating juries, judges, and other lawyers through drama, rhetoric, and grandstanding. Essentially you can win a case by putting on a good show rather than winning on facts and substance. And that's not a good thing, because it has no relationship to justice. Without that element - or at least with much less of it - lawyers would have to work harder, but the results would be fairer.
- credit_guy 7y agoI like your argument. I'll offer a different view, but I want to emphasize upfront that I'm not disagreeing with you. American football has many rules. Tens of millions of people follow it, and if asked, most will tell you that they know the rules. But, being a game with more than 100 years of history, it accrued plenty of obscure rules that come up infrequently. Referees are expected to know all these rules, and react in a split of a second to uphold the rules. A few years ago there was a labor dispute between the NFL and the referees, and it resulted in substitute referees for a few weeks. I think most people remember that period as a period of great frustration. It's very likely the substitutes knew the rules too, but not having the experience and the proper training/reflexes, the way they upheld the rules was a bit lacking. Football players are too familiar with the rules, are expected to follow them, and they generally do. But if you try to ask a player to be a referee, he will probably suck just as much as one of those substitutes.