3 ms·
You want medical practice dispensed by the median doctor not the median patient. The median voter already sits on juries.
by michaelmrose 7y ago
You want medical practice dispensed by the median doctor not the median patient. The median voter already sits on juries.
- roenxi 7y agoBut the only similarity between a judge and a doctor is they both traditionally require degrees. If we accept that a judge doesn't need a degree then there is no comparison to a doctor. Ie, that is probably a form of circular reasoning. Degrees might be a reasonable proxy for general intelligence which is nice to have in a judge, but so is popular support. We already let any fool off the street write the law, they should also be qualified to interpret the law.
- chongli 7y agothey should also be qualified to interpret the law The problem with this is that our system is built on literally centuries of case law, in addition to all the legislation. Fools off the street don't know any of that stuff. Are we going to wait around while they spend weeks doing the research for every case? We already let any fool off the street write the law Foolish legislators often have their laws struck down for being unconstitutional. If we're going to let fools also be judges, then the inmates are running the asylum and we might as well not have a constitution at all.