3 ms·
> It’s intellectually interesting, but nobody could actually dance to it. In Dungeons and Dragons terms, the song has astronomical Intelligence, fairly high Cha
by egypturnash 7y ago
> It’s intellectually interesting, but nobody could actually dance to it. In Dungeons and Dragons terms, the song has astronomical Intelligence, fairly high Charisma, and low to medium Wisdom. I’d rather hear all this craft being poured into a straightahead groove that’s more amenable to audience participation.
It's kinda nice to see someone getting all elitist about Music Should Be Danceable; usually when I see this sort of attitude it's connected to people sneering at music that makes people wanna shake their asses for being "simple".
But there's lots of things you can do with music, and some of them are danceable, and some of them are most emphatically not. You can't dance to bebop, you can't dance to Gregorian chants, you can't dance to ambient. And if this Collier dude wants to chase cold intellectual undanceable thrills and has an audience willing to pay him to do this, then it ain't my problem if I don't like that, there's an uncountable number of other musicians, past and present, who have made music chasing other goals.
Personally this was the first I'd heard of Collier and he's not doing much for me. I'm not at a point in my life where I wanna hear cold crystalline overdubs of one white dude's voice. But whatever.
- fredsanford 7y ago>> cold crystalline overdubs I do not mean this to be harsh or nasty, but there are no goosebumps. Needs some grease from Stax or some touches of Motown. Booker T and the MGs, Wilson Pickett, Otis Redding, Ray Charles, something... is... just... missing...
- egypturnash 7y agoIt did nothing for me either. A vaguely pleasant noise. But he won a Grammy and has a bazillion subscribers, so obviously there’s an appeal there for people who are not you or I. There’s people who love living in Northern places who will rhapsodize endlessly about the joys of winter and snow and being all cozy and shit, I think they’re crazy but I’m glad they exist so they don’t all try to live in the places I like. Same thing. It ain’t for you, me, or the author of this post about it, and that’s fine.