10 ms·
This is better both for San Francisco and Texas, from a load-balancing perspective. Unless housing can catch up, large companies shouldn't be expanding in San F
by skybrian 7y ago
This is better both for San Francisco and Texas, from a load-balancing perspective. Unless housing can catch up, large companies shouldn't be expanding in San Francisco.
- zer00eyz 7y agoHousing and taxes in CA are close to oppressive. The housing situation will not change unless CA voters agree to a change in property taxes and they won't. I would also bet that the move will come at the expense of Texas tax payers and to the benefit of Schwabb.
- skybrian 7y agoWhile California taxes are high, this doesn't seem to be the main reason that building more housing is difficult? For that you can blame zoning restrictions and political opposition.
- zer00eyz 7y agoThat is a piece of it. But the housing market lacks liquidity due to prop 13. When your tax basis doesn't reflect the value of your property and doesn't keep up with inflation it makes NO sense for you to move in response to market conditions. Not building housing increases the value of what I already own, and the tax policy means I don't face the economic pressure to change any of it. The two are deeply linked and going to be nearly impossible to change.
- TulliusCicero 7y agoPart of the problem with housing prices in California is that property taxes are too low. Prop 13 means existing homeowners are shielded from higher property taxes, so growing property values are only good for them, no matter how high. Thus, there's no incentive to increase housing supply, which could lower prices.
- justinzollars 7y agoThe problem with housing in California is that we do not build it because regulations prohibit new housing. Look at a zoning map in San Francisco. Housing is illegal.
- ethbro 7y agoI believe the full reasoning is that (1) if property owners paid property taxes on the full market value of their property, then (2) they would lobby for (or at least cease opposition against) upzoning for density, and (3) more dense housing would be legalized and built.
- rizwank 7y agoCan you help me understand how #1 becomes #2?
- TulliusCicero 7y agoIn most parts of the country, there's both an upside and downside to increasing property values to landowners. Upside: they're worth more, they could sell and move somewhere else cheaper, pocketing the money, or they could rent out their place for more. Downside: they have to pay higher ongoing property taxes. Most landowners still like increasing property values, but it's not all good for them. With prop 13, the downside is wiped out. Increasing values are only good; they could increase 10x overnight and this would only make landowners filthy rich, there's no negative effect for them. Ergo, they have every incentive to keep housing supply constrained, to keep voting for politicians and policies that limit housing density.
- ethbro 7y agoAnd to bear specifically on the sub-point that blights the Bay Area -- by removing increasing property taxes, you are removing market pressure for highest and best use. Another way to think about property taxes is that they're annual nudges to encourage best use of the property. Without that pressure, as TulliusCicero notes, why would I ever sell before retirement? And furthermore, why would I even try to make money off the property (say, by renting)? That's probably not in the city's (as in, all the people living there) best interest to have a substantial portion of homeowners so disengaged from the actual market. PS: Which isn't to say there aren't gentrification and affordable housing debates to be had. Simply that Prop 13 doesn't really help with that -- it just removed risk from those who are already homeowners.
- galangalalgol 7y agoProperty taxes in fort worth are ~2.85%. What is bay area?
- burlesona 7y agoCloser to 1%.
- ramses0 7y agoAsterisk: Texas has no state income tax, but has a higher property tax rate.
- downrightmike 7y agoZero until the house is sold.
- jogjayr 7y agoThe Bay Area's problem isn't absolute tax rates. It's that taxes aren't calculated on current property value, but on original sale price. This keeps effective tax rates low if you bought earlier. It also discourages redevelopment, rezoning, or anything else that would bring more supply into the market.
- thatfrenchguy 7y agoAren’t taxes highly regressive in Texas with sky high property taxes which exempt rich people ?
- crikli 7y agoThe property taxes are sky high, yes, but they most definitely do not exempt the rich. There is no state income tax. I wouldn’t call the state’s general tax structure progressive or regressive.
- kyralis 7y agoProperty taxes are inherently more regressive than income taxes, since since property (either directly or through rents) nearly always consumes a larger portion of the income/wealth of lower-means individuals.
- whokal 7y agoIt's not obvious to me that you can't also have a progressive / marginal tax system for property taxes based on home valuations (e.g. home values >$1MM taxed higher than those worth $200K). So, I don't think property taxes are inherently regressive. That said, I don't think it's enough to just look at one tax. We have to consider taxes and regulations as a whole to understand whether a place is overall regressive or not. This leaves room for different implementations of tax policy which if done correctly will benefit the people.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- mifreewil 7y agoI would say overall California’s high income and sales taxes and low property taxes are far, far more regressive, see this at the extreme: https://www.latimes.com/politics/la-pol-ca-california-property-taxes-elites-201808-htmlstory.html https://www.latimes.com/politics/la-pol-ca-california-proper...
- scarface74 7y agoSure there is another way for it to change. Companies start moving out of California, the employees follow and the demand lessens.
- fortran77 7y agoGiant companies get to personally negotiate their own favorable property tax rates. If people goose-step to the polls in 2020 to confiscate additional property from commercial property owners in the form of increased property taxes [1], the mega-corporations won't pay a cent of it. The mom an pop business that give SF its character, however, will be driven out of business. [1] https://www.sfchronicle.com/politics/article/Change-in-California-s-Prop-13-makes-2020-13314983.php https://www.sfchronicle.com/politics/article/Change-in-Calif...
- justinzollars 7y agoThe attitude here is we are fully developed and thus done developing. I don't imagine a bright future for California with these housing policies.
- BurningFrog 7y agoI don't see a bright present: "The poverty rate, when adjusted for the cost of living, is the worst in the nation" https://www.bloomberg.com/graphics/2019-california-housing-crisis/ https://www.bloomberg.com/graphics/2019-california-housing-c...
- justinzollars 7y agoMore on no bright present: https://thehill.com/changing-america/respect/poverty/471332-san-franciscos-homeless-population-may-be-more-than-double https://thehill.com/changing-america/respect/poverty/471332-...
- BurningFrog 7y agoI'd say that if you're not a tech company there is no reason to pay the premium cost of being in SF.
- pascalxus 7y agoI agree. With the way thins are here, I'm often surprised we don't see more companies leaving SF.