3 ms·
The point they are making is that the inflation index doesn't properly account for increase in quality that these technological innovations are offering. In fac
by TimPC 7y ago
The point they are making is that the inflation index doesn't properly account for increase in quality that these technological innovations are offering. In fact many measures treat a 1992 cell phone as an interchangeable good with a 2019 state of the art smartphone and in that basket of goods the cost of a phone has risen substantially. Never mind that the 2014 phone that's free with a contract can do stuff that in 1992 we didn't even imagine a phone doing.
Similarly, by treating health care as a single good and ignoring all the new treatments that get introduced we see the cost of healthcare is dramatically up. But the cost of getting a treatment that didn't exist in the time period was infinity. Regardless, patient outcomes are better too on a per condition basis so the treatment quality has gone up too.
I'm not sure many people would take the option to pay a 1970 price for a 1970 standard of health care if they could have that choice now. But the inflation indices treat 1970 healthcare and 2019 healthcare as almost interchangeable.
For education, my 2nd year undergrad course used a textbook that was a grad school book at MIT in the 1960's so the material being taught has advanced too. Again, interchangeable good in the index.
If inflation is wrong, then most measures of inequality are also wrong because inflation adjusted incomes are wrong.
- riversflow 7y agoI can’t afford healthcare at all, but I have to pay for it regardless, either through fines or insurance. I’d take 1970’s prices and service over today’s if I could. Your anecdote about education being better goes absolutely against what I’ve seen first hand. My parents, who went to College ~40 years ago, paid a fraction of what people do today even accounting for inflation, and the quality was far higher. Smaller class sizes and higher standards than today’s student loan fueled universities, meant that getting a degree was a big deal, unlike today.
- Gibbon1 7y agoIf the quality of healthcare is up why has life expectancy declined for the last three years?