10 ms·
The successor of SMS has already been hacked
- kerm1t 7y agoDisclosure: I work for SRLabs, the company who did this research. You can find more infos on our blog release: https://srlabs.de/bites/rcs-hacking/ https://srlabs.de/bites/rcs-hacking/
- panpanna 7y agoGreat work! So this is mostly on Google's implementation? Or is RCS insecure in general?
- 3fe9a03ccd14ca5 7y agoI don't think you need to add a disclaimer if you use qualifiers such as "our".
- macintux 7y agoWithout it, someone will ask for confirmation that "our" really means "our", and someone else will complain about the lack of a disclaimer.
- notlukesky 7y agoWhen did carriers ever get anything tech based right? In fact to expect them is wrong as their business model is very different to a tech company. They are beneficiaries of law-bound limited duopolies or oligopolies. In most countries the only audience they care for are the regulators, and not consumers or their security and safety. Regulatory capture is a wonderful thing for these companies and not for consumers.
- gimmedanger 7y ago... he said, while his comment posted correctly, in the moment he wanted, because the tech behind the posting ability was Right.
- Varriount 7y agoNot that I agree 100% with the parent poster, but your argument is flawed. ISPs are only part of the enormous tech stack that is required for the internet to work. The fact that things do work doesn't mean that ISPs are doing everything correctly, not that there isn't reason for complaint or improvement. Just look at the state of the related infrastructure, both technological and political, in the US and elsewhere.
- allovernow 7y agoStatistically most likely from a ≈25-100mb US connection while developed countries the world over have had gigabit for a decade... Our internet is quite a bit behind because telcos in this country don't have to meaningfully compete. Plenty of legislation has cemented their market dominance through artificial (and unnecessary) barriers to entry with practically no accountability for shoddy service and infrastructure. Remember when Verizon received billions in subsidies to bring fiber to NY in the late 00s and ran off with the money with no penalty? https://www.wired.com/story/new-york-city-verizon-internet/ https://www.wired.com/story/new-york-city-verizon-internet/
- orf 7y agoI’m paying the equivalent of $40 p/m for 600mbit download and 100mbit upload in Europe. I don’t think it’s even the best deal I could be getting.
- m-p-3 7y agoAnd of course, RCS is not even end-to-end-encrypted so there is no reason whatsoever to use it over SMS or any other messaging platform. I hope we'll see a good and federated instant-messaging platform that respects privacy and is easy to adopt.
- adzm 7y agoWell, it's still an easier way to share higher resolution images and videos with other non-technical users.
- ViViDboarder 7y agoMost non technical people I know can send emails.
- srgpqt 7y agoSuch as.... email?
- michaelt 7y agoE-mail doesn't have end-to-end encryption either. PGP doesn't count.
- inetknght 7y agoTLS isn't end-to-end encryption?
- juped 7y agoNo. End to end means that plaintext exists only at the two ends (initial sender, final receiver) of a communication.
- capitol_ 7y agoNot in email. End-to-end here means that noone except sender and reciever can read the content. With tls and email you send it to a server which can read it, not to the enduser.
- heavymark 7y agoHard to call it a successor of SMS when have the world uses iOS which does not and currently has no plans to support it. So more just another service rather than a replacement for SMS which is a way for all phones to communicate with each other.
- hocuspocus 7y agoThe world is bigger than the US.
- katbyte 7y agoMore then just people in the US use iPhones?
- tialaramex 7y agoOutside the US the iPhone is not a common choice. It does exist, but most people don't have one. This makes Apple's social lock-in markedly less effective.
- perl4ever 7y agoI don't think most people have iPhones in the US.
- ansgri 7y agoWhile in RoW iPhones are definitely luxury items, by this very property about half (or more) of people whose decisions matter would have one, and you often wouldn’t want to use technology that doesn’t work on your bosses’ phone.
- theelous3 7y agoIs this a troll? You think half of the world's decision makers are in the US?
- Sami_Lehtinen 7y agoI thought MMS. Did someone miss something?
- Jonnax 7y agoTelecoms companies operate with license in the countries they operate. The concept of "lawful intercept" is baked into any product they build, operate or sell. That's just how it works.
- theelous3 7y agoWorked in b2b voip, same there.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- konschubert 7y agoTelcos should focus on being dump pipes and leave the application layer to others. Going into messages or even content is nothing but a rent seeking attempt to exploit a missing net neutrality mandate.
- lucb1e 7y agoI don't really care who sets it up, but since everyone that is currently on facebook chat (be it Messenger or WhatsApp) is also a customer of some mobile carrier, having the carriers create an alternative is not a completely ridiculous idea when we want to make the chat infrastructure distributed/federated. I'd be happy to MMS my uncle if it didn't cost like two euros per 640x480 picture; RCS seems to be the way I'll be able to do that without going through Facebook.
- tus88 7y agoSuccessor according to who?
- egwynn 7y agoAccording to most telcos. It appears to be the next “default” messaging service for (non-Apple) mobile users.
- faitswulff 7y agoFrom the SR Labs post on the topic: > In the second half of 2019, Google and a group of mobile operators started implementing a new communication technology, Rich Communication Services...In June 2019, Google officially announced their plans to push RCS on all Android phones starting with trials being run in UK and France. Fast-forward to November 2019, RCS is being rolled out to all Android users in the US, and operators in other countries are running trials. https://srlabs.de/bites/rcs-hacking/ https://srlabs.de/bites/rcs-hacking/
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- Stubb 7y agoWhy this when applications like Telegram, Signal, etc. already exist? That ship has sailed…
- burpsnard 7y agoThere's arguably a market for commoditised secure messaging/queueing, baked into the standard radio silicon, that's a few steps ahead of sms.. Finance, email, voicemail, etc. P2P.
- Stubb 7y agoI read your comment as "There's arguably a market for compromised messaging/queueing…" And there is by repressive governments every!
- SlowRobotAhead 7y agoTypical headline of a VICE article. “HACKED”... “implemented with errors by some telcos”.
- jeffnappi 7y agoIt's so unfortunate that Google couldn't stay focused and make Hangouts competitive with iMessage. I would guess that the issue stems from Hangouts' legacy code base that harkens back to Google Talk. However, it appears their 3rd(?) attempt to replace it with RCS/Messages is failing once again. Google engineers if you're listening - FIX AND IMPROVE HANGOUTS AND STOP WASTING YOUR EFFORTS ON NEW MESSAGING PROJECTS
- jiqiren 7y agoYou can’t get promoted at Google by maintaining an existing product. Only building a new one. (I’ve heard that over and over from friends that work/worked at google). Yes, this is antidotal...
- deadmutex 7y agoI have seen plenty of people that work on existing products like Chrome, Gmail, etc. get promoted. I also have witnessed people successfully going from L4->L5 as SWEs without launches. I had to see to believe it, and I have seen it. That said, Google is a GIANT company, and other people might have different experiences. Disclosure: I work at Google.
- sieabahlpark 7y agoIt's probably just not as fast as being able to hop diagonally instead of vertically
- zamadatix 7y agoI think it was back in 2013 mobile communication had peaked. In one app (hangouts) I could: sms/mms/IM/phone-call/video-call using my phone, laptop, or some library kiosk browser in private mode. All of this and the notifications went to all of my devices whether or not my physical phone was powered on or connected. On my actual phone Hangouts would also show all of my local messages and I could merge conversations. Voicemails autotranscribed and you could even have them sent as emails to you. SPAM call filtering was built in. IMs could send images/videos. About the only thing it didn't do was send files (had to put it on Google Drive and share the link manually). Now 6 years later there is nobody else (free or paid) that offers what Google offered for free in 2013. Google itself has disabled functionality in Hangouts and put out a deprecation notice. The replacement options have been spread across multiple individual app attempts, some of which have already closed down, none of which actually got to the point of replicating the functionality. Hopefully some service will come along that mimics what I was able to do in 2013, I just hope Google Voice doesn't get gimped before then.