3 ms·
> Quebec's Ministry of Transport says from 2013 to 2017, alcohol-related crashes killed an average of 100 people annually. That's on top of the approximately 22
by bsder 7y ago
> Quebec's Ministry of Transport says from 2013 to 2017, alcohol-related crashes killed an average of 100 people annually. That's on top of the approximately 220 serious injuries and 1,800 minor injuries.
Given these numbers, you can keep cranking the knobs but is that really going to be an effective use of money?
At this point, it looks like the only people left are the really hard cases. And they probably need medical and mental health care more than jail.
Whenever I have contact with DUI stuff in the US, about 1/3 are young, idiotic dipshits who did something egregiously stupid and dangerous and wind up on the straight and narrow after being punished. The other 2/3 are so clearly repeat, hardcore alcoholics that desperately need some form of treatment and are so bad that I wonder how they can even function.
- cf498 7y ago> And they probably need medical and mental health care more than jail. If they dont want help and keep repeating then the second is absolutely needed. The problem isnt that they are addicts and self destructive, but that they carelessly endanger other peoples lives. One would imagine what an apocalyptic outcry it would be if any other drug, that large parts of society consume daily, was found responsible for people starting to kill people in their surroundings. Do you all remember the PCP scare? Or the Spice Horror stories?
- bsder 7y ago> If they dont want help and keep repeating then the second is absolutely needed. Is there anything to suggest that they don't want help or is it that they can't afford help? Alcoholism is not easy to shake off for various physiological reasons (drying out an alcoholic seems to damage your impulse control brain centers, for example). Consequently, treating alcoholism is rather expensive.
- cf498 7y agoFrom my personal experience, not wanting help is rather common. Its a core problem with most drugs and addicts. People have to want to get better or what ever you are trying to help them will fail.