5 ms·
> People can also help by double-checking anybody's licence before lending them their car, said Theresa-Anne Kramer, a spokesperson for MADD Montreal. > The SA
by jrockway 7y ago
> People can also help by double-checking anybody's licence before lending them their car, said Theresa-Anne Kramer, a spokesperson for MADD Montreal.
> The SAAQ says visually checking a driver's licence may not be enough, as a hard copy does not always provide up-to-date information. The agency reminds people that their car could be impounded for 30 days or more if the driver breaks the law.
> For a fee of $1.75, the SAAQ will verify a licence through its website.
> "That would be a wise thing to always do whenever you lend your car, even to your best friend," said Kramer.
> "That person might have kept it secret that they have an alcohol interlock in their own vehicle. Family members might not be aware of it. Friends might not be aware of it."
They want you to pay $1.75 for a single query against a database? That makes AWS prices look cheap.
- gruez 7y agoProbably because usage volume is low, so they have to amortize the fixed costs (eg. payment to the government IT consultants) over a smaller number of requests.
- mdtusz 7y agoThat seems like a weak excuse. The capability needs to exist for SAAQ staff regardless, and something like this can either be implemented as a human service where it's an email request (low volume) or a form on the website. I could be mistaken but I believe it was the SAAQ that had "business hours" for one of their online services where you could only submit a form between 9 and 4 or something ridiculous like that.
- arcticbull 7y agoAeroplan had this until recently too, the website shut down at 9PM PST and re-opened at 6AM PST. Last employee out turn off the servers? What is it about Canadian IT haha.
- fredsted 7y agoLooks like this service has business hours as well. Very strange.
- kaikai 7y agoIt’s an accessibility regulation. If a government website has to be equally accessible to people who are deaf / hard of hearing, blind, etc. then the website can only be live when services for those people are up. There are some sites that rely on humans to provide backup services like filling out forms, and they only work business hours.
- jrockway 7y agoI am not sure volume is going to be low. Won't every car rental have to do this check? Now every time anyone uses a ZipCar or rents a car, it costs an extra $1.75.
- spangry 7y agoI hate it when governments do this, and they seem to do it a lot. The socially optimal price is the marginal cost of providing the service. In this case, the marginal cost is essentially 0 so the search should be free. They're leaving welfare gains on the table by setting such a ridiculous price.
- 3fe9a03ccd14ca5 7y agoUnfortunately, this is one of the most effective methods of discouraging wanton scraping. I’m not sure about the laws in Canada, but aren’t these convictions public domain? Presumably someone could just scrape that and build a free API?
- brandon272 7y ago> Unfortunately, this is one of the most effective methods of discouraging wanton scraping. Maybe they could require you to add (and verify) a credit card and then not charge it for fewer than 30 queries a month. Of course, it's a solution that brings other problems, but it's one way of using payment systems to provide the service and keep it free for everyone but the scrapers.
- emsy 7y agoAsk for name and date of birth. Voila, no scraping.
- distances 7y agoWith the current state of PII leaks, I'm not so sure.
- throwaway40324 7y agoHmm.. hold my, no wait.. take my beer.
- LorenPechtel 7y agoA simple, pretty much unscrapable system: App on your phone that you use to take a picture of the license. The system returns the current status.
- timeimp 7y agoStop spam I would imagine. If you have to pay such a "high" price for the query, then you're not going to enumerate every license combination (unless you had deep pockets)
- novok 7y agoThat is what rate limiting is for. You can also give free queries up to the p95 of usage and then start charging for another example.
- brunoTbear 7y agoTurning everyone into deputies to enforce that their friends not borrow their car seems pretty lousy to me. Reminds me of those felony murder laws, or the laws that punish parents where their children host binge drinking parties without their knowledge.
- cmyr 7y agoThis isn't much different from lending your car to someone without asking if they have a driver's license, period? I mean it's slightly different (I'm not sure if the car is automatically impounded for driving without a license) but I think they're making a big deal out of a fairly minor detail. If your friend borrows your car knowing full well that if they're pulled over it's going to be evaluated... maybe in general a good sign it's time to reevaluate that friendship?
- Tharkun 7y agoAddiction is hard. And some people hide it really well. There are many high functioning alcoholics out there, and you can be sure that many of their friends don't know how bad the situation really is. Letting a visibly drunk person get behind the wheel is obviously a big no no, but there are many shades of grey here. You should not be responsible for other people's failures.
- tomjen3 7y agoThere is a world of a difference between knowing full well that your friend has lost his license and lending him your car after he has shown you a license that is no longer valid. The obvious solution is to never lend your car out to anybody, but that is not the optimal solution.
- paggle 7y agoI for one am a fan of the felony murder law and the laws that punish parents who negligently create opportunities for kids to hurt themselves.
- retrac 7y agoInterestingly, neighbouring Ontario provides the service for free by phone and online.
- onion2k 7y agoThey want you to pay $1.75 for a single query against a database? That makes AWS prices look cheap. They want to set a price that's high enough to stop people invading the privacy of everyone they know for a cheap laugh, but low enough that it won't put people off checking if they're genuinely concerned but also very poor. Making it, say, $5 would cause some people to seriously think whether or not they can afford it.