8 ms·
What Happens if SAT Scores Consider Adversity?
- kdamsfISJF 7y agoWhat happens is that schools will have a harder time avoiding discrimination against white children because they have the misfortune of having law abiding parents and white neighbors.
- alphabettsy 7y agoYour comment implies white neighbors are somehow better and that non-whites don’t have law abiding parents. At least you’re pretty transparent in projecting white victimhood and racism all at the same time.
- planetzero 7y ago"At least you’re pretty transparent in projecting white victimhood and racism all at the same time." The results will be same as what happens now with affirmative action: students get into the university based on inflated scores and then a high percentage drop out/fail out because they can't keep up with the courses. I predict the next step after this is changing courses and making them easier because they somehow reflect 'white culture' and are 'racist'. This doesn't help the affected communities, makes our educational institutions worthless, and only serves to help politicians get votes and make liberals feel better about themselves.
- sieabahlpark 7y agoHave you actually lived in an area with underprivileged families? They truly don't care about their children. Sure, some do, the idealized version everyone thinks about do. The reality is a bunch of entitled adults or single parents who send their kid to school without jackets in the winter but come into PTA meetings (if they show up at all) are wearing $250 shoes and driving a Mercedes.
- skinnymuch 7y agoWhy did you specify white? Are they superior in the metrics you deem as best?
- forgotmypwd123 7y agoWhat's happens to the title?
- dang 7y agoFixed now.
- pcurve 7y agoSome schools already consider geographically correlated socio-economic background into evaluation criteria. It's not really up to college board to decide this, though I'm sure they have sizable empirical data. I'm afraid it will just be one more way for unscrupulous people to game the system.
- mywacaday 7y agoAre there any studies post college to see if there is any correlation between adverse backgrounds and success post college?
- kevindong 7y agoThe NY Times has something similar to what you (see the very bottom of the page): https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2018/03/27/upshot/make-your-own-mobility-animation.html https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2018/03/27/upshot/make-y... That graphic lets you compare and contrast between various gender/race and their income mobility.
- pcurve 7y agogood lord, the downward draft for black folks are hard.
- nkkollaw 7y agoIs adversity always bad? Many times adversity creates more motivated people. That's why so many successful companies are created by smart immigrants, and many times spoiled rich kids do drugs and end up losing all the money they inherit. Regardless, when we stop looking at merit to judge people's work, we get into a very dangerous territory. Identity politics is cancer.
- alphabettsy 7y agoThe problem is that average poor and middle-class kids don’t make it into college at anywhere near the rates wealthy kids do and it has almost nothing to do with their capability. There are a lot of capable people that will never have the same opportunities just by lottery of birth. It’s true they could try to be exceptional, but everyone can’t be and that’s a ridiculous way to attack poverty.
- OCASM 7y agoCollege education isn't the only way to escape poverty. Trade schools are a thing, for example.
- ccsnags 7y agoThis is how I started. I became a master technician in multiple fields learning under journeyman and master techs, found a well paying job and went to school on my employers dime. Zero debt. Technical positions requiring trade schools (or often just practical knowledge and a will to learn) pay better than many positions that require a university education.
- cobookman 7y agoSocioeconomic mobility doesn’t happen overnight. Maybe the poor kid goes to a trade school moving up from poor to upper middle class. The kid of said person would have a better start...repeat the cycle and after just 2-3 generations you have a Harvard/Stanford graduate This is how many Jews and Asians moved up from being broke poor
- tachyonbeam 7y agoI hope that this isn't hinting at boosting SAT scores based on such a measure, because the obvious problem here is that you can't possibly objectively measure how much adversity a child was exposed to. Some schools are poorer than others, that's for sure, but some of the kids from rich schools are queer, getting bullied, or getting chronically abused by alcoholic or mentally ill parents at home. There's a lot of suffering out there that is not visible, not spoken about, and not identified by race, place of birth or skin color. IMO, the best way to avoid issues like this would be to ban private schools, and make sure all schools have the same amount of funding per student. In other words, target the poverty problem directly, don't try to adjust SAT scores based on some guestimate of how oppressed you think a person might have been.
- OCASM 7y agoNo, communism isn't the answer. Some people having an edge over others is not an issue in the first place.
- tachyonbeam 7y agoI believe that it's useful to have capitalistic motivations to motivate people to perform. You should be able to start a business and get outsized returns if you take risks and succeed. However, I also believe in equal opportunities, and giving kids a more equal start.
- friedman23 7y agoWe could easily give kids an equal start if we mentally handicap them all at birth.
- ownagefool 7y agoSure, but it'd also be easier to just provider decent nutrition at school, to ensure it's actually happening, irregardless of whether the parents are rich or not. Disclaimer: I'm Scottish/European; we have different cultural thoughts on these issues
- CapmCrackaWaka 7y agoI work in this space, and this study is getting a lot of attention. At the end of the day, colleges don't care. They have their pell eligibility quotas, their ethnicity ratio considerations, net tuition revenue requirements, etc etc. Their objective is to maximize their reputation - if they find students with lower SAT scores from poorer neighborhoods become more successful in their careers and donate more money/become notable figures/contribute more to academic research, that's who they will admit (given the profitability with financial aid and federal incentives). Colleges aren't going to change anything based on this study, however it does enrage the wealthy white families and rally the poor black ones with the topic of racial/financial adversity, so it's bound to get a lot of attention.
- remarkEon 7y agoI think you’re right, universities are reputation maximizers - but so are parents and students, and I’m not so sure they think of the university as another rational actor in the same vein as themselves. The more I think about it the more I’m starting to believe that the only winning move is not to play.
- sabujp 7y agodepends on what you're trying to become, if you want to be a doctor it's still required
- GhettoMaestro 7y ago> [...]their ethnicity ratio considerations [...] I really hate coded language like this. Call it what it is: race-based social engineering. Yeah, it doesn't sound as "nice", right? Something to ponder deeply.
- hyperbovine 7y ago> Call it what it is: race-based social engineering. Race-based social engineering, aka racism, has been a thing for as long as society has existed. Not exactly a new concept. This is a small attempt to right thousands of years of injustice.
- remarkEon 7y agoInteresting plots. What would actually happen though is that anxious elites would attempt to game the adversity system, doing things like maintaining an address in a “distressed” neighborhood for how ever long it takes to matter. The moral-ethical considerations aside (we’re actually going to punish or reward the children for the decisions the parents make?), this is just going to be abused. I’m skeptical it would even work as intended. Putting students into schools that they’re not academically prepared to be at because they had a rough time growing up sounds like setting them up for continued failure. I also didn’t know UC was considering dropping the SAT all together. You know who will be the loudest cheerleaders for that? The same anxious elites that would move to a crappy neighborhood to boost their kid’s SAT score. Dropping the closest proxy we have for future academic performance (and a darn good one at that) would make everyone run for the side-door entrances to these institutions - and the back door will get a lot more lucrative. What a shame.
- SolaceQuantum 7y ago" Dropping the closest proxy we have for future academic performance (and a darn good one at that)" I'm actually super not educated in this- do you have proof that good SAT score is a strong predictor of good academic performance, and vice versa? (The vice versa is the most important part to me.)
- alistairSH 7y agoThere's a loose correlation between SAT and college grades. There's also a correlation between parents income and college grades. And several other things. The common thread - they're almost all related to socio-economic status - the more educated and wealthy the parents, the more successful the student, on average.
- polski-g 7y agoSAT is a proxy for IQ, which is a good predictor for life success, and that includes academic performance.
- 7y ago
- tobib 7y agoOff topic, I'm wondering, do people on here tend to have subscriptions to sites like wsj.com that are behind a paywall or is there a known way to get past it without one that I just don't know about?
- gnicholas 7y agoThese days, twitter seems like a reliable way in. Just search the article url.