4 ms·
I find interesting that while the "right to be forgotten" does not prevent the person from being named, all the articles I have found on Google are careful not
by mytailorisrich 7y ago
I find interesting that while the "right to be forgotten" does not prevent the person from being named, all the articles I have found on Google are careful not to name him (and I'm not talking about German articles, but articles in English from non-German sources).
This strikes me as self-censorship.
As an aside, it's also interesting that a person sentenced to life for murdering two people in 1982 was freed in 2002...
- kstenerud 7y ago"Life" in Germany typically means between 15 and 25 years (and there's no such thing as stacking life sentences). Nobody is ever kept permanently incarcerated except for very very very extreme circumstances where they are considered still dangerous, and must be kept in a separate facility that's technically not a prison sentence. The goal of the justice system in Germany is reform, not retribution. The "self-censorship" is done out of respect for the spirit of the law.
- Tomte 7y agoYour comment is basically correct, let me add a little correction: You're talking about "Sicherungsverwahrung", which has indeed that effect, but a regular life sentence without Sicherungsverwahrung can also be indefinitely long, until the person dies. There are also perodical checks whether the prisoner is still a danger to society or whether he can be released, but it is possible to stay in regular prison without Sicherungsverwahrung forever.
- mytailorisrich 7y ago> The "self-censorship" is done out of respect for the spirit of the law. Or fear of being dropped by the search engines?
- Kbelicius 7y agoThe article would be dropped from the search engines, not the publishers...
- bloak 7y agoWhat if he has a really common name? What if he has a rare name that happens to be shared with one other person? I don't think naming people online is a good idea any more.
- aliceryhl 7y agoA life sentence is rarely truly a life sentence in western countries.
- glotgizmo 7y agoThis is correct for the UK, however we do have something called a Whole-Life Order [0] [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_prisoners_with_whole-life_orders https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_prisoners_with_whole-l...
- mytailorisrich 7y agoThis is because of the European Court of Human Rights that prevents courts from handing hard life sentences. There must be a point when prisoners have to become eligible for parole and have the possibility of being released. The UK has had issues about this and has had to find a way to adapt: Whole-life ordesr have to be reviewed after some time in order to give a chance of release (at least on paper). For the same reason, e.g. in France life sentences come with a maximum of 30 years before becoming eligible for parole. What they do is then that they simply keep denying parole for prisoners they want to keep inside.
- jeremyfranco 7y agoexcept US, that on this matter are very far from the western culture and Cesare Beccaria's writings.
- larnmar 7y agoSo why do courts keep lying to people? Why not just be honest about sentences?
- NeedMoreTea 7y agoIt's not a lie, it's a life sentence, with early release granted by parole. They remain on a parole licence the rest of their life. A whole life tariff, i.e. imprisoned for the rest of their natural life is very, very rare and saved for the most extreme cases. That's the UK context, but most of Europe seems to operate similarly.
- atoav 7y agoThis is btw. normal procedure in Germany, culpits are usually not named, with the exception of boulevard media thinking they have to break that rule in some cases. If a name is printed it is usually shortened to hide the identity of the suspect (e.g. Franz M.) This probably has its roots in the past, with Nazi lynchings were justice was just skipped and people thought they had to carry out a sentence themselves. Although I understand the emotional conflict that arises from situations like these, it gives me actually confidence in the justice system of the nation I currently live in: if they even defend the rights of a murderer, this indicates they will also take the privacy of everybody else seriously. Edit: I also don’t feel I need to know whether e.g. my neighbour served a prison sentence — the goal of german prisons is rehabilitation and they are actually not bad at that.
- blue_devil 7y ago>>it gives me actually confidence in the justice system of the nation I currently live in: if they even defend the rights of a murderer, this indicates they will also take the privacy of everybody else seriously. He murdered people on a yacht - maybe he's rich? At least an alternative explanation for why his case was honoured by the highest court. Suing in Europe is pricey and time-consuming, so I would not say your privacy would be taken seriously "by default" so to say.
- albertgoeswoof 7y agoLife means a Life sentence, as in you are never free. That does not mean you spend the rest of your life inside a prison. This murderer will still be under supervision until they die, will have particular restrictions about how they live their life, and will be recalled to a prison for almost any minor offence. However the parole board will have made a decision that they are unlikely to offend again and so it is better for society, the taxpayer (and the individual) to allow them to live outside of the prison walls,
- larnmar 7y agoWhat’s even odder is that nobody in this thread has named him (or else HN has also decided to censor itself to comply with a barbaric German law that has no bearing whatsoever on HN). The man’s name is Paul Termann, and fuck the German Government for thinking that it had the right to try to cover up his crimes. I’m sure the families of the people he murdered have never forgotten about him so I don’t see why we should either. Proposal: temporarily rename the Streisand Effect to the Paul Termann effect.
- bildung 7y agoWhat you are effectively proposing is an abandonment of seperation of powers, a cornerstone of a free society. Seperation of powers also means it not up to you to decide when an offender has finished serving his/her sentence.
- geek_at 7y agoIn Germany and most of Europe actually you get a life sentence for murder. Life sentence is 20 years, (a bit less if you show remorse). Unless you are deemed criminally insane then you won't come out maybe ever. Also in the EU the name of criminals are usually not printed or published in any other way unless it's a big thing like murder of multiple people or massive fraud. Tabloids sometimes do print the names but usually only with the first letter of their last name
- mytailorisrich 7y ago> Also in the EU the name of criminals are usually not printed or published That is not true at all. Criminal trials are public and people are fully named in the media in many countries unless there is a specific court order against it (which I have never heard off except for minors). (Germany is not the EU)
- jonathanstrange 7y agoIt's part of a voluntary press codex - or, better to say, an interpretation thereof - to not fully name suspects of crimes. Every reputable newspaper adheres to it and even a few less reputable ones, but the yellow press/tabloids don't.
- Cthulhu_ 7y agoBeing a suspect or convict of a crime does not mean you forfeit the right to privacy. We are better than that.