8 ms·
India considers commissions cap for Uber, Ola, unsettling industry
- Mengkudulangsat 7y agoWhy would it be "... another blow" ? Isn't this fantastic news for Uber? Since it applies to everyone equally, this signals the end of the race to the bottom between the aggregators. Any lost of income can just be mitigated by raising headline fares. Since most drivers are on all apps at once, they will take the job that post the highest fares.
- hiyer 7y agoIn many Indian cities the maximum fare is also fixed by the government. Uber/Ola make money only from the commission. They attract drivers not with higher fares but with various reward schemes - e.g. complete X rides within Y time to get a bonus of Rs. Z.
- hiyer 7y agoThis is a welcome move. For short, small-value rides like with auto-rickshaws, Uber and Ola's commission can be close to 100% or even more. You can travel (slightly) cheaper by negotiating with the famously fleecing rickshaw drivers themselves.
- nindalf 7y ago> famously fleecing Fleecing who? Natives would never pay more than a dollar or two for a short ride, and never more than 10-20% more than the “fair” value. It’s even better in places like Mumbai, where everyone uses a standard meter. Tourists would pay 10x but in my experience they don’t even notice or care they’re getting fleeced because $10 for a short (5-6km) trip is a reasonable price to them.
- simula67 7y agoIt is not OK to fleece anyone 'because they are tourists'. EDIT: Removed rant
- nindalf 7y agoPlease show me the tourist who had a problem paying $10 for a ride across town. It’s a rounding error for people used to paying 2-3x that rate normally. I have probably taken rickshaws as much as you have but I don’t share your contempt for them. They’re doing a difficult job and they’re charging very little for it. You complain so much about their attitude but do you complain about the customer who refuses to pay more than what they paid 5 years ago, as if inflation didn’t exist.
- looping__lui 7y agoThat is a pretty arrogant and very Indian thing to say. 1) It’s not tourists or foreigners taking advantage of other Indians - it is Indians. Indian people disrespect and mistreat each other to an extend I have never seen anywhere else in the world. 2) It is not tourists who set the prices for taxi meters - it’s the Indian cities or governments; yet it is Indian cab drivers who often believe they stand above the Law and can take advantage of tourists because “they can afford it” 3) Nobody argues about rickshaws not doing a difficult job and I NEVER heard a tourist complain about the prices of rickshaw dwellers - only fellow Indians 4) It’s not tourists but Indians that pretend inflation doesn’t exist; tourists generally overpay Yes, we “rich foreign tourists” can afford to pay 10USD for a ride across town; but it’s not the same deal as riding in an actually safe vehicle with seatbelts and a driver passing an actual driving license in Europe or the US; taking these aspects into account the 10 USD trips are a rip off Yes, countries can continue to take advantage of tourists, squeeze them as much as they can and justify that with the “they can afford it”. I will never travel to India again unless I HAVE to for business purposes - because I am just tired of it. There are a million cleaner places on earth - with people being more honest. Yes, in other Asian countries people also haggle - but at least they take care of their environment. You know, people that believe that “taking advantage of foreigners is ok because they have the money” aren’t exactly contributing to the reputation of a country. What’s left? Treat everybody with respect - and good stuff will happen.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- thrwe4234safd 7y ago> Natives would never pay more than a dollar or two for a short ride, and never more than 10-20% more than the “fair” value. It’s even better in places like Mumbai, where everyone uses a standard meter. Please. Autowallahs have their own versions of "surge pricing", which is even more frustrating and non-transparent. Night time ? Triple rate. Going to a residential area ? Double rate, because the vehicle need to return empty.
- pritambaral 7y agoNot in Mumbai. Source: I'm a resident.
- thrwe4234safd 7y agoAh Mumbai, the place where taxis wait under the noses of policemen at the domestic arrival gate, only so that they can pick up unsuspecting idiots and then fleece them of 5-10000 Rs for the privilege of taking them to the International departure gate (or for a lower fee after just 100 m). Little wonder everyone is advised to use prepaid taxis in India. I've been told by various sources that this the development of the petty "anti-capitalist" politics that dominated India since its supposed independence.
- foogazi 7y agoJust experienced what the lack of app based surge pricing does. After exiting a major sporting event I expected the streets to be swarmed by taxis - easy money for them But there was no incentive, nothing to tell the city’s drivers to show up en-masse. They would just earn the same city base fare Thousands of people either had to walk or wait in line at the crowded metro station
- TeMPOraL 7y agoI'm guessing the regular people in the city were very happy that they didn't experience sudden shortage of taxis, coupled with an extreme surge in price. Meanwhile, the spectators from the sport event were incentivized to choose the more efficient means of transport. Looking at it from the systems level, I'm not at all convinced that when a mass event spikes the demand for taxis, having drivers go to that event chasing profit is a good idea. Imagine half the plasma in your body moving to your digestive tract the second you eat something. I think from the city's perspective, it's better to have taxis minimize variance than maximize profit.
- SeanDav 7y ago> Imagine half the plasma in your body moving to your digestive tract the second you eat something Actually this is not too far from what really happens soon after you eat a big meal. The blood flow to the stomach-related arteries greatly increases soon after a meal (not sure on actual number for "greatly"). I tend to agree with your main point in any case.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- dpiers 7y agoThat’s not exactly how it works. The primary function of surge isn’t to redistribute a fixed pool of drivers - it’s to incentivize additional drivers to go online in an area with excess demand. For example, it used to be that surge would spike insanely high on big days like Halloween and New Years Eve because demand was drastically higher than supply. Once drivers saw other people making 8-10x surge, more people started signing on at these peak times and average surge went down.
- rataata_jr 7y agoWe'll seems like Indians don't deserve nice things.
- puranjay 7y agoI can't see any situation where Uber retains its current volume if it increases its prices. I'm not a particularly price sensitive customer, yet I find myself taking auto rickshaws more and more. The gap between their fares and Uber are becoming a little to unjustifiable. I'm comfortable with an Uber being 1.5-2x more than an auto, but fares these days are often 2.5-4x higher. My Uber usage is now reserved mostly for edge cases - going to the airport, going home after a night out, bad weather conditions
- olcor 7y agoI usually take an Uber only when I know that it’s price is going to be cheaper than a taxi, when public transport is inconvenient, and when time isn’t an issue (prices are sometimes at a 10-15% discount to black-and-yellow taxis at non-peak hours). Uber/Ola has slotted itself as more of a nice transport option than a necessity. That’s a good deal for me, all things considered. Hopefully it stays that way.
- gtyras2mrs 7y agoI use Uber for almost all my transport needs, despite my own concerns about how Uber operates. Despite the higher surge prices. My issue with using auto rickshaws are two-fold. The first is comfort and safety. Rickshaw rides just feel crap and I can never feel safe enough to just wear earphones and relax. The second is integrity. I don’t mind paying more. But there have been 3 auto rides out of my last five where drivers ask for one amount drive halfway there and demand 2x. I don’t know if it’s because I’m not a local or if I just look vulnerable. I just feel like I’m being used.
- sumgame 7y agoIf you do the math in India, the drivers were basically not earning any money last year. They spend about 30% of their income of debt. Another 30-40% on fuel and maintenance cost. Then 20% charged by Ola and Uber. There’s other miscellaneous fees that creep up plus insurance every year which atleast takes another 10%. So they take home around 10%. That 10% has to pay for food, rent, children’s education, etc. The argument can be that they’re technically taking home 40% if you take their debt payments that’s paying for an asset. But a car is a depreciating asset, so after 5 years they’ll technically have lost 50% of that money. The 10% decrease in fees would go a long way for these drivers. I’ve spoken to a lot of them and it’s really sad what’s happened. You may ask why did they join in the first place ? They were attracted to these services by glamorous stories of cab drivers making 1500-2000$ a month on these apps. But all fo that income was funded by inorganic incentives that never fit into the unit economics. It was basically VC funding that was channelled into a few drivers income, which then brought in a lot more. I feel strongly about this as I’ve spoken to multiple drivers who make very little money and work about 12-14 hours a day. You can see a lot of them just sleep in the car in the night to make sure they can make ends meet. On the other side, they’ve stopped heavily discounting the rides at the consumers end, which means demand has decreased because they had artificially inflated demand by providing a service at discounted prices. So that means drivers don’t get as many rides either. It’s basically a double whammy for the driver. Aggregators charging 20% of the ride costs is just unempathetic and stupid if they actually did the math. But obviously they’ll have to recoup all the VC money they’ve invested. It baffled me for a long that the unit economic never made sense for the longest time. They took no fees, they gave discounts and they attracted drivers by inspiring them of glamourous stories where cab drivers were making more than most employees in India. Most cab drivers who saw this as a gold rush, took on a lot of debt to buy a car and drive people around. With time they’ve realised it’s all a sham but there’s nothing they can do about it. They’ve already committed to the debt, and if they stopped paying it, they’ll loose the car, which is all they have as assets.
- throwGuardian 7y agoIf this were true, drives would quit en-mass. This is entirely an at-will engagement, any party can back out at any time if things don't work out
- modi15 7y agoRidiculous meddling by the government. There are a zillion ways to circumvent this ruling - each of which are easier done by big guys rather than smaller startups. The only thing all this meddling ends up doing is making the space hard for startups to start in and increasing the cost of business.
- django1993 7y agoA startup that keeps eating more and more money like a blackhole without emitting a single penny of profit.
- sifar 7y agoTotally unrelated to the finance minister blaming increasing ride sharing usage to the slump in the Auto sector sales :) [1]. Really myopic. Yes Uber/Ola overcharge and don't pay the drivers enough, after enticing them with offers and getting them in debt. But Uber had done this in the US and shouldn't have been a surprise. The so-called fleecing, arrogant auto rickshaw is more resilient, can navigate the traffic better. [1] https://www.telegraphindia.com/india/nirmala-sitharaman-blame-it-on-uber-ola-mindset-too/cid/1704039 https://www.telegraphindia.com/india/nirmala-sitharaman-blam...
- throwGuardian 7y agoDisagree with this move. Uber & co. have been a net positive to the country, people and the economy. After pouring billions into creating and proving a market, the government is baselessly capping their earnings. Here's a fair proposal: 1. Encourage competitors and allow the free market to set prices and revenue shares. A vendor undercutting prices will get higher ridership 2. Prevent price gouging via collusion - do not let the companies cartel up 3. Limiting surge pricing to 2X is the only reasonable policy in their proposal After all, every stakeholder in this vertical is an at-will participant, with no compulsion to stay if the economics do not work out
- yipbub 7y ago> After all, every stakeholder in this vertical is an at-will participant, with no compulsion to stay if the economics do not work out That's not true. There are only 2 aggregators to choose from. Staying off one is not a feasible option for most. > the government is baselessly capping their earnings. They are not capping earning, they are capping percentage of fares. The cab driver puts in most of the cost. > Encourage competitors and allow the free market to set prices and revenue shares. A vendor undercutting prices will get higher ridership How? A company trying to enter this market would have a loong cash burn ahead of it with no certainty of a profit. Like social media, there's an inertia to users platform switching.
- ReptileMan 7y agoI don't know. With the Ubers you don't have the network effects as strongly. As long as the ride if safe, you will pick up the cheapest for given comfort level and be done with it. Cost of switching for the user is 0. And cost of switching for drivers is probably not high since any serfdom agreement for freelancers can be struck down as invalid.
- yipbub 7y agoWhat I mean is that it's very hard for any new company to compete. It's also a very bad bet for any VC to back them.
- say_it_as_it_is 7y agoThis is how regulators wind up securing established companies. Capping commission rates favors Uber because Uber already has the infrastructure and resources at its disposal so that it may afford earning less, cutting head count as necessary, where as entrepreneurs who want to compete with Uber don't. They have many more mountains to climb and less opportunity once they've reached the market. India is essentially planning on fortifying Uber's position. Well done. Mission accomplished, lobbyists. Go long on Uber stock.
- badestrand 7y agoIt's a business with a very low barrier of entry. Same like food order platforms, both will have new players enter the market. If anything, the cap is dangerous for Uber as they have very high fixed operating costs, compared to a startup.
- Gys 7y agoRegulation is always beneficial to esthablished companies. GDPR, European VAT rules, data security, encryption requirements, etc. In the end all this just makes it harder for newcomers. Existing companies only need to adapt, newcomers need to comply (spend more time and money), before they even can enter the market and start competing. Having a better position for future regulation is another benefit for being a first mover advantage.
- paulsutter 7y agoThis is a way better help to drivers than forcing them to become employees. Uber used to charge a flat 20% but now optimized to squeeze out as high a percentage as they can take. This is the real problem for drivers. Not employee / contractor It’s unions pushing to force drivers to be employees, not drivers.
- rrrazdan 7y agoI see lots of people assuming that the drivers are in a debt trap. Its auto debt. They can just default and go home. The bank will take their car. I have talked to multiple Uber/Ola drivers. Sure the economics aren't as good now. But they are still better than alternatives. That's the sad truth. Unless people can get them better jobs, Uber/Ola will have to do.
- llampx 7y agoIts India. They might get a few broken limbs in the repo process. Its not as easy as you make it sound to walk out on a loan.
- rrrazdan 7y agoI live in India so I don’t understand what you mean by “Its India”. No nationalized bank( majority of auto loans) will use a coercive process. Hell no private bank will use one. RBI has clamped on that practice as illegal in 2010. Worse case is the bank repos the car and auctions it.
- jariel 7y agoGiven the massive power imbalance in this situation, margin regulation may have to be in place in order for this to work in the long run. The owner/driver imbalance pales in comparison to massive, multinational/driver.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- oceanboy81 7y agoPeople like Masayoshi Son are gonna lose the shirts off their back.