3 ms·
> It didn't sound like that's what you were pointing out, at all. Sorry. I'll try to do better. > This makes it sound like the mushroom is little more than a
by carapace 7y ago
> It didn't sound like that's what you were pointing out, at all.
Sorry. I'll try to do better.
> This makes it sound like the mushroom is little more than a placebo.
Yeah, kind of. It has an effect, that's undeniable, but whether that effect results in a therapeutic outcome or a bad trip or just a fun time is not due the chemical. It's not like e.g. aspirin for headaches (FWIW that's still pretty mysterious too, but at least it's consistent.) The result of taking psilocybin depends on the "set and setting" (and a lot of other factors no doubt.)
> Can go wrong? Sure, so should be used with caution, like anything else powerful.
Look this is weird for me to say but no, I object to the normalization of getting high as a way to treat depression. There are other methods that are effective and safe.
> Are the insights and healing similar?
> Is the amount of effort similar?
> Is the likelihood of receiving insights similar?
> Is there trustworthy evidence suggesting high risk (likelihood and magnitude) of risk with psilocybin, and trustworthy evidence that there is lesser risk with <x>?
> I feel fairly certain the answer to most of these questions is something like: "We don't know, for sure, because there is very little evidence outside of anecdotal stories."
One of the strange and frustrating things is that every kind of healing modality with which I have personal experience (including Reiki, Feldenkrais, NLP, EFT, hypnosis, and others), every one of them is somehow "unreproducible" by at least some mainstream scientists, to put it mildly:
> Reiki is a pseudoscience,[1] and is used as an illustrative example of pseudoscience in scholarly texts and academic journal articles.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reiki https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reiki
> There is no good medical evidence that the Feldenkrais method confers any health benefits. It is not known if it is safe or cost-effective,[2] but researchers do not believe it poses serious risks.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Feldenkrais_Method https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Feldenkrais_Method
> There is no scientific evidence supporting the claims made by NLP advocates and it has been discredited as a pseudoscience.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Neuro-linguistic_programming https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Neuro-linguistic_programming
> EFT has no benefit as a therapy beyond the placebo effect or any known-effective psychological techniques that may be provided in addition to the purported "energy" technique.[3] It is generally characterized as pseudoscience and it has not garnered significant support in clinical psychology.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Emotional_Freedom_Techniques https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Emotional_Freedom_Techniques
> The use of hypnosis in other contexts, such as a form of therapy to retrieve and integrate early trauma, is controversial within the medical or psychological mainstream.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hypnosis https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hypnosis
And so on.
I know from personal experience that the five things I just mentioned are pretty profound healing modalities. I have some theories, but really I don't know why science can't verify this stuff (at least so far.)
- mistermann 7y ago> Yeah, kind of. It has an effect, that's undeniable, but whether that effect results in a therapeutic outcome or a bad trip or just a fun time is not due the chemical. It's not like e.g. aspirin for headaches (FWIW that's still pretty mysterious too, but at least it's consistent.) Agreed, somewhat. It's not due just to the chemical. BUT, it doesn't necessarily follow that: > The result of taking psilocybin depends [primarily] on the "set and setting" (and a lot of other factors no doubt.) Set and setting is undoubtedly important, and it's possible that they are paramount, but I see little evidence to believe this is the case and that similar (see above) results can be practically achieved with alternative approaches, and much that contradicts it. But to be clear, at a bare minimum one needs to be sitting in a quiet, (preferably) dark room, not at a rave. This much seems obviously true, and in line with what you're saying. I think where we agree is that a certain state of mind MUST be achieved in order for the magic to occur. Where we differ is how (the various ways in which) that can be achieved, and to what degree, in reality (which for us to know, would require substantial study, that has yet to take place). > Look this is weird for me to say but no, I object to the normalization of getting high as a way to treat depression. There are other methods that are effective and safe. Agreed, if you word it like that, but I don't think that's a fair wording. Just "getting high" isn't the only option. > One of the strange and frustrating things is that every kind of healing modality with which I have personal experience (including Reiki, Feldenkrais, NLP, EFT, hypnosis, and others), every one of them is somehow "unreproducible" by at least some mainstream scientists, to put it mildly I intensely share your frustration with the excessively scientific materialist style of thinking that comes up with these "unreproducible therefore it's false pronouncements. We need to get everything down on paper and start sorting it out, and then form opinions. And this applies to everything, not just psychedelics. If only people could figure out this incredibly simple idea. You know, I wish more people were able to have reasonable conversations like you, imagine how wonderful the world could be if a way could be found to recognize and spread this character trait.
- carapace 7y agoYou're too kind. :-) I appreciate your conversation and reasonableness too. And I agree with you, > We need to get everything down on paper and start sorting it out, and then form opinions. And this applies to everything, not just psychedelics. If only people could figure out this incredibly simple idea. I like to think we're getting there, but only time will tell, eh? Warm regards